Software
Houzz Logo Print
marymac1

pleated shades vs cellular

8 years ago
Trying to decide on pleated shades vs cellular. Top down bottom up is an absolute must have for this situation for privacy. I am more drawn to the pleated shades. They look a little more high end to me for some reason but every time I tell someone in the store they try to steer me towards the cellular shades! I just want to make sure I’m not making a mistake and choosing something dated! The windows are covered up with a piece of housewrap right now but I wanted to post that picture so you could see the beams and get a feel for the room. The other picture of the windows was taken before the beams went up :) pardon the cardboard in the window... (it’s blocking the neighbors out)! Would love your all‘s input on how to finish this space! I posted pictures of the rug I am putting in here as well. The wall color is requisite gray SW. trim white dove

Comments (13)

  • 8 years ago
    It may be helpful to note that the floors are red oak stain early American and this is a dining room.
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I have never used the pleated shades, and i could be mistaken but I think they have a tendency to flatten since there is nothing in the stringing to keep the pleats equally spaced. Whereas the cellular shades keep their pleats.



    This above is pleated on the left and cellular on the right


    This is just pleated


    This shows the differecne between single and double cellular shades


    This is ust pleated

    .

  • 8 years ago

    Beverly,

    What would drive a decision to use single vs double cellular?


    following bc I also need shades and am lost.

  • 8 years ago

    Wow, what a beautiful home! You must be so excited. Are you looking at shades for privacy/light control? I never consider shades/blinds as window treatments. They are a necessity that should not be seen whenever possible.

    We have had pleated shades for over 30 years. They have been replaced just one time. Our original ones came from Sears and Penney's. They were very inexpensive. We recently got some for our second home. They were purchased at Home Depot , again very reasonable. They are kept completely up during the day and are pulled down only at night. I greatly dislike the look of shades from the outside because they often look like sheets hanging at the Windows.

    I always have curtains at the Windows so that they add warmth and softness.

  • 8 years ago
    I need the shades for both privacy and light. It is west facing so we need to block the intense light but our windows are very high and low E, and we have awesome spray insulation in the room so I don’t feel like energy efficiency needs to be my driving force. I really want them to look good!!! I am definitely planning on putting drapes up... it will be a large black rod but I’m not sure what curtains I will use yet as I want to see how the room comes together and what I feel like it needs. I don’t want to be pulling the drapes back-and-forth as privacy and sun control. I want to have the shades for that.
  • 8 years ago

    I think the cellular are supposed to be more insulating. But personally I like pleated.

  • 8 years ago
    What do you mean strings running across the glass? Are you referring to the top down bottom up feature when they are lowered from the top? Thanks for your feedback!
  • 8 years ago
    I have decided on cordless top down bottom up cellular, but since the window is 106” total, 72” tall. I am struggling to find a brand that will do a 3 on 1 headrail. They won’t do the cordless feature on that big of a window. Any suggestions
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Will you always want to block that area of the window where the neighbors house is? I'm just wondering if the privacy issue can be resolved with a different approach - furniture.

    Your view and architecture are so very beautiful. I'm concerned cellular shades will bring down the look. I've enjoyed cellular shades in previous homes, but I didn't have a view that the open shades would obscure. (Because of the width they stack up to.)

    I suggest sorting out privacy with a well placed piece of furniture and opt for nice drapery on rods.

  • 8 years ago
    @Benjesbride. Thanks so much for your comments. I totally agree! I’ve thought about the furniture and even a large plant too, but unfortunately our neighbors are a school with a bright red roof and I really feel like it needs to be covered! I am going to put some large fiddle figs in front of the blinds to soften the whole thing. The view in top of the school is great, but the trick is getting past the school!
  • 8 years ago

    Not sure if this was considered regarding furniture. I was thinking something like a high back settee/sofa that covers the same area and leaves the rest of the view in sight. If it's a privacy issue, sheers on a rod with the drapes are a more elegant solution than blinds, IMO.



  • 8 years ago

    I think I'd even prefer plantation shutters on the bottom of the window. You can adjust the louvers to still let in light, but not the view of the school. This avoids the problem of the strings and the stack of shades.