Software
Houzz Logo Print
marticus

Brick cottage needs curb appeal help!

8 years ago

I'm buying this little 50's cottage as a rental. It's on a corner lot, in a neighborhood that has a mix of historic homes ( South Carolina) and more modern infill homes, that range from turn of the century to the 70s. I would like to ramp up the cottage aspect, and downplay any ranch style.


Since it is a rental, I can't spend too much on the exterior, but it makes a statement simply due to it's location, so I need to give that some attention.

Current plans include:

Painting trim and facia white

Removing 60's metal awning and adding a portico (commonly seen in this neighborhood)

Adding a small landscaping tree on the right such as bronze crape myrtle or a burgundy crab apple and pruning the magnolia way back (or removing)

Removing mailbox from porch (have to) and adding a stylish mailbox in a small landscaped bed

Maybe some shutters? if so, what style and do I have to put them on all the windows?

Removing screen door so the wood door can be seen.. painting it a brighter color maybe?


Other ideas appreciated!


style of portico

Comments (35)

  • 8 years ago

    If you'll remove the overgrown and aging shrubbery we can see what you actually have to work with. No shutters please.

  • 8 years ago

    I don't see cottage. Get rid of tree and bushes and then post a picture

  • 8 years ago

    Ok, should shrubs be even with the porch floor? or remove completely? I think they are old camellias, I can probably rehab them instead of remove altogether.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    As deco and jck mention: The house is overwhelmed by the shrubs and the tree. How close is that tree to the home? If it were mine, I would get rid of that old landscaping so you can see what you have now. New landscaping would need to follow a much different plan.

  • 8 years ago

    The landscaping is bringing the house down. The house could be really cute. Remove all the foundation planting and start over. It's hard to tell if there is a flower bed in front of the house, but I would add one or make the existing one larger. Add a window box the the window on the left. Replace the wrought iron railing with something more modern. The house needs some color. Yes, crepe myrtle, azalias, perennials, etc.

  • 8 years ago

    Remove and start over

  • 8 years ago

    following

  • 8 years ago
    Please think rehab first. Those are well established living bushes and trees. Maybe someone would be willing to remove them and use them themselves. I know when I wanted to redo a side yard, I posted pics of all the plants and the days that they could dig them up. While I had to replace the dirt, I was ok with this because replacing with new plants I needed new dirt anyway. People came out of the woodwork for free well-established plants. Also, I would frame and trim the windows then paint them if you don’t was shutters. The house still needs a screen door so consider a screen door that you pull closed when needed but is otherwise invisible. Good luck. I like those styles of homes.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    some ideas:





  • 8 years ago

    Does the invisible window behind the magnolia match the white window or the black window? Are you planning to replace any of them so that they match?

    Prune the magnolia into a graceful tree shape, cut the camellias way back. If you put in a new tree, will you yourself be around every week or two to water it and make sure the wind doesn't blow it over?

    Keep the screen door or replace it with a painted wood screen door.

  • 8 years ago

    Dig Doug's Designs...WOW, just WOW!!

  • 8 years ago

    Kimberlee T Yes, I'm a botanist, and I also love gardening so rehabbing to get things in scale would be my first choice. The magnolia however is really right on top of the house.. I still have to think that one over.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    apple_pie_order I live about 10 houses down, also I will be over there daily for the next few months as we renovate inside, so I will take good care of any new trees I put in. TY!


    I'm not sure about the window issue. Just now realizing they don't match. The big one (black) has a broken seal so that would be the one to replace. I think the hidden one has white mullions and is original but I have to check.

  • 8 years ago

    Dig Doug's Designs thanks so much for the mock up. I was trying to envision what limbing up the magnolia would look like. Those curved beds are much prettier too!

  • 8 years ago
    If the trunk and roots aren't causing foundation trouble, trim the lower branches. (You can make wreathes and garlands from those trimming:-) Drastic pruning of the shrubs will take time to recover but they are too tall.
    the portico will look great. When moving mail box to curb, you can add a few perennials around it like irises or daylilies which take little care once established. Surely a neighbor has some to share. A few flowers in a curve bed near would brighten it. Pick a dominant color to carry through the plantings.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Yardvaark and phuninthesun great work! it does look SO nice being able to see all three windows and bringing the foundational planting back into scale. I LOVE the portico too! make such a difference! I believe the magnolia is causing some moisture issues because the inside of the basement tested high for moisture in that corner. It does look much nicer to have the tree offset. But I hate to give up on a tree that's been there 30+ years.

  • 8 years ago

    kathleen MK I have some things I can bring over, and there are actually already some daylilies on the bank to the right of the stairs (can't see them in the picture). Perennials are definitely the way to go. Magnolia garlands are so pretty too, especially for weddings and the holidays.

  • 8 years ago

    I cannot imagine not having a screen door on my house. I would just replace it with one that is not obtrusive.

  • 8 years ago

    Roller screens can work well. They pull across the opening and retract to one side when not in use.

  • 8 years ago


    alrighty here's an updated photo. We removed the magnolia that was growing on the house and the dated metal awning. The new portico is done but has not been painted yet. All of the trim is going to be painted white as are all of the mullions in the windows. Obviously the permit board on the left will be removed, and I plan landscaping the sides of the sidewalk with something low maintenance. You can't see from this picture but there are little stairs that lead to the road at the end of the sidewalk and that is where the mailbox will be. What else would be cute? I really don't want to add shutters and I think if I added a window box my future tenants would not necessarily take care of it.

  • 8 years ago
    Coming along nicely. The bushes on the left are overwhelming the house and could use a pruning. The landscape on the right looks bedraggled and could use a refresh. What are your steps made of, stone, wood or something else? Can you make the risers th he same white that you are going to paint the trim? I think it would brighten that area.
    marticus thanked Denita
  • 8 years ago

    Yes, the bushes on the left will get pruned down after they bloom (80 year old camellias)

    Landscape on the right are some large azaleas which are trying to recover, I will probably shape them up as well and try to define a bed around them, maybe with an informal walkway from the front stairs to the gate on the right? too much maintenance?

    The steps are brick. That's an idea about painting the risers, I will have to look and see if I can find some pics like that. Thanks!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    You can add hostas all along the walk way. So low maintenance. No pruning unless you have deer, they will do that for you lol.

    I have the white tip leaf hostas and love them. You just plant them and never look back kind of plant.


    If you have a friend who has them, ask if they will split them. Then plant, they easily transfer.

    As Denita mentioned. Painting the railing white would brighten the area up.

  • 8 years ago

    I love hostas, but this is full sun until about 6pm. I think they would get cooked there. most people in our area use liriope (monkey grass) for an area like this as it is tougher. 96 degrees today :(

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    The bushes do not need to just be pruned down. They need to be pared down such that they do not look like a freighter ready to steam off toward the left. And end undercutting so lower foliage could be kept. They could be dome, not a ball. It could be difficult to recreate into a nice form without a hole or scar as some at left side need to be entirely removed.

    "I plan landscaping the sides of the sidewalk with something low maintenance." Well, that in and of itself is not a low maintenance idea. At this point we don't know what the "something" is, but if it has much of any height, it's going to make the entry experience substantially less appealing, and the drive by experience less appetizing. Lining the walk with Liriope would be an example of adding negativity. It would be creating a raised edge that shrinks the apparent walk size and divides it from the larger path (lawn) with a trip hazard.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I also wouldn’t line the walk with plantings. You already have a narrow walk and this will just make it feel more hemmed in. On a practical note, it also adds considerable edging and adds to mowing time. Instead, use low plants at the front of the house bed and make the bed deeper front to back to accommodate them. If you want to dress up the walkway a bit, add a course of bricks to each side, trying to match the house brick color as closely as possible. This will involve using a proper base and edging so the bricks stay in place, but will make the walk wider as well as dressing it up a bit.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    NHbabs those are helpful suggestions, thank you. You are right about the plantings lining the sidewalk. This is a quick sketch I did yesterday while I was thinking about developing some small beds at the end of the walkway to make it more welcoming from the street. The light green represents new plantings, I was considering a small evergreen on each side of the stairs to give it some attention. What do y'all think about that idea? I'm trying to find an actual picture to share...

  • 8 years ago

    Yaardvark, I just meant bringing the camellias into scale would be a process as they can't be downsized all at once without really damaging them. I agree they look terrible right now, but I would like to keep them if possible, so am planning a more gradual shaping in order to reduce stress.

  • 8 years ago

    It looks so much better. Painting the trim, the windows and the portico support will also brighten it up. I'm not too sure about painting the railing white. Love that you have a front porch. Hope your tenets use it - so neighborly! Your planting plant looks good.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Are you planning to leave the sloped areas grass? Or groundcover? Regardless, I would lose the beds along the walk by the steps. Add something bright and colorful up by the house rather than planting along the steps or the walkway. This is a rental, so you want plantings that are attractive but KISS (keep it super simple). The more edges that need maintaining, the more likely that the plantings will not be maintained well. What is the exposure or direction the house faces?

    I also think that you might want to consider removing at least one of the camelliasas Yardvaark suggested. They are currently such a large mass that they overwhelm everything else. You really want one or two individual shrubs, not a massive green blob.

  • 8 years ago

    right now the sloped areas have monkey grass and daylilies on the right side of the stairs . I was just going to do the same on the left side as well, as it's already a mow and go situation. I totally get that less edges = less work, but it also looks so stripped down and ugly right now :( The plantings I was going to do at the top of the stairs would be pretty minimal. Yard service will be included in the rent, I do this with all my rentals.

    The house has a southern exposure and is a corner lot in a historic neighborhood. It has plantation style homes, victorian styles, and mission style houses as well as a couple ugly ranches immediately surrounding it.

  • 8 years ago

    Aside from landscaping, other ideas for good curb appeal?

    So far:

    The front door is going to be blue, we are removing the screen door (might replace with a more minimal storm door).

    Also, I will put new exterior lights on either side of the front door, going for cottage style.

    New 4" house numbers that will be mounted on a board painted the same color as the door.


  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    A few things:

    If there is any solid part of the screen door/storm door, paint it to match the door. You don't want a white rectangle obstructing the blue door.

    What color blue for the door? Light? Dark? I've seen many here like Modern Masters paint--high-quality apparently.

    Adding colorful pots of flowers would be lovely.

    Post pictures of what you're thinking for paint and lights--I have a feeling people here will give you their opinions. LOL.

    Also, it would be nice if the windows could match...