Software
Houzz Logo Print
gauth1979

Tile installation

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

My wife and I are building a new house. For our bathroom floors we were going to install 12x24 tiles. The tile installer said that would require extra labor charges vs. the standard 12x12 which is included in the house price from the builder.


I'd like to know if this is legit or not. I'm not really buying it because when I ask him what type of additional labor is needed I basically get the "it's because" type of answer. I've argued that it's the same square footage, half the tiles, less grout lines, and handling (all of which he agrees with). Also the 12x24s are NOT rectified edges.


They also want to charge extra for mosaic/glass tiles for a border strip in the shower - which I don't have a problem with and completely understand how those smaller tiles could take more time/precision to lay properly.

Am I out of line in my thinking on the 12x12 vs. 12x24?

Comments (7)

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    You contracted for 12x12. You want something different? Pay for the change.

  • 8 years ago
    Well I am paying more for the actual tiles (no issues for that). I just want to understand what the additional labor is involved with installing 12x24 vs. 12x12.
  • 8 years ago
    Thanks that was more info than I've been able to get out of my tile contractor. We're not doing any thing fancy with the tile pattern...will be a simple brick with 1/3 overlap and 3/16" grout line. Tile is a decent quality porcelin.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    It takes twice as long to do the job. Cutting is more difficult. Especially in a bath. There’s more wastage, so idiot homeowners don’t order enough and then you have dye lot issues and trip charges that they don’t want to pay for.

    It requires a 4x as expensive setting material. And expensive lippage management systems. And reinforcing joists on the second floor, and decoupling membranes if the homeowner didn’t tell the architect he wanted to use a tile that needs a floor twice as stiff as for wood. And you have to deal with penny wise and pound foolish homeowners who don’t take the time to buy a TCNA manual to learn what they’re specifying, or ask about truly vital things like waterproofing in wet areas, or how to minimize the lippage in some seconds tile from China that some HGTV decorator wannabe picked out.

    Every single deviation from a standard 12x12 stacked bond is an Upcharge. Sometimes a significant up charge. And don’t stint on the extra charges for prep as well. A good concrete sub can make or break your tile installation, just like a bad framer can kill your shower install.

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The main reason I charge more for anything larger than 12x12

    A. More demanding of substrate and actual putting/setting time.

    B. 90% of the time I do use a lippage system add 1$/sq

    C. More mortar and must be medium bed.

    Now you also go an add Unrectified and your fudging grout joints....add a mosaic or accent band and you likely are dealing with both material and mortar thickness differentials that also take time to pad out. Add the upgrade to 12x24 and theres even more time.

    Buck up and be mad at your builder:best advice :):)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    When you're old and grumpy (like me), you resist participating in pointless debate with neophytes, especially with articulate professionals who figure their LLB and immense T-4 trumps whatever you have to say about anything anyway. (Leave it to Sophie instead.)