Software
Houzz Logo Print
chocolatebunny123

Backsplash choices

My countertops are in!


After many, many months of indecision, I decided to go with Hanstone Kindred. I liked other colors better, but it was the one that went best with my existing birch cabinets.


The installers were able to remove the old laminate without disturbing the current 4x4 white ceramic tile backsplash, which I thought was pretty impressive. My husband thinks we should keep what we already have since it's in great shape (and he's afraid of ruining the edges of the cabinets trying to remove it) but I kind of want something else, even though my choices aren't too different.


Here's a far view of the counters. You can see a little bit on the far right how the builder used a full tile at the top so it wraps around the cabinet a bit. This is what my husband is concerned about removing.



Comments (10)

  • 8 years ago

    Here's a closer picture. There is 1/4" gap at the bottom of the backsplash because the laminate countertops were a bit higher. I've been told that if I want to keep the 4x4s, I should be able to get trim pieces to fill in the gap. You can see the tile wrapping around the cabinets here too. As you can see, my window sill is all tiled as well.

    Here's my other choices that I've narrowed it down to.

    I really like these white glass tiles. This one is 3x8 (actually 3x8.75) but it's also available in 3x12.

    Here's a further shot with the cabinet. I plan on taking down the paper towel holder.

  • 8 years ago

    This one is a sparkly one called Cottage Crackle. It's a 3x9 ceramic. I like it but I think overall it would be too busy.

    This last one is a 3x6 ceramic subway, color is called Oatmeal. It is a perfect match for one of the colors in the countertop. It's kind of boring but probably the safest choice.

    Any thoughts or suggestions is appreciated. Overall, am I just better off keeping what I currently have and safe myself the $$$ and the mess of having a new backsplash installed?

  • 8 years ago

    I like the last one best and I think although subtle if it were my kitchen I would change it.

    chocolatebunny123 thanked isabel98
  • 8 years ago
    The old tile, while it matches well, kind of gets lost and almost looks like just a white wall. I like your third choice.
  • 8 years ago

    Karen - it does look like a white wall with the white grout, but I don't usually care for contrasting grout so if I went with the oatmeal ceramic tile, I'd probably use a similar grout, then creating an oatmeal wall.

    I've decided not to use glass tiles at all. I spent over an hour last night reading various posts about how people were so disappointed with how glass tiles had a bluish or greenish hue once installed. I'm going to look at more porcelain or ceramic choices today.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The quartz has a casual feel because of the granite it imitates so I wouldn't use crackle. I like the Oatmeal. It looks like there's some pooling of the glaze on the edges which will give it dimension.

    You might consider changing the gold paint in the adjacent room and working with a cooler color palette in the gray-blue family. Bringing color in there and in accessories might make you feel okay with a plainer tile. I would bring a complementary color and texture in with a fabric window shade since the window is so prominent.

  • 8 years ago
    I also agree changing the paint color would make a big difference!
  • 8 years ago

    Mayflowers and Karen - yes! The paint is going! If I stick with the current white tile, I think it gives me more choices with paint than going with a different tile. The current paint photographed much golder than it is in person (color is SW Whole Wheat).

    I'm considering hiring one of those paint consultants from either BM or SW because I have no idea what paint color to go with, but I thought I would figure out the backsplash situation first. I supposed I could wait and do the backsplash at another time (and touch up paint where needed).

    I picked up 2 more ceramic tiles but they're both too dark. Hubby wants to stick with the white, or go with a different white tile.

    I thought this would be easy...wrong!

  • 8 years ago

    ....it is possible to tile right over your old back splash IF it is in good shape. A good tile guy will know the required material to create a bond between the tiles. If this creates an issue with your window, then it might not work. If you have edge pieces etc see it this is an option. We had a pro do our master bath this way many moons ago and you would never guess.