Software
Houzz Logo Print
mtnrdredux_gw

"Rash guards" - sun protection

8 years ago

So we are headed to Tulum later this month. This will involve a good amount of snorkeling in cenotes and open water, swimming w turtles, etc. Prime sunburn activities for my pale New England family. Moreover, many places only allow biodegradable suntan lotion, which I hear does not work terribly well.

So I am loading up on rashguards. I found ones I like for me that look just like a hoodie and zip up; much easier to take on and off. This one is even made longer to provide additional protection.

But doesn't it look odd? I think it looks like its for spring skiiing, LOL. What do you wear to protect yourself from sun?


Comments (41)

  • 8 years ago

    I’ve never had a need for a rash guard - just use sunscreen. I see a lot of them for sale these days though. I have a hard time imagining myself putting on a skin tight long sleeve synthetic shirt in blazing hot, humid weather.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked 3katz4me
  • 8 years ago

    I don’t think it necessarily looks odd but I would be hot in something that came down that low. Since it is fitted, I think I’d prefer something that hit no lower than my hips so it didn’t overlap too much with my bottoms.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked 4kids4us
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I agree the long sleeve shirts are very common; I just wasn't sure if this thing went too far .. it might even be hot. Hmm, a lighter color might be a good idea.

    This is fine

    This is almost a wetsuit


    lighter color --- it occurs to me these are not shown w bathing suits; that might be throwing me

  • 8 years ago

    I didn't find mine hot at all especially if I went in the water

  • 8 years ago

    Ok, so maybe since this is for stand up paddleboarding, people do that a lot in colder climes. But here they show it on a boat in warm weather, presumably a swim suit under it. I think it looks fine, but I will prob go w the grey.

  • 8 years ago

    3katz -- the sunscreen issue is as follows. To protect the animals and reef, they have gotten very strict about sunscreen lotion (and I don't blame them and I will honor it). I read that it must be biodegradable, but that some biodegradable products still have things in them that make them unacceptable. So it will be hard to buy in advance, I worry a bit about exactly what we will get and if it will work. One severe sunburn is enough to change your skin cancer risk.

  • 8 years ago

    I wear long sleeve rash guards everytime I swim outside. I worked for a dermatologist briefly in my twenties and it left a lasting impression. My kids have always worn rashguards when swimming--it is such a part of their routine that they even wear them when swimming indoors. I actually prefer a rashguard that pulls over my head--never liked the idea of swimming in a jacket with the stiff zipper on the front.


    I have never found rashguards to be particularly hot. I actually get in the water so mine is most often wet.


    I suggest taking a look at Athleta and title 9 for rashguards. I might also look at coolibar--but I don't have any personal experience with their products.


    For coral safe sunscreen, maybe research badger. It has worked well for us and this source says it is coral reef "safe."


    http://www.tropicalsnorkeling.com/best-snorkeling-sunscreen.html


    I think I would do my research and take sunscreen that seems like it would work and be prepared to buy more on site if necessary.



    mtnrdredux_gw thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 8 years ago

    I use the ones from Lands End. They work great.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked 1929Spanish-GW
  • 8 years ago

    Try Cabana Life

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked theclose
  • 8 years ago

    I don’t think the pic of it with her on the boat looks odd at all The cenotes are freezing anyways you’ll be glad of it when you’re in them. The hood will be nice to cover your neck and head. Putting on goggles should be easier too I’d think

    We were in tulum end of March last year. I don’t remember seeing biodegradable sunscreen for sale there but I wasn’t looking for it.

  • 8 years ago

    I always wear rash guards too when on vacation in sunny climes, but only while in the water. The only quibble I have with the one you originally posted is with the hood. (I don’t usually care about color as long as the fit is good.) Seems like the good would get in the way while swimming or snorkeling. The only way it would work with a mask is if it’s extremely snug, like a wet suit. We have vacationed a number of times on tropical beaches and I’ve never seen one with a hood, so that must be a relatively new feature.

  • 8 years ago

    Daisy --- did you go to CI when you were in Tulum? I am trying to decide if it is worth it... long drive and so heavily touristed... plus we've seen similar elsewhere. I was planning a Valladolid day trip and seeing lesser and quieter sites along the way.

    Also people say Gran Cenote is overrun and Casa Cenote is better?

    Would love any other thought/suggestions you have, thx!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Mtn, we hired a driver and did a day trip to Casa Cenote, Solomon Bay for lunch and relaxing and another big cave cenote further back in the jungle. We are really low key travellers and don't go for crowds either. Casa Cenote was beautiful but small - very basic. A couple of guys with a card table set up renting snorkelling gear and life jackets. We went early in the day and there were maybe 15 people there.

    When my DH wakes up, I'll see if he remembers the name of the bigger cave Cenote we went to. It was a new operation with nice facilities and lots of rental gear. I am slightly claustrophobic so I opted out of doing the whole tour (you had to swim thru a very short but narrow entry and I couldn't do it), but my family really enjoyed it. You rent a guide to go with you thru the caves.

    We did not go to Chichen Itza. I backpacked through Mexico and Guatamala as a young adult and it was horrendous even then. We went to Tulum ruins last year and found the same thing. We could not see past the tourists. Literally, shoulder to shoulder. I would highly recommend doing a less touristy ruin if you want to see that sort of thing.

    Didn't do Valladolid, but we did a trip to Merida a couple of years ago (loved it there - they call it the Paris of Mexico) and did a day trip to Uxmal (and some cenotes). Hired a private guide when we arrived, just a few other small groups there. IIRC, the family we were staying with said that Valladolid was similar.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked daisychain Zn3b
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I burn very easily, so I finally bought a rash guard. It provides a lot of peace of mind for me, otherwise I have to apply every 15-30 min. I got sun poisoning a few times as a child... once in México when I was 8. :( Mine is just a long-sleeve T-shirt style. I think anything with zippers would be too much. Side note... I went to Tulum years ago and they did sell the biodegradable sunscreen, but that was 16 years ago! My mom lived in Mérida for 6 yrs. so we went back to the area to visit. I wish I could take her again. Have fun!

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked anele_gw
  • 8 years ago

    Super, Daisy, thanks. Wish I were sleeping late too but I got up early to check in on relatives without power!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I use rash guards here in Texas for swimming and hanging around the pool. Mine are all light colored as the sun on anything dark really gives a burning feeling. I also stay away with anything with zippers or grommets and other metal as it gets too hot as well when out in the sun. For swimming with it on I prefer it to be form fitting as it is annoying with it twisting and floating and creating bubbles or moving up and around so skin gets exposed. I prefer it to stay where it is when I'm on land. Only way I've found that's happening is with a more skin tight one. Note mine are not super tight when dry, but skim my body so when they are wet it stays close in place.

  • 8 years ago

    No problem, mtn. DH says he thinks it was called Cemetery Cenote. Let me know if you have any other questions.

    Hope everything is okay with your family and things get back to normal there soon. Our school's debate team is stranded on Bermuda due to the storm. Sounds like it was a real doozy.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked daisychain Zn3b
  • 8 years ago

    Check out Rip Curl. If I needed extra length, I'd pair the rash guard with board shorts. That long-length pictured above is so clingy around the hips that it looks like it might ride up.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked jellytoast
  • 8 years ago

    I understand mtn re: not being able to use reliable sunscreen where you're going. I guess a rashguard only when in the water wouldn't be so bad or if the temperature/humidity is moderate. I see more and more of these in the Lands End catalog and think, no way could I put one of those on but I can see how it would be useful in situations like yours. I learn something new here everyday....

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked 3katz4me
  • 8 years ago

    Lands End has one this year that looks like a tunic and has a zipper in the front. At times crew necks feel restricting to me so I thought that was a bonus.

    DD in Punta Cana now without a rash guard and she is very fair. We will see if she regretted it. She did take a fishing shirt that has SPF in the fabric to wear while boating, etc.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked RNmomof2 zone 5
  • 8 years ago

    Yes, there are a lot of really cute Ripcurl ones! At the end of the day though I did opt for length, but board shorts are a good idea. Hope the zipper is not annoying.

  • 8 years ago

    I'm not sure about the hood. Would you put the hood up? I think, for me, the hood would bother me floating around my head in the water.

  • 8 years ago

    IDK czarina, it might be nice to protect my neck or even my scalp ... i don't know if it's because I am fair or if it happens to a lot of people but my part gets sunburned and it can be miserable.

    When it comes, I will try it out in our pool to see how it works for snorkelling. It is really for SUP so IDK.

  • 8 years ago

    The hood will be fabulous for those reasons, mtnrdredux. People often forget to protect their scalp. If no hood, a hat or sunscreen on the part (messy) is essential.

    I wanted to chime in and say that Coolibar has fantastic products. We have quite a few of their products and have always been pleased.

  • 8 years ago

    suzmtl, thank you for the endorsement of Coolibar. I have looked there several times, but never ordered. I'm glad to know that you have had good experiences--will keep them in mind.

  • 8 years ago

    It seems pricey at first but it's unparalleled peace of mind. I ended up wearing my swim shirt as a jacket over sleeveless dresses all summer long. Sooo much easier than sunscreen!

  • 8 years ago

    FWIW, from someone in subtropical Florida, the original rash guard looked odd to me, as did the one shown on the boater. Nobody I've ever seen down here wears anything like that! They both look incredibly uncomfortable to wear in the tropics; I think you would feel very weighed down and the length is just weird. The Roxy one looks more like what people wear for swimming or water sports in the tropics :).



  • 8 years ago

    Thx, running, I thought it looked a little weird too. It's on its way now, so we will see!

  • 8 years ago

    When we vacation in beachy, tropical places I use only a good, high quality, waterproof sunscreen. I’m very much into snorkeling and scuba, and have never considered “rash guards”, so I can’t comment on them. But, after our last vacation at a resort south of Cancun I strongly suggest that. you bring along a good, safe, dependable insect repellent. The ones for sale there were very expensive and very questionable. And very needed in many places.

  • 8 years ago

    http://annaeverywhere.com/best-cenotes-tulum/

    Good information.

    Mara Hoffman rashguards! Check them out.

  • 8 years ago

    Mtn - If you are also looking for a reef safe sunscreen I've had really good luck with Beauty By Earth.

    https://www.beautybyearth.com/product/mineral-sunscreen/

  • 8 years ago

    Raven; it looks like that person only goes to Cenotes without any services there .... I guess that has its pluses, but the cenotes themselves are less interesting than many I've seen. Love the Mara Hoffman high waisted suits; so cute.

    SMH, that's funny, I went looking on Amazon and I chose that product because it had tons of reviews (nearly 700) and a 4.5 star rating. And the negative reviews simply said it was hard to put on because it is thick, and it made you white (hard to get around with bio sunscreen). I bought one for the body and then a tinted one for the face.

    Lynn, Yes, totally bringing repellant. Have you found a non-Deet one that you like? The issue with sunscreen is that some of the state parks make you shower off whatever you have on, and use only what they provide ... and there are mixed views on its efficacy. So rashguards are the safest. Also, the eco-tourism boat we are chartering to snorkel does not allow sunscreen unless it is biodegradable, and suggests that you cover up instead. Many of the better known cenotes do not allow sunscreen either.

    By the way I noticed "rashguards" in quotes. They used to be called sunshirts, unless they are different products?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    We were in the Western Caribbean two weeks ago and did a chartered catamaran excursion in Cozumel that included deep water snorkeling. I used SPF 70 sunscreen, a hat and a shirt while lounging on the catamaran and just a bathing suit and sunscreen when in the water. From there we went to the beach for a couple of hours where we read in the shade. I did see people paddle boarding with rash guard shirts only. That seems like it would be enough.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked Bonnie
  • 8 years ago

    We dove the cenotes near Tulum 15 years ago and it was an amazing experience. I can't recall the names, cause, 15 years. But I really loved that area of Mexico. We stumbled across this little place called Zamas one evening and had dinner there. Highly recommend if it still exists.

    One of the best experiences of our lives was the day we drove from Valladolid (I think we stayed there two nights) to a monkey preserve (punta laguna) and got on the wrong road. They have roads with the same numbers so you have to watch for the road vs. the freeway, as the freeways has NO exits. Ever. It was a long exhausting day that found us buying gas from Luis (watch out for pigs and chickens in his backyard) which he stored in 5 gallon penzol jugs, meeting a lovely woman who only spoke Mayan but who's grandson gave us a tour of the monkeys, saw alligators for .25 cents and finally made it to Coba in a downpour so extreme we didn't get out of the car and turned around and left. 5 stars, would do again. Also, loved Chicnen Itza.

    I think a normal rash guard and your zippy up option looks like a good plan. I think I need the zippy one for the boat this summer! We were in Maui a few weeks back and used the bio sunscreen and it worked fine. But I find I don't really burn that badly at sea level. Or, maybe it's just my high elevation makes burns so much more severe that my perspective is skewed.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked lobby68
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    We just got back from a snorkeling trip to Fiji and we (my brother and I) had excellent results with reef-friendly sunscreen (from Amazon), Stream2Sea, and brother is a redhead and burns very easily. I would recommend getting a swim cap - that was the one thing we needed and didn't have. We also wore rashguards. Mine was white and short sleeved, but DB wore a long sleeved one. I had a GoPro camera headgear on and put a shower cap under it, which helped protect my scalp and also kept my hair out of the camera lens. Here are some photos I took last week:

    (Video captures)

    Snorkeling is better in Cozumel - I've been there about eight times, but that was in the late 1970s and early 1980s. I used to go there every summer when I lived in San Francisco. I've also traveled extensively in the Yucatan, Quintana Roo (when it was a territory instead of a state) and Guatemala. When I went to Xel-Ha and Tulum, there was almost no one else there, but it also wasn't that easy to get there. When I first went to Cancun, it was still under construction and there were no open hotels. I hitchhiked around Cozumel Island. I think Chichen Itza (also CI) is worth it - I've been a few times, but crowds weren't crazy. Uxmal was my favorite site, but you can go to other ruins that are somewhat less remote. I generally spend a few days in Merida while in the Yucatan and stayed downtown. Food is especially good there because there is a Lebanese population, and you can get pita bread as well as food that is a combination of Mayan and Lebanese. IMO Yucatan has the best food in Mexico, or at least it did when I was there.

    If you are really interested in snorkeling, I cannot recommend Cozumel highly enough - it is better than Fiji, and Fiji is pretty good. Both islands have had damage from storms - Fiji for Cyclone Winston in 2016 and Palancar Reef a few years ago - I think it has had time to recover somewhat. Belize is good also, but I was only there for 2-3 days on my way to Guatemala.

  • 8 years ago

    Bonnie, that sounds like a good day!

    Lobby, love your story about Valladolid. Those things are far better than anything one could have planned!

    Lars! Those are great photos! So pretty. How did you like Fiji otherwise? I have never been. A swim cap? Is that what we used to call a bathing cap? To keep hair out of your eyes?

    I bet that area of Mexico was heavenly in the 70s/80s. I am always hoping for places that are just about to become big tourist destinations, but I am not an early adapter, alas.

    I considered Cozumel but was swayed by two things - friends who loved Tulum, and crime in Cozumel. I just googled this: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-embassy-warning-apparent-explosive-device-found-on-mexican-ferry/

    Criminy! I am hoping we can lay low in Tulum and avoid all the folderol. But I won't be heading back to Mexico any time soon.

    I have snorkeled in Belize, a few places in the Caribbean, Hawaii, Bali, Bermuda, FL, Malaysia, and the Great Barrier Reef. But I've never been to the South Pacific! It is soooo far from the East Coast and I think of it as a place to just relax. Should I add it to my list?

    My favorite place we snorkeled was in Sipadan in Borneo. Only issue is it very very hard to get to and the accommodations and food were very expensive and totally mediocre.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Ok, it finally arrived and I tried it on. I think I will like it. I also tried it in the pool and it worked fine wet. Not too heavy or stiff. I was worried it might almost be like a wetsuit.

    Then there are the aesthetics. For some reason, I keep hearing a jingle... (sorry about the ellipse Linelle)

  • 8 years ago

    Isn't Borneo considered partially South Pacific? Or is it in a different sea? It looks like it's between the Pacific and Indian Oceans. I'd like to go to the Great Barrier Reef also. I find the Caribbean expensive, but one of the reasons we went to Fiji instead of Tahiti is that hotels are about half the price. It's an 11 hour flight from L.A., and so that made it easy for me, but it would be far from the East Coast. I found Fiji to be completely enchanting, but it would be better to go during the peak season, I think. We went during cyclone season, but it did not rain that much while we were there and most of the days were sunny, but we were west of the main islands. I think if you've been to Bali and Malaysia that you don't need to go to Fiji, but I do think it's a wonderful place and it's definitely underdeveloped, considering the potential. One of the reasons for that is that it is rather remote. Most of the visitors are Australian. I wanted to go there because there are so many uninhabited islands and some of the islands only have very limited facilities. The island I really wanted to visit did not have electricity after midnight, and so that eliminated that one for me.

    I guess a swim cap is the same thing as a bathing cap, although bathing cap sounds more glamorous. Swim caps are worn mostly by competitive swimmers, but they would protect your scalp from sunburn. I'm planning on getting one or two anyway. I have a wetsuit cap, but that is very thick and is meant to keep my head warm.

    Cozumel has an airport, but I don't think it has as many flights as it used to, as people now fly to Cancun instead. I used to take that ferry from Playa del Carmen, but I also flew to/from Houston and New Orleans.

    Here are some more pictures from Fiji:

    This shows the resort where we stayed.

    Beach where we snorkeled.
    Sandbar that we visited by boat, seen in the background.
    Sunset photo with Samoan flying fox in the photo. We saw a lot of these at every sunset from our balcony and my brother got some good videos of them.


  • 8 years ago

    Oh Lars that looks heavenly! I love the sunset video too. I think that people from the E Coast go to the Caribbean, people from the W Coast tend to go to Hawaii or the So Pacific. One more reason I wish I were Californian!

    I had to look up your question about whether Borneo was in the SoPac.

    I learned something! The red dot is Borneo. When I look closer at the part where we stayed, it is in the Celebes Sea, pretty well known for snorkelling and diving. To me, it was the best place for snorkelling that I've been. It is probably not unrelated that the tourist facilities were mediocre and inconvenient. Hence unspoilt.

    I learned something else ... look at the weird borders of the South pacific?

    I scrolled down and found this - Hanga Roa, due west of Chile, is in the SoPac! Aka as Easter Island, we were there 3 yrs ago. It is half way to Tahiti from Chile. So now I realize I have been to the South Pacific. (check!) I've accomplished something already this morning, LOL.

  • 8 years ago

    It looks like you made a decision, but I have been using swim shirts for a couple years and wanted to comment. in case it helps anyone else

    Rash guards and swim shirts can/should be different. I expect a rash guard to have a thicker material, although sometimes they are listed erroneously with interchangeable titles. I don't like putting on sunscreen (chemicals, feels gross, effort) and throwing a shirt on is much easier. I have lighter colored rash guards and if they feel hot at all, I just get them wet. If they are wet, they end up making me feel much cooler and more comfortable than I would otherwise. I have one by Carve Designs that I love. It has a zipper on top, but it is plastic. It doesn't get hot or get in the way. Being able to zip down a little is nice for venting or drying off. It also has side ruching so it looks slightly nicer, imo, than a normal rash guard. (The side ties also let me tie the top to my bikini bottoms if I plan to be doing anything athletic. This helps the shirt stay in place. That isn't the intended design, I imagine. Just a bonus for me.)

    I use mine for paddleboarding all the time...


    https://www.rei.com/product/112630/carve-designs-cruz-rashguard-womens