You need to provide a link or an image, otherwise we can't tell what you're asking about.

Yikes! It's not the wood, it's the mirrors. They give off a kind of bordello vibe.

That headboard is going to be difficult to pair anything with; it's really awkward.

I don't think the shape is right for that curvaceous headboard. I'd look for ovals and/or rounds. Perhaps, even a Bombay.

The headboard is great. It's actually pretty unique - unique scares people sometimes. I think the wood and mirror combo are too busy with the headboard. If you're set on mirror, get one that's mirrored all around and then you won't have to worry about it matching (see photo randomly picked from a cursory search, apparently mirrored bedside tables are pretty popular) ... but I agree with Manon, a round or oval shape would work with the curved shaped sides of your headboard nicely.

Lake Keowee: Smith Private Residence · More Info

Well, if you like the mirrors...wddim? And you know, neither piece 'matches' the floors. It's about design, size, price, need and than match. If the price is right, and the size is too....it's your room..

I would definitely take them back and look for something in an oval shape or round, like what was suggested above me. They would go with your headboard so much better. Here are a couple of ideas:

Emma Mason Signature Cormere Bedside Chest in Honey Walnut · More Info

Monarch Specialties Light Brown Traditional One Drawer Bombay Cabinet · More Info

Hooker Furniture Sanctuary Small Three Drawer Bombe Nightstand · More Info

I think they look great together.

Not liking the mirrors on the front of the drawers or bedside tables that wide in that space with that headboard. You might seriously consider a couple of upscale wood filing cabinets as bedside tables instead.

That said, they do appear to be the same style as your headboard so, if you like them, keep them.

I always did think Audrey was a pretty name! Nice find. Nice match too.

Yes definitely modern nightstands!