Software
Houzz Logo Print
sarah_ebel

This fireplace is stumping me....

8 years ago

Hi! We put in this gas fireplace in our eating area. We did a black granite surround that I thought would look really sleek and I do love it, but I'm struggling to decorate around it. Without a mantle, I can't put up candlesticks, etc. to fill in the area. I thought the woven shades would give me the extra thing I'm looking for, but it still looks like it needs more. Maybe a more interesting mirror? We have sconces on the opposite wall so I don't want to "over-sconce". Any suggestions? Thinking I might just have my contractor add a mantle...




Hi




Comments (16)

  • 8 years ago
    I think it lots pretty great as is. But you could try changing the mirror if you want something different.
    sarah_ebel thanked K R
  • 8 years ago
    Beautiful room! And love the woofie!! I think everything looks too horizontal around the fireplace. And the mirror doesn’t add anything IMO. I would hang a fabulous painting or wall hanging of some sort above it....something definitely “portrait orientation” (tall) with subdued but rich colors
    sarah_ebel thanked Laurie Tillett
  • 8 years ago
    No mantle. Keep it clean and spare to fit with your room
    sarah_ebel thanked Laurie Tillett
  • 8 years ago

    Not a Pro.

    The fireplace looks great without a mantel.

    I think it's the mirror that is throwing it off.

    I think you need something either sculptural or a piece of driftwood to hang there.

    sarah_ebel thanked njmomma
  • 8 years ago

    I think the mirror is more of an issue than no mantel. You need art over the fireplace. A simple wood floating mantel could be nice.

    sarah_ebel thanked torreykm
  • 8 years ago
    I’ll join the chorus— the room really looks good! Try tinkering with the mirror, subbing art for the mirror, etc, no mantle.
    sarah_ebel thanked rainyseason
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Art instead of the mirror .

    sarah_ebel thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 8 years ago
    Love the space but agree with the suggestions to replace mirror with art. Also not liking the shades on the windows. Do you really need them for privacy and/or light control?
    sarah_ebel thanked Horizons
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The room looks nice and spacious but the furniture looks crammed against the corners and wall; pull chair away from corner, maybe small floor lamp, but fiddle with it, center console on wall and away from corner even if only two inches....and the mirror looks way too flimsy for the wall; try it over the console or a round gold mirror over the console.....the console could use a pair of lamps with mirror between it and plant etc only on the top; get rid of the small items. Maybe do lamps in brass like lamp and with white shades or navy shades or navy and white print on shades to repeat the navy chair fabric......

    Large art over the fireplace in black and white or bold colors seen in rest of the room with gold frame to pick up the floor lamp metal......black and white patterned pillow in the navy blue chair.

    sarah_ebel thanked Susan Davis
  • 8 years ago

    those woven blinds are far too bulky and unnecessary on those small windows. are you afraid someone is going to look in? if so, do a window film or get a beveled glass overlay.

    how bout if you move the console under the window? could you do that and take a picture? I think it would look better than how you have it crammed in the corner.


    At some point maybe you could replace the windows so it looks like this.

    so other similar set ups to give you some ideas. I think a nice art piece over the FP, and maybe a little bench on the right side (move the console)



    you don't have to do a mantel, but examples of how this is decorated

    small windows like yours w/cabinets below

    sarah_ebel thanked Beth H. :
  • 8 years ago

    If you want to keep a mirror above the fireplace, I would change the mirror from a rectangle to an elongated oval (longer horizontally) mirror because all the items on that wall currently are all the same geometric shape (square/rectangle). It would add a bit of visual interest to have a different shape (and color!) up there (add some circles, not just boxes). :)

    sarah_ebel thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    The fireplace looks GREAT ! You need to take the mirror off that wall it belongs in the hallway . Hang a painting or a large black and white photograph ..and put two chairs on either side ...maybe an ottoman in front to make an area where one can enjoy the fireplace ..and put that lamp on the outside towards the left ...still over the chair , but from the left ...do you need that little brown piece of furniture there ...? If so why not paint it black ...it looks out of place ....but , would need to see the whole room ...
    sarah_ebel thanked silviakunst
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks so much for all the comments! As always, very helpful and informative! I think the main takeaway is that I have to change out the mirror for art. I think I always knew the mirror didn't work great but kept thinking "mirrors always work!" lol.

    As far as furniture placement, as you can see in the second pic I posted above, there is an opening to the family room there, as well as the kitchen table and chairs so I can't really move stuff out into the area where people walk (this is not a main seating area). There just isn't enough room and would be very crowded. Unfortunately there is no space to move that lamp to other side, either! There is a kitchen cabinet there. And the sideboard matches a table on the other side of the family room opening so I think it would look off balance to move it under the window.

    For the windows, I added the shades because I wanted some warmth and texture over there and they match shades on the windows on the same wall in the kitchen area. Besides that they are custom and I like them!

    I appreciate the help!

  • 8 years ago
    Well in my opinion, the fireplace has to have a mantle and I expect Jackie to want the tv above the fireplace. When I think about the issues we have now, it would even be nice to have a double to include a place to put electronics leaving the upper level for decorative items. Just an opinion mind you and I’ve never seen one.
  • 8 years ago
    You have got it ! Like to see new picture when you exchanged the mirror . But do try the lamp on the left ...just MOVE the chair over and out a bit , enough to leave room for the base ...it will look better ...the lamp is not meant to be facing this way . The lighting of the chair is the same ..but the stand it obstructing the view ...and doesn't look right next to the fireplace . Good luck and congrats !