Software
Houzz Logo Print
shescomeunstrung

Questioning how my contractor is handling something

8 years ago

Hi folks,


We're in the midst of an upper floor remodel with a contractor who is pretty great overall. But I am questioning the fact that he has scheduled the electricians to trim everything out (fixtures, face plates, etc.) before the painting happens. Confirmed that yes, that would mean the painters would go back and remove all those things (or in some cases with light fixtures, loosen and wrap them), paint, and then reinstall. He claims it is more efficient because then it's less likely that there will be any marring of the paint job that would need touch ups (thus requiring painters to come back). In fact, he has scheduled painting to happen at the very end of the project for that reason.


It sounds to me though like I am paying to have the same work done twice and wasting time to boot.


Just looking for input from others with remodeling experience. This isn't the first major project we've done, and this definitely wasn't an issue in the past. Thanks!

Comments (9)

  • 8 years ago

    OK, yeah, but there's also no requirement that the final electrical inspection happen before painting -- it can happen after just as easily. The schedule is entirely at the contractor's discretion. And now I hear from him that all the door knobs, towel bars, etc. will be installed before painting too, so those will also have to be removed and put back by the painters.

  • 8 years ago

    He claims it is more efficient because then it's less likely that there
    will be any marring of the paint job that would need touch ups (thus
    requiring painters to come back).

    It is only more efficient if he installs those things after painting. How is it more efficient to install them twice? That makes no sense.

  • 8 years ago

    It could be an availability issue with his painter or another trade affecting scheduling. I wouldn’t accept that explanation, or that order of operations, even if it meant a delay. Which it likely will.

    Good trades are in short supply, and sometimes GC’s jump through hoops to keep them happy and their schedules rolling. And they forget the effects that such accommodations have on the overall project and homeowner.

  • 8 years ago

    There is another possible reason(speculation because we cannot talk to the folks involved) I discovered in my experience as a handyman. I often was called to fix small problems most larger companies did not want to handle. One was marred paint from another trade's work. Electricians often are in time constraints, needing to meet scheduling requirements. While that may only mean a ten to fifteen minute difference, it only takes a couple of seconds to scratch a paint job when installing a light fixture or wall plate.

    A painter will be much more careful. And, calling the painter back to fix a problem made days after the paint job will be problematic, since the paint may not be available easily, the painter may be booked, or the time necessary not easily available.

    That could explain the contractor's reason. And, other than trim(base/door/crown/chair) and flooring, painting should be near the end of the job.

    Seems to me the idea is to get the best result, not double cost/work.

  • 8 years ago

    I doubt all the fixtures would need to be removed...they can be wrapped and taped off without harm. Switch plates take minutes with a cordless screwdriver. Blue tape over the receptacles and switches if they are spraying. I think paint should go last unless you are using Aura paint which can be touched up easily without marking (assuming you are rolling).

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, all, for your thoughts. HandyMac, that's basically what my contractor is saying. Maybe I'm just getting cranky with the delays, how slowly he's working on some things, the costs, and the overall intrusiveness of remodeling. Overall the project is going quite smoothly, I have to keep reminding myself of that!


  • 8 years ago

    Someone try to explain again, please, because HandyMac's solution still doesn't make any sense to me. Why put the fixtures on in the first place, if they need to be removed for painting? They can be checked for proper fit/placement without installing. Seems to me that there is more risk of a gouge or scratch in the drywall with multiple installs/removals. Why would they need to be put on prior to painting? The only exception I can see is needing to have the electrician install the light fixtures (although that is really a simple task if the correct wiring is in place -- I've done it many times)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Switch and receptacle faceplates are extremely easy to remove/install. So by putting them on before painting, you are just verifying that you have all of the correct faceplates and that they don't get lost in between the electrician doing that and the painter painting.

    For example, if the electrician were to just place the faceplates on the floor by the receptacle, someone may come along and accidentally kick them out of the way and they get lost before the painter comes to paint. Remember, days or weeks may pass between these two jobs. So by 'installing' them, it's just a safe place to store them.

    Regarding some of the other things, it's more of a matter of the 'not my job' idea. A painter shouldn't be responsible for installing doorknobs. But loosening them, painting, then tightening them could be seen as their responsibility. If they were to install them from scratch, then what if the alignment is off? Is the painter then suppose to adjust the doors? He's a painter, not a carpenter or handy man.

    It isn't about doing the same job twice. It's maximizing the ease with which the appropriate person is available to do the appropriate job.