Software
Houzz Logo Print
tig727

Update Cherry Kitchen - Too dark!

8 years ago

We moved into our house 6 months ago and I really don't like the cherry cabinets, backsplash and black granite countertops in our kitchen. To me it's dated, and I feel that the cherry is dark (and too red) and the counters make them look darker. In my old house we had redone our kitchen and I had antique white cabinets with a glaze and a much lighter color granite and that's more my style.


The rest of my home is mostly traditional with a bit of French style furniture. I actually really like the style of these cabinets so I'd like to keep them. What I'm debating on and need help with is:


-Should I paint the island? (a cream? glaze or no glaze?) I would be open to gray as well but don't want to darken the room.

-Change all of the counters or just the island counter? And if so, what color and type of stone?

-Change the backsplash? Color?

-Change the cabinet knobs? Color and style?

-What color lighting fixtures? Need 2 for over island and 1 for kitchen table.

-What color/style of new bar stools & table that fits 6 would go that isn't so match matchy like what we have now?

-Paint color?


We have tile floor that is staying. We will be ripping down the wallpaper so I will also need to decide on a paint color. I plan on having the trim around the room painted linen white to match the rest of the house as well. The family room it is open to is a taupey gray (BM Himalayan Trek), the dining room is blue per the previous owners (BM Solitude), and hall to the kitchen is BM Spring in Aspen which is neutral. The hardwood floors in the DR and FR are a similar color to these cabinets.


Any suggestions? My husband, of course thinks it's fine as is, so painting all of the cabinets would be the least practical option. He is willing to compromise on everything else.


Please help! I am at a loss. Every time I think I have it figured out I change my mind.








Comments (36)

  • 8 years ago
    Some inspirations. Note how they used light backsplashes and wall paint to lighten the kitchens.
    tig727 thanked Carol Singletary
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you, Monique! I never even thought of getting rid of the arch above the sink. Great pictures, Carol!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I have nothing to add to Monique's and Carol's advice. Start with those and then come back and post pics! Those cabs are beautiful and they're real cherry, not stained maple from the look of it.

    tig727 thanked Carolina Kitchen & Bath
  • 8 years ago

    Yes, the cabinets and countertops are dark, but there's a richness to the depth of tone in the cabinets. The drab mid-tones of the wall color and backsplash, though lighter, are the real culprits, imho. They're dating and dulling the kitchen more than the cabinets. I'd strongly suggest bringing in a lighting consultant, too. Great, strategic lighting will make a huge difference.

    I agree with removing the arch, which will increase natural light and open things up. I see you have one cabinet door with glass. You might also want to change out a couple more to increase the reflective elements.

    tig727 thanked kchreg
  • 8 years ago

    kchreg, thank you and I totally agree with this, especially about the backsplash and wall color. I have lighting that is built into cabinetry under the arch, so unfortunately the arch can't be removed without having to find someone to put molding on the top of the surrounding cabinets, if that makes sense. We have under cabinet lighting, 2 lights over the island, lights over the sink and stove, and a lighting fixture over the kitchen table. I like the idea of including more glass in the doors. Thanks for your input!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    We think changing the wall color, adding undercabinet lighting, updating the pendant lights, and getting new stools will help.

    Modern-Rustic Loft Kitchen Remodel · More Info

    tig727 thanked Chi Renovation & Design
  • 8 years ago

    following...

  • 8 years ago

    I like Monique Barrow's suggestions. Your cabinets are beautiful. Good luck

    tig727 thanked shwshw
  • 8 years ago

    You could backlight the cabinet with the glass doors as well as add undercabinet lighting as suggested. I think it's nice to have a small table lamp in a kitchen on a corner of the counter. Commission a small, bright, light patterned floorcloth from Etsy for the kitchen or rug sto lighten the floor--kind of a painting on the floor effect. Here are some indoor outdoor ones you can clean easily;


    Navajo Casual Indoor Outdoor Rugs, Yellow, 5'x7'6" · More Info


    Coral Cascades Indoor Outdoor Hand Hooked Area Rugs, Yellow, 5'x7.6 · More Info


    Nazar Casual Indoor Outdoor Area Rugs, Brown/Blue/Yellow, 7'6"x9'6" · More Info

    I don't like too many small things to clutter up a kitchen, but maybe a beautiful hand painted tray against the tan backsplash, or kids' art work there. Or don't do any of this. Your kitchen looks wonderful!

    tig727 thanked housegal200
  • 8 years ago

    Yes, change the cabinet hardware to stainless or brushed nickel. Once you change the countertops, you might consider painting the stools(don't think they need to be changed).

    tig727 thanked shirlpp
  • 8 years ago

    These reminds me of your kitchen. This one has that farm sink, glass cabinets on one side, something you could do--change out a couple more cabinet doors.Do light cream wall paint, too.

    Ireland in CT · More Info


    tig727 thanked housegal200
  • 8 years ago
    I would love to see someone do a mock-up with light countertops. I don’t know how to do it. Your cabinets are beautiful.
    tig727 thanked Brenda Waggoner
  • 8 years ago
    my sil has similar (beautiful) cabinetry. She changed her countertop and backsplash to much lighter materials. it looks amazing.
    your cabinets are beautiful. please don't paint any of them...
    tig727 thanked oliviag55
  • 8 years ago
    Following

    I have the same dilemma, gorgeous cabinets: Cherry with a custom blend mahogany type stain, with a similar wood floor stain, ice blue Formica Color Core countertops with stainless steel double sink. I have light taupe walls but thinking of painting them a light silvery gray. I have one cabinet with extra China that is glass, and corner shelving but I think it would be silly to paint over the cabinets as they have retained some beauty. They could use some touching up after 33 years though! And i have wanted to get new stools and pendants and I really cannot decide what to do with a backsplash as I want it to be easy to wipe down, and yet fit the style of the cabinets. Sometimes I like the glass tiles! Would love to know what you decide on!
  • 8 years ago

    I am waiting on my painter to come and take down the wallpaper. I am painting the kitchen BM "Spring in Aspen" which is very neutral and is in the hallway and foyer adjacent to my kitchen. I am having the trim painted linen white as well, which may help brighten up the walls a bit. I like the idea of a glass backsplace! Definitely more modern than the tumbled marble I have.

    Once I have it painted, I will change out the lighting fixtures. Then I will do the barstools and kitchen table. If I still don't like it all, I will most likely just get the island and hood painted an off white/cream.

    I really took the advice from everyone here! I sat back and realized that there is truly nothing "wrong" with my cabinets- the color just isn't my taste. The style I love...so it's worth keeping them as is and trying to fix what's around them to make them appear to be different..if that makes sense.

  • 8 years ago

    Raising my hand, I am in the same boat as you. We bought our house from the builder 10 years ago, cabinets are custom just a little darker than yours with brown granite and wood floors. None of it is my taste but the layout works for us. I started step by step, getting rid of the goldish paint, switching the hardware to a brushed nickel (tried polished nickel first and didn't love it with the cabinets), changing out the appliances. I wanted to see if I could grow to love it with just small touches.


  • 8 years ago

    andria564 I wish we had wood floors! Do you have a picture of your hardware against the cabinets? I was debating on sticking with oil rubbed bronze but get rid of the ones we have now... or do a brushed nickel.

  • 8 years ago


    Existing Kitchen · More Info
    I will take some when I get some tonight you can kind of see the difference, left and right are new, top is old.

    tig727 thanked andria564
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks for the picture! There's definitely a difference between the two. I love the trim you have under the cabinets!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Your Kitchen is already wonderful but I do agree a Spa Day is in order for the space! First lets go bright...some shade of the many whites on the wall, then choose a super cool wallpaper to add to the ceiling/walls and finally add some new lighting over the island. You will be amazed how quickly just these three elements will elevate your space. And if you're really feeling like a full facelift...paint your existing cabinets either light or dark or a mixture of both. Happy Decorating!


    Sassy and Chic · More Info

    Sassy and Chic · More Info

    Kitchens · More Info

    Summer Street Residence · More Info

    tig727 thanked Layla Weiss Designs
  • 8 years ago

    I would also add my mom is a kitchen and bath designer. My entire kitchen face lift has been planned in her head for years. To get it to fit my style fully steps are:

    1. New cabinet doors on uppers, no arch - this will be happening

    2. Paint out cabinets - this will be happening

    3. If I want to get rid of the OTC microwave, common here, change cabinets to the right of the fridge and make them the same depth and put micro there or do a micro drawer on side of island and extend counter over - not sure if I will do this

    4. New counters, I love calacatta gold marble but that will not be happening because kids. She has access to quartz slabs at her costs, which is hard to beat. I will probably at that time take out our step up bar and make everything counter height.

    5. Backsplash

    6. Floor refacing in 4-5 years on the wood floor, we have old dogs and this needs to happen throughout

    You have a lot better light in your kitchen then we have in ours and your cabinets are lighter. I usually like to have the island cabs and other cabs match unless the island is a star, I guess I am old fashion like that. Yours looks to be on the smaller side like ours is so I would keep it the same color. I think switching out the backsplash would help to update and so would the counters. It really depends what your budget is and long term goal of what you want. If you just hate the color of the cabinets, make a plan. It doesn't make sense to get new counter and backsplash coordinated to the current cabinets installed and you still hate the color of the cabinets because those choices might not have been what you would have picked with different cabinets. My husband lives by the saying "happy wife, happy life" so he goes with whatever. He hated the paint until it was done and he came home and realized how much lighter and happier it felt.


  • 8 years ago

    andria564, I totally agree! Right now I can deal with what I have and make small changes. In another decade or so, maybe I'll change them out. I really love the style, I am very traditional, so the only thing I would change now is the color. Yes, I am hesitant to paint the island. I'm really hoping once the walls are painted I'll start to see a nice difference! Thanks for your advice!

  • 8 years ago
    Ignore the double ovens, those are also being replaced with stainless.
  • 8 years ago
    You need some recessed lighting and a lighter color on the walls. If there is little natural light, lighting is necessary. If the central fixture isn't lighting up the corners, replace the bulbs with the next higher wattage: 60w
  • 8 years ago
    Your kitchen reminds me of mine in my new house, and my sentiments are the same as yours. That’s how I found this post. I feel it is too dark, and I’m really into white cabinets and light countertops. However, we’ve been hesitant to make any major changes for a few reasons : (1) we did a bunch of other work to the house already and the kitchen wasn’t high on our priority list even though it’s not necessarily my taste, (2) the cherry cabinets, though not my style, are beautiful and I’m afraid of ruining them with paint and regretting it down the line if/when trends change, and (3) I’m hesitant to make piecemeal changes, e.g. just the backsplash, kitchen island counter, etc. because it’s possible that we may paint the cabinets and change everything down the line, and I don’t want to have to redo anything, and (4) I’m just not sure what to do with it to make me love it beyond a total redo. So, we did the basics - changed the wall color to Benjamin Moore Pale Oak which I think looks great with cherry, and bought new lights and counter stools. The lights and stools made a huge difference, enough to hold me over for the foreseeable future, but I do still find myself constantly looking for ideas and inspiration. Anyway, sharing a before and after so you can see the difference the lights and stools made. Note, the original pictures were professional photos from the listing, whereas I took mine on my phone, so my pic looks a lot darker, but you’ll get the idea. Don’t mind the clutter.
    tig727 thanked rschleifs
  • 8 years ago

    rschleifs wow that first picture is identical to my current kitchen! Your kitchen now looks totally different! Do you happen to have a picture of the wall color next to the cherry? I've heard of Pale Oak before. Your kitchen now definitely looks much less cherry in color.

  • 8 years ago
    Here are a few shots from different places. We considered Balboa Mist too but I thought this one looked better.
    tig727 thanked rschleifs
  • 8 years ago

    rschleifs thank you so much! I'm going to get a sample of Pale Oak. We have Himilayan Trek in our adjacent family room and I think the Pale Oak would like nice in the kitchen. Is your cabinet hardware oil rubbed bronze? I'm debating on keeping mine bronze (just getting new ones) or getting brushed nickel.

  • 8 years ago
    Those colors could look nice together! Pale Oak wound up being my favorite paint color in my house - I absolutely love it. Our hardware is bronze. I think oil rubbed but could be some slight variation to that. I haven’t looked into changing them out yet - will prob wait to figure out what I’m doing with the rest of the kitchen. Please keep posting with your updates - I want to see how your changes look !
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    So my current kitchen is from 2008 and looks very similar. I just gutted the original 1984 bathroom and want to avoid it. I’m liking the previous farmhouse post with the creamy glass subway tiles - i would love a new counter but I don’t know what to choose. We chose shaker beige by Benjamin Moore and added new pendants and cans for lightening. I don’t like the style of the hardware. I hate the floor because it doesn’t clean well, but that is an entire other can of worms that I’m not ready to open. I don’t know how I could fix that without removing cabinets.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Your kitchen reminds me a lot of mine. My cherry cabinets are 1990 and my upper cabinets have the cathedral shape. I have replaced the tumbed backsplash with a honed marble, and replaced the countertops with white princess.


    https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-1jiuT-Ult60/U3OEf3kPP_I/AAAAAAAADa8/NtFiWfnEW5w/s1600/kitchen+w+new+granite.jpg

    tig727 thanked kkenning
  • 8 years ago

    Looks pretty! Love the changes I think we have the same floor!

  • 8 years ago

    I can appreciate all of the pretty white kitchens that are out there. However, I painted all the doors and woodwork a while back and though it looks nice, painted white is a lot of work to keep it looking good. My floor is not hard to keep clean.

  • 8 years ago

    following

  • 7 years ago

    Following