I am not an expert, but love the grey one.. it just looks way too small. Hopefully you get some good advice from the Pro's. Good Luck!

Thanks, stumpedinnc! I was also thinking of using a chunky jute rug... same color as the fireplace mantle. Something like this....https://www.worldmarket.com/product/basket-weave-jute-rug.do?code=STOCKUP&ab=promo:53:1:stockup

I like the gray also but that one is too small

I think the reason it looks too small is because the rug sticks out too far from the furniture. If you can put it under the furniture more, it might not look too small.

I like your rug but it's much too small. It should be much longer and wider, as you can see in the picture above. It needs to be a major part of the room.

I would want to try something a lot bigger. Sized more for the room not just the sectional. I like without rather than the two options shown.

I think a larger rug would look better. I would also turn it so that it runs lengthwise with the back of your sofa.

I think you need at least an 8x10. At a minimum turn a 6x9 rug so the widest part is at the opening of the sectional.

I actually like no rug. Easier to clean in and around and under!!

A few other considerations: the ottoman probably is useless there. No on is going to sit for long with no back to lean on and it makes the whole thing look cramped. The end tables are too short: they should be as tall as the sofa arms so you don't have to reach over for your drink or book.....