Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_19294981

What’s Wrong with my Christmas Cactus?

8 years ago
My Christmas Cactus has weird orangey-brown spots on it. They seem to sit there and then make a hole in the leaf. I scraped some off, but there was still an indent left.

Any ideas what is going on? Google didn’t help, but I’m not sure what to search for!!

Comments (14)

  • 8 years ago

    Are they hard? It may be oedema?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Could be scale insects. They have a waxy, hard coat. Scrape one off. There are methods to get rid of them, but when a plant gets scale, I toss it and go shopping for a new plant. Not worth all the trouble, and that particular kind of plant is easily started by rooting a leaf in fresh soil.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Your Easter Cactus (I can tell by the shape of leaf & the hairs) has a fungus, has happened in the past on mine too. I was told by a horticultural friend to spray with a fungicide and dispose of those worst fungus dotted leaves. I used the Bayer 3 in 1 as that's what I already had on hand. Often 2 or 3 treatments are needed (read the label). It happens when they stay too wet too long. For some reason Easter Cactus are extra susceptible to this, so I try to keep the leaves dry or water in the morning so it has time to dry quickly in some sun.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Some of those brown things do look like scale (second picture, at the top), maybe along with the fungal infection. And scale does leave a hole where it has eaten the leaf. In any case, i would throw out the plant and start fresh. It's not like it's a huge, beautiful plant with sentimental value. It's sickly and it's a houseplant. :)

    Also, i see lots of people post problems who have those pebbles on top, so I wonder what they are contributing...

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    There is very easy way to determine if plant has scale or not: take a q-tip; moisten it in rubbing alcohol. Smear directly over the questionable spot. If a bug - scale - it will come off easily since rubbing alcohol will kill it on contact. I have experienced scale of few different plants (some succulents and also non-succulents), and never found a hole left after bugs were gone. I treated it with rubbing alcohol, keeping plant out of the direct sun while treated. It has been some time since I saw scale last time...

    Having approx. 300 pots of succulents and using gravel for top-dressing on all, I never had problem with it. Perhaps some ppl have problems. Problems are usually caused by the potting medium under the top-dressing.

    If there is extensive infestation, it may be good idea to get rid of plant - sometimes. But one should be sure what the problem is before discarding it. I see only very few spots, scale multiplies if not taken care of.

    Hillary

    How long since you noticed spots? Where is the plant kept (indoors? outside?) and how muh-how often do you water it?

    There is a chance of mechanical damage too - but that is usually bigger , just as visible on coupe of pads in pic #2. Do you know what happened there? (not a problem, just wondering).

    ETA:

    I found a jade with round spot that some may think it is scale. It is oedema. I wiped it with rubbing alcohol, but it doesn't come off. I scraped it, and it left indentation - just as I mentioned above. It doesn't look exactly same right now as marks on plant posted by Hillary, but it is fresh - I just did it. Here is the leaf 'before' and 'after':

    If Hillary is interested, I'll take photo in a day or 2 and post to see more healed hole/flesh.

  • 8 years ago

    My plants have these little bumps and depressions and I don't concern myself with it. I guess that plant, based on its leaves is S. xbucklyi, not R. Gaetneri.

  • 8 years ago
    Thank you all so much for your input! Yes, it IS an Easter Cactus - you got me on that one! As soon as I posted I knew I was wrong! When I bought it this spring, I thought it was just a Christmas cactus gone crazy blooming that time of year, but I wasn’t about to tell it that! I attempted the running alcohol on a q-tip solution when I initially noticed the problem (maybe a week ago?). It was hard to get the dot off - it looked like an orange/brown dot with a clear layer of slime over the top (probably a bad description!), and didn’t immediately come off, but eventually did once I “helped” it a bit more with some harder pressure. The plant is outdoors and is in the shade most of the time. If it gets any sun it’s afternoon sun. I water once a week, but I have a moisture meter and check the moisture first. Right now it’s reading as very moist/wet, which, I know, is not a good thing. It was potted in a mix of cactus/succulent soil, sand, and pearlite, so it should be draining well. I’m in California where it’s been 100°+ for a while, so the fact that it is not drying out is a little worrisome. Hopefully I watered it recently and forgot! The pebbles on the top were a deterrent to gnats that I read about, and I also like the look. However, if it’s causing the problem, it’s back to sand for me! yes, Rina, I would love some pics. I took one as close as I could (my phone camera doesn’t like to focus close up when I want it to!) of what I scraped off with a q-tip and alcohol today. Maybe it will help! I’d like to save the plant if at all possible. It’s not huge or terribly sentimental, that’s true, but I’d like to keep it if at all possible, just the same.

    Thanks again everyone for all of your help!!!
  • 8 years ago

    Hillary

    That is interesting. I can't tell if the 'color' is because of blood. If it was a bug, that's what it would be. You also said there was 'slime' over it, and I don't remember seeing that on any scale - but, there are many species of scale. If scale, there isn't that many and could be treated with rubbing alcohol. If it is fungus as Nancy suggested, fungicide should help.

    If the soil is still wet, it is most likely not draining well. Most ppl here don't recommend using sand and would leave it out completely. Gravel or small rocks are better for top-dressing than sand IMO. Plant may be better in a mix of C&S soil and coarse perlite. Using a bamboo skewer or chopstick inserted deep inside of pot helps to see how fast potting mix dries - it may work even better than moisture meter :) And making sure there are drainage holes in the container.

    Another sign that your soil doesn't drain well enough are fungus gnats: they like wet conditions. So if you had them (or still have them), repotting plant into better draining mix would make sense.

  • 8 years ago
    Sorry for the delay in response - I’m a teacher and I’ve been getting my classroom ready for school to start! Less than 2 weeks ♀️.

    I am definitely going to repot this little guy. I’m propagating some cuttings in water as well, and one of the cuttings slipped and has been completely in the water and has developed blistery-looking bumps (in addition to one of the orangey-brown ones). Based on that, I’m thinking the current issue is the fact that the soil seems to be staying wet. I’ll check in after I repot and see what happens.

    Thanks again, everyone!
  • 8 years ago

    It may not be best idea to propagate succulents in water. Some ppl do, but succulents are low-water plants and often will rot. I never propagate them in water (and have many plants grown from leaves or stem cuttings...I would say that probably 30% of my succulents are grown from cuttings by me. I have many hardy succulents too, and none have been propagated in water...

  • 8 years ago
    I finally had a chance to report this fella. When I took off the gravel, I was surprised at how wet the soil was! Guess my moisture meter wasn’t lying! Messing with the soil, I think I just used it straight out of the bag and didn’t add anything like pearlite to it to make it drain better. I sure did this time! I also put it in a smaller container, and did not cover it with pebbles, just so I can better monitor the soil moisture. A few with the gravel seem to be running moist, but others are always bone dry. ♀️ I’m still learning. Can’t wait to see if this little fella makes a comeback!
  • 8 years ago
    So it’s been a few weeks since I reported this little guy. Doesn’t look GREAT, but he seems to be doing well and the soil always reads dry. There even is some new growth happening!
  • 8 years ago
    Darn it. When I post the pic, it cuts off the part where there is new growth!! I swear its there!
Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner