Software
Houzz Logo Print
cmeister419

Are my Austins dead?

8 years ago

Last spring I planted 2 Austin’s - Princess Alexandra of Kent, in the ground, and Carding Mill in a container. Both flourished beautifully, tons of blooms, no disease, but in fall they did get attacked by sawfly larvae. I am in the Northeast, Zone 6, and we had a particularly long winter. The canes are brown and dry from winter, and I just assumed with the prolonged cold the roses hadn’t woken up yet. I was at my parents yesterday who live only 20 minutes south of me, and their Lady of Shallot (also in her second year) is fully green, already covered in new shoots and small buds are forming. Another rose bush that they have had for over 25 years is also full of new shoots.

Since they are not far from me it got me thinking that maybe I lost my shrubs. The bottom of some of the canes are starting to flush green... how long should I wait to see if the shrub will produce? My Alexandra of Kent very leggy after the sawfly attack and started growing these really long canes that would only flower at the ends. Should I prune deep?

Comments (21)

  • 8 years ago

    The answer to if you lost these roses or not depends in part on whether or not they are grafted. If they are own-root, the roots are the same kind of rose as the canes. In that case, you can prune off the dead, brown canes and wait for new growth to spring up and everything is likely to be fine. If they are grafted, there is a chance that you will find that the rose that blooms for you this summer is the wrong rose -- that means the root stock survived and is blooming, rather than the Austin rose you wanted (which would have frozen off, particularly if the bud union was above the soil when you planted the rose). If you want to grow modern roses in pots in zone 6, you will be most successful if you protect them during the winter somehow. The rose only has the pot to provide it with insulation -- which is not nearly as the ground. If you don't want to give winter protection to your planted rose, own-root roses come back more reliably than grafted. Something to think about for the future. I hope this helps.

    cmeister419 thanked K S
  • 8 years ago

    I would trim off the obviously dead parts to make us both feel better. If there is white pith in the center of the canes as you trim down, there is still hope. You could give them another month or so to see which way they go.

    cmeister419 thanked Sheila z8a Rogue Valley OR
  • 8 years ago

    See if you can post a pic of the roses.

    cmeister419 thanked SoFL Rose z10
  • 8 years ago

    If there are any green parts of the canes, this is what will produce. You can cut off anything that is brown, these will not produce new growth, you will have to cut down to the green parts.

    cmeister419 thanked diane_nj 6b/7a
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I will try to post pics when I get home. All of the canes I have trimmed lightly have white piths.

    I believe carding mill is own root but Alexandra is grafted. The bud union WAS underground when planted, but it looks like with winter snow erosion it’s now exposed. I should have been more attentive.

    Regarding the canes - the green coloring is traveling further and further up the canes each day. How long should I wait before knowing where to cut back to?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    You prune from the top down. Remove the brown and leave the green at this point. You can prune a bit more later. The plant will tell you what part is healthy or not by how it grows.

    cmeister419 thanked Sheila z8a Rogue Valley OR
  • 8 years ago

    After taking these I think I answered my own question. I have no hope. As a general rule of thumb, should the canes stay green through winter?

    I took such good care of my roses during the growing season while my Dad did nothing to his, no watering, no fertilizing, no winter protection, and he has this pristine plant budding!

    I clearly need to improve winter protection.

  • 8 years ago

    What Sheila said. Anything I have in a pot, will go in the ground by September. That winter wind will just hit the side of them turning them into a big popsicle if I don't.

    cmeister419 thanked witchygirrl6bwv
  • 8 years ago

    It's still too early in zone 6 to say these are definitely dead, but virtually all those canes have to go. There's at least some hope in the last photo since I see some green at the base of a cane or two. Remember, all you need is for the graft (or the roots) to survive - it's not necessary for the above ground canes themselves to survive. A good 80% of my roses have canes that die to the ground every winter and they come back from the base. In cold zones, we either have to bury the graft (the knobby bit where the canes sprout from) in hopes of keeping the graft alive in the somewhat warmer ground or planting own-root roses.

    When planting in pots, all the "below ground" in the pot is actually above ground and subject to the same temperature swings and cold as the canes above ground. That might be why your dad's roses survived and yours might not, if his are in the ground. Alternatively, some people that grow roses in pots bring them into a garage or other protected space over the winter to avoid the consequences outside. A rose has to be at least a zone more hardy than your own zone to survive in the pot, as a handy rule of thumb. That means that for zone 6, your rose would have to be hardy to zone 5 or below.

    Bottom line for now is to prune the dead canes off, water and wait to see if there are sprouts. If the rose is own root or the sprouts are from the graft or above, your rose has survived. If the sprouts are from below the graft, only the rootstock has survived and like KS said the rose is likely to be the dark red of the rootstock Dr. Huey.

    Don't fret - just live and learn as we all do. You'll be able to grow roses if you want to, it's a matter of coming up with roses that work for your zone and conditions.

    Cynthia

    cmeister419 thanked nippstress - zone 5 Nebraska
  • 8 years ago

    I am sorry to say, they don’t look promising. I would bury the graft union deeper than that; from the picture, the graft unions are above the surface. Give them another month, but start shopping in the mean time....

    cmeister419 thanked Claire Z5 IL
  • 8 years ago

    I just took another look. The PAK in the ground still has hope, as I see some green canes. PAK can survive my Z5b winter without protection (with graft union 3” below), so they should be fine in your zone.

    cmeister419 thanked Claire Z5 IL
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you Sheila,


    I didn’t realize about the container making it less winter hardy. I guess I’m going to cut my losses, no pun intended. DA is offering own root Carding Mill in stock right now so maybe I will start over. It was a really beautiful rose. Bummer.

  • 8 years ago

    Cynthia - thank you so much. Both roses are supposed to be hardy from zone 5. I’m on the cusp of zone 6b & 7a so I assumed I’d be ok. At this point I will prune down to green on Alexandra.

    I can get a new Carding Mill on own root right now so maybe I’ll start over. I didn’t know I could garage my rose containers. I will def keep that in mind for next year. I am limited with planting space on my property otherwise in the ground wouldn’t be a question.

  • 8 years ago

    Palytoxin- thanks. I will work on PAK but I think Carding Mill is a lost cause. There is one cane that’s faint green at the bottom.

  • 8 years ago

    You said Carding Mill was own root? It does look bad, but why not trim it down and see if it comes back. Give it some water, and wait. It might surprise you.

  • 8 years ago

    I say you start over. I know they aren’t cheap but you’ll have more blooms this season if you start again. And having learned you’ll be better prepared for next winter. :)

  • 8 years ago

    Hi All - So I have deeply pruned my shrubs to check the canes as low as I could go and I am assuming death.

    PAK

    Carding Mill

  • 8 years ago

    I might wait and see. Watch to see if you get any sign of a bud break, i.e. where a stem will emerge. A couple of years ago, I had one that had just a tiny nub of "proof of life", a bit of green less than 1/4". I did a better job of weeding around it, keeping it mulched and fertilized and sprayed, and it recovered. (That being said, I have adopted a strict "own root only" rule, so that if the plant is alive, I know it is not root stock I am trying to nurture.) Another way to over-winter pots is to submerge the pot in the ground up to at least the level of the soil in the pot, which decreases temperature swings of the soil in the pot.

    cmeister419 thanked ellatiarella (SW Mich 6a)
  • 8 years ago

    I agree with Ella - wait and see. I don't see the cut ends of the canes as being in the "definitely dead" category, since there is the look of some creamy live cane in most of the cuts. The brownish-red outer canes don't look that great, but if they get the bud breaks that lead to growth, that means there are live canes to support growth. If you get some growth lower on the canes but dead parts further out on the canes, gently prune the cane back to just above the sprouted bits. Until you see other roses in the same locations start to bud out, you won't know if these are going to regrow or not.

    Just make sure to keep the soil watered, but not drenched or sitting in water. You might still see recovery. I don't give up on a rose in zone 5 till at least June.

    Cynthia

    cmeister419 thanked nippstress - zone 5 Nebraska
  • 8 years ago

    I also say wait a few more weeks. I'm in zone 5 and most of my roses (even those that typically make it through a winter with quite a bit of cane) are nearly dead to the soil. It was a rough year here in my garden. However, a few years ago I had a Lady Emma Hamilton that I was sure was dead. Being lazy, instead of digging it up I instead just planted a new rose right next to it. Imagine my surprise late that summer when I noticed a Lady Emma bloom in my pink rose! I agree to give it till at least June. Here's hoping they make it. I still have some that haven't starting leafing out yet even though there's an inch or two of green cane. With this crazy spring/long winter I think some are just confused!

    cmeister419 thanked kellbell5555
Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County