Hey guys, I am building a home and I’m torn between these two carpets. I have to commit to the finishes soon. Please help! Carpet will be in bedrooms and possibly study (if we can’t afford to extend hardwood there).

I’m focusing on tying in with my master as it will butt up against the master bath flooring and we have a beautiful bedroom set. The other rooms will eventually have new furniture so I can pick that later.

It is the brand Shaw - Grand Isle. The light is called “weathered”, and the dark is called “English oak”. I did ask the designer to burrow the sample board so I could see it next to my furniture too.

1. Light carpet: Definitely ties better with the hardwood, might warm up the rooms?

2. I think it looks better with master bath floor tile. I also have two giant Alaskan malamutes and their coats will inevitably leave dirt marks (we have light carpet now and it’s an absolute nightmare).

Tentative wall color included for the the house however we will be painting the master something different once we are settled. The stock photo is the same as our 5 piece bedroom set.

Thanks!