Software
Houzz Logo Print
whycantichangethis

Need advice choosing backsplash

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

Hi all,

We've just closed on our home and I'm struggling with reaching a decision. We're gutting the granite and the backsplash, but I have no idea which tile would match my granite and cabinets nicely. Any advice would be appreciated. The walls have yet to be painted, but we're thinking the lightest color of the granite slab. Thanks!


Photos included are of my current kitchen and of the slab we've purchased to replace current granite.




Comments (20)

  • 8 years ago

    My advice is to wait until the granite is in before you decide on a backsplash. It will look different on the horizontal plane than it does vertically. I just got my counters installed a couple of days ago and all the sample backsplashes that I have before I got the counters don't work at all. I'm starting from scratch.

    But in general I would suggest to keep the backsplash very calm because the granite is so busy. You only want one thing to be the star and it's the granite (which is very pretty - I don't remember coming across that one in my search. What kind is it if you don't mind me asking?)

    j g thanked chocolatebunny123
  • 8 years ago

    I agree with chocolate bunny. I had the same experience when we changed out our counters to granite. Unfortunately, our backsplash was installed while I was at work - came home and saw that it was way too busy with the granite. I ripped it out that night!

    j g thanked 2pups4me
  • 8 years ago

    I am redoing my kitchen now and decided to wait to order the backsplash until counters are in. The counters can look SO different once they are installed with your lighting, etc. This way you are less likely to make a mistake. Good luck!


    j g thanked Sandra Durante
  • 8 years ago

    The other folks who posted here are giving you good advice. I imagine you’ll want to go with a very simple, cream colored ceramic tile for your backsplash but it’s a good idea to wait until the counter is in to decide. If you don’t already have under cabinet lighting, you may also want to do that.

    j g thanked cyc2001
  • 8 years ago
    Are the new and old granite different enough to give you a new look? On my phone they look like the same colors in a different pattern. Make sure you’ll get the change you actually want before spending all that money!
    j g thanked athomeeileen
  • 8 years ago

    If you do want to start getting an idea though, I have a sample that I'm considering for my own kitchen that I think would work with your granite. It's called Imperial Oatmeal glossy ceramic from The Tile Shop.

    https://www.tileshop.com/product/imperial+oatmeal+gloss+ceramic+tile+-+4+x+8+in.do?sortby=ourPicks&from=Search


    j g thanked chocolatebunny123
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I'm not sure why you're replacing one granite with a very similar granite. It's not much of an update. It also looks a little more grey, which seems like it would clash with your tile floors. But wait on the backsplash.

    j g thanked Sina Sadeddin Architectural Design
  • 8 years ago
    I like the oatmeal! Posting so I get a notification when you update us with ur decision. We have very similar kitchens and I’d love to see the outcome of new granite/backsplash. I’ve been at a loss myself trying to keep my cabinets as-is and finding a good granite / backsplash combo
    j g thanked irol96
  • 8 years ago

    i see swirls of your cab color in the granite. i think its an improvement over the old one. it does lean gray which is ok, but i think i would have went a little warmer toned since your cabs are warm.

    that being said, agree with others, wait till its in, then pick a color in the granite for the b/s. pick a plain, quiet tile. less is best in this application since your counter is busy and beautiful, let it be the star!!

    j g thanked sprtphntc7a
  • 8 years ago

    It took me like 6 months to finally decide on a back splash that would go with the granite. My advice is do not get a glass tile. It doesn't look the same on the wall as it does as a sample so it ended up not going well with the granite after all.


    j g thanked Bonnie Muehleman Zone 5b No IL
  • 8 years ago

    I'm changing the granite because it's the home that I plan on spending the rest of my life in, and I'm not in love with it. Sending my husband to the design center alone wasn't the best idea, as none of the tile in my house matches currently :-). I was too busy and ended up with an all beige, mismatched home. I'm more impressed that he managed to choose everything and none of it matching!! It's not grey in person, it's a light beige with the rust tones through it. It won't matter because the floors will be changed in time as well. Thank you all so much for the advice on waiting until it's in, I will update with photos. It's been installed today, but I won't be at my new home until a few hours. Will update with the horizontal and photos from above once I'm there.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Hope everyone had a good day today. Just got home from wrapping everything up, I'm so happy with my choice to change granite. Chocolatebunny123, the color was caramelato from my local stone yard. It's unbelievably beautiful, and these pictures give it no justice. My fabricator managed to get cut it seamlessly, and I'm so thrilled about the difference even though before has similar tones. Even my husband who wanted to keep the granite before is thriled about it. Cyc2001, we're going to be adding under-cabinet lighting later on. Dealing with this beforehand before we can move onto that!! But trust me, we've got that in mind.

    What I've noticed is that the current backsplash that we have matches nicely with the lights on; however, it looks too different with them off.

    This is with them on (excuse all the knick knacks and things on them please, only furniture in our home right now is the coffee table and 2 end tables).

    This is with the lights off, with the 4PM sun and lots of windows.

    The granite is much more beautiful in person, and I'm very thrilled with my choice to switch from a level 1 to a level 3. I think it's a huge difference, and the rust tones throughout pull the cabinets in nicely. They look thrown off in these photos, they're closer to the before above. We think an oatmeal color would look really nice as backsplash, another option is to pull the granite up and do a full granite backsplash.

    Here's a photo of a near perfect tile match that we're using for listello in 2 of our bathrooms (once again, it's a much closer match in person than via cell phone pics).

    So once again: does anyone have any suggestions or ideas to add? I'd appreciate hearing input. Thanks everyone. :-)

  • 8 years ago
    Ps, I think the new granite looks great with your current tile floor too. I know you said it would be changed eventually, but it’s still cool that it looks good in the meantime. :)
    j g thanked skmom
  • 8 years ago

    even though the glass tile may match, its not a good match with your granite. it just visual overload.

    busy granite = simple b/s.

    your eyes need to rest somewhere and with that mosaic, granite & floors, its just too much! keep the mosaic in the bathrooms. go with a solid color picked from the granite. you don't need anything fancy/busy.

    there are many threads on this topic. please read through some of them. there is a lot of great advice from professionals who do this everyday.

    j g thanked sprtphntc7a
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I think you guys are misconstruing the tile pictured as the backsplash we're looking to use. Sorry about that!! To clarify, it's just the listello we're using in 2 of our bathrooms. Not going to be used as backsplash, just added it as well to show the tones in the granite properly. Our options right now for kitchen backsplash are the oatmeal that everyone is suggesting to match the lightest part (which we're hesitant to do because we're painting the walls that color), or doing a full granite backsplash.

  • 8 years ago

    oh ok got it!! so glad u are not considering the mosaic for the kitchen!!

    i think i would do the "oatmeal" b/c it will lighten the kitchen overall. do u have undercab lights? i think painting the walls the same color is fine. there is usually not that much wall space anyway.

    you could do a piece of granite behind the cooktop which is great for clean up, not grout! just an idea.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    We have an open concept, so there's a lot of wall space. The walls are going to be painted the same color as the lightest part of our granite. No under cabinet lights yet, going to be added after the backsplash dilemma is solved. Here's a view of what the area looks like:

    I doodled myself out, this is from before we swapped the granite. We're changing the baseboards and adding crown molding. Windows need the trim as well. Light fixture is being changed. Adding the wooden wrap around the island so it won't be drywall wrapped. Lot of work to do!

    This is the view from the kitchen. Living room where my tables are, and by the bump in the wall we're adding wallpaper or tile and hanging a pool cue rack. We're adding a pool table in front of it. Lighting to be changed as well. Possible wooden beams added to the cutout in ceiling? Uncertain about that for now.

    That's why we're a bit hesitant on doing the lighter beige as backsplash. There's loads of walls around where it is. I don't think the darker kitchen w/ full granite backsplash would be bad seeing how much around it will be light. What do you think?

    Also, sorry if anyone is playing a drinking game for however many times I've said backsplash. I think you guys will be out by now ;-).

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    That granite is a perfect match for your cabinets! I don't usually care for stone with a ton of movement, but yours is gorgeous!

    I'm not sure if this one is too close in color to what you currently have, but there is also a color called Bone in the same Imperial ceramic line at The Tile Shop.

    https://www.tileshop.com/product/imperial+bone+gloss+ceramic+subway+tile+-+4+x+8+in..do?sortby=ourPicksAscend&from=fn

    Edit - I was typing at the same time you're posting. Given that the space is so open, I think a full granite backsplash would be fine. I normally don't care for them as I think they're too busy, but I think it would work in your case.

    j g thanked chocolatebunny123
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Where is Beth H with all her wonderful suggestions/photos? I'll bet she'd have some good ideas to offer.

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert