Software
Houzz Logo Print
morganism10

Really red house - yes or no?

8 years ago

We painted the house this red after three batches of paint came to us the wrong colour. It was late in the year, snow was right around the corner, and we figured it just needed 'something'. (We were going for a deep maroon, if you can believe it.)


After it being this colour for 3 years, my friends and family are just now starting to tell me they don't like it.


So now I'm trying to decide; leave the red, but change all the trim to either all white or all black -- or repaint the whole house. (The carport now has a garage door on it, by the way, so more surface on the front.) It's getting a new roof this summer, too.


I'm beffudled. Any advice?




Comments (16)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I can't tell what color the trim is now?

    It is not as bad as I was expecting. I could probably live with it for awhile but then I am cheap. :)

    What color was it before red? And what color will the roof be?

    morganism10 thanked shari13
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    If you are willing to paint again, I would have the body of the house green because of the fabulous back drop you have of the huge evergreen trees. I would put the red on the roof…can you have a metal roof in your location?

    morganism10 thanked JudyG Designs
  • 8 years ago

    If you like the red, then you should find a way to keep some. I think I'd let the 2nd floor stay red and paint the 1st floor a greyish colour a shade deeper than your foundation stone.

    If you've decided to do away with red, well, your house feels a bit log-cabinish to me so a rich brown might work well.

    Treehouses at Village of Cheshire · More Info
    Either way, beefier trim in a contrasting colour will definitely help. And since you're looking at a new roof, consider a metal one like this:

    White Mountain View · More Info

    Actually, to my mind, the main issue with your house is not the colour. It's that the full length balcony combined with huge parking area in front makes it look like a motel. Consider getting a professional landscape plan that you can implement yourself. I think that will make more difference than all the paint in the world.

    morganism10 thanked Jennifer K
  • 8 years ago

    I actually like the red. The back drop of green is its compliment. I think once you get your landscaping in it will look great.

    morganism10 thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Yes to changing all the trim except for that at the bottom of the siding and the downspout should be painted the same as the siding.



    morganism10 thanked groveraxle
  • 8 years ago

    Fantastic feedback, and so quickly. Thank-you all.

    shari13 - the trim is black and an ikky grey. And LOL at 'not as bad as I was expecting.

    JudyG Designs - great colour combo. I'm not sure another bold colour is worth the risk, as I REALLY don't want to paint again any time soon. The back of the house has several peaks for a deck and a nook, I'd have to ask my roofer about the metal roof.

    Jennifer K: You suggest metal roof too, hmmm? Interesting. Worth looking at. We do get A LOT of snow. The house is on a small acreage, so I get the 'log cabin' feel, but I'd rather go more ... executive, I think. For sure more tame. Thank-you for supporting me in the red, if I like it. I like it, don't know if I love it.

    Lezlie Cooper - Thanks for your support of the red. LMAO at landscaping ... it IS done! :-) There are lilacs and ornamental trees where the photographer would have been. There are usually red petunias behind the truck, along that wall. But, other than that ... that's it. (So much concrete block.)


  • 8 years ago

    Now let's try on a few different siding colors, eh?





  • 8 years ago

    groveraxle, that's fantastic! Thanks for taking the time to do that.

    I like them all.

    Would you be able to do a light beige colour with white trim?


  • 8 years ago

    I am over-the-moon at being able to see examples outside of my imagination.

  • 8 years ago

    I kind of like the two tone,,but don't like any of those others.

    I almost like the red,,really like the black trim,,,why not add some cedar shake or siding ?? You don't have to do the entire thing, maybe the upper left portion.

  • 8 years ago

    Beige with white and black. (Note: I didn't do the window frames.)



  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    this house needs bold. I'd do a cedar something, black, dark blue, or some stone work,,,forest green w/wood accents,,,,something of that ilk.

    that beige is a no go w/that surrounding hillside.

    morganism10 thanked Beth H. :
  • 8 years ago

    I like the all-black trim very much. I like Grovers 2-tone more than I expected to. Of course in real life you can tweak the 2 colors to pull them together a bit tighter. Even a darker, dirtier red I think I'd like if you have the energy to repaint. Unfortunately the red you got is a little too watermelon and not enough barn red. If you do repaint try an earthy shade of any color. Otherwise just smile through it!

    morganism10 thanked lisaam
  • last year

    We chose russet red for our house. people have told us they love it and others do not. we love how it turned out with the trim and stone work and wood garage doors. I like your red house.


  • last year

    funny thing, I like the red best