Sorry to hear that - I haven't ordered from them but it frustrating to have it happen not once but twice. I have heard great things about Adelman's and Klehm's. Most of my peonies I have purchased locally and the place I have ordered most of my peonies from online retired so I am trying these two this year since they have a great reputation. I've also ordered from Gilbert Wild & Son but some of their divisions are a lot smaller than they advertise though the sale prices are usually good.

That’s a bummer. I would like to second Adelman’s and add Hollingsworth... they’ve both always sent the correct ones.

They have offered to replace it (again) or send me a store credit. I don't have room for another peony so I will take the store credit. They do have excellent customer service.