Software
Houzz Logo Print
rubba_donga

evergreen options for shady area?

8 years ago

I'm looking for some evergreens to plant as a hedge/visual barrier. We have a partially wooded lot, with a backyard then a wooded area behind that. There is a neighbor behind us who has a lot of junk in his yard, and the next road over is somewhat busy, so I'm looking for something that will block out most of that year-round (in WI, so it gets pretty bare in the winter & we can see straight through the wooded area).

The issue I'm running into is finding evergreens that will grow well in shade - it seems like most are for sunny or mostly sunny areas.

The other complication is that we do have quite a few deer. I've heard that they tend to eat arbor vitae, so that wouldn't be a good choice. Any suggestions?



Comments (13)

  • 8 years ago

    evergreens that will grow well in shade


    ==>>>>


    all conifers are full sun ...


    some can TOLERATE certain levels of shade .... but the problem is.. the darker it is.. the slower they grow ....


    so .. if you plant babes in shade.. it might take decades for them to grow to the size needed.. and if you plant large sun grown plants in shade .... they may not stay as full and vigorous as when bought ...


    how about a pic of the actual site.. rather than the drawing .... and is there ANY direct sun???


    ken

    jason s thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 8 years ago

    Some shade tolerance conifers include Hemlock, Yew, Mugo Pine, Norway Spruce, Oriental Spruce.

    jason s thanked stuartlawrence (7b L.I. NY)
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    P. Orientalis Aureospicata in full shade. There are two large trees, eastern white pine and american basswood you cant see that block most of the sun. I think it gets 1-2 hours of direct sun in late afternoon. This tree has been in the ground 4-5 years and is filling in nicely considering it was in poor shape when I bought it (nothing wrong, just not many branches, it was the last one). I planted it with the intent of it taking the place of the dying austrian pine. My neighbor has dawn redwoods up and down her driveway that she planted as bare root cuttings about 15 years ago.


    jason s thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Having problems adding pics to post, lets try a new post.

    Above was recent pic, here is May 25 pic showing new growth (what aureospicata is known for).


    jason s thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks for all the comments! I'll try to get over and take a picture in the next couple days. It's new construction and we haven't actually moved in yet.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    When you take the picture, please get the complete view. You might need to take several slightly overlapping pictures. Keep the camera at the same location for all pics, just pivot.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Full shade P. Abies ‘skylands’ (note, more greenish than yellowish due to shade, plus this is spring pic, that yellow fades to green, now tree is mostly green)

    Full shade skylands. Could be denser on top half (probably whats grown since I planted it 4 years ago) but Im fine with that. It will fill in as well. (I think May pic)

    P. Abies (that had its leader snapped by deer a couple years ago) in full shade. This gets zero direct sun, its all dappled, a bunch of large cottonwoods and silver maples in this area. Vernal pool has started to form. This will be “P. Abies island” for months straight this winter/spring. My conclusion is that p. abies can handle wet feet and shade(at least for 5 years when young, knock on wood)3. Did I say P. Abies is my favorite conifer? Im pretty sure Ive never killed one.

    P. Abies full shade (spring pic, trees in background fuller now plus a bunch of honeysuckle just behind p. abies)

    P. Abies full shade (will be island for months, in vernal pool area). Boardwalk (1 of 2)is so I can get to middle area of property during winter/spring, pretty much everything in pic except where sun is in upper right will fill with water. If I took this pic in march/april, you would see about 8 conifer islands, the boardwalk, and water. (boardwalk will eventually look nice, not a priority).

    P. Abies full shade (all dappled sun, this pic faces north and behind is woods)

    Canadian hemlock in full shade(took 4 years to get a leader). I am procrastinating replanting arborvitae atrovirens.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Abies amabilis has done really well for me in shade. 'Green Giant' is supposed to be deer resistant and shade tolerant. It's been deer resistant, but I have heard others have not been so lucky, I guess depending on how hungry the deer are, and regional differences in what they like to eat. GG does OK in shade, but I'm not too impressed. I planted one in 2012 in a filtered woodland shade situation (not dense, but high/filtered light). It looks decent, but very stunted growth rate, and not particularly dense.

    Thujopsis dolabrata are supposed to be better with shade. If you go with Tsuga, consider diversifolia

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I see canopy gaps and smallness of usually deciduous shade source trees in what is being called "full shade" in posts here. True full shade in a practical sense is a tar pit of constant shade throughout the year.

    The basic set - climate permitting - of garden sized evergreen screening plants for shady places is holly, yew and box. Arborvitae and spruce etc. are climax species in nature that oh so slowly work their way toward the light beneath the taller existing trees in the forest - small specimens trapped in the understorey of old growth conifer stands may be growing fractions of an inch per year, actually be as old as their vastly larger, much more fortuitously placed breathren - that happened to get good light exposure.

    And unless rounded shrubby habit cultivars are chosen for a garden situation all have pointed tops that can set up a visual tension when planted beneath or near existing trees with spreading branches. By looking as though they are poking into the bottoms of the taller trees.

    Anything planted in heavy shade grows at a snail's pace because of the shade, even when the same kinds are more vigorous in stronger light. And has a thin habit. So you may really need to shell out for a solid wood fence to see the desired level of relief anytime soon.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Please post pic of “wooded setting”(how wooded? any evergreens like virginia juniper, p. strobus, etc that could block out winter light?). Sounds like your wooded area is mostly/all deciduous trees and thus not “true full shade”. I am certain these two smaragd never get direct sun when leaves on trees (fence runs south looking into pic)- large silver maple to left, whatever the heck that large juniper is, more dawn redwoods behind the two to right of fence(now, with foliage, branches of dawn redwood rest on fence, go over tops of emerald greens and meet wilth silver maple leaves), plus other larger trees as well that block much of the sun before it even gets to the silver maple, juniper, or dawn redwoods. Highly dappled sun unless late fall, winter, or early spring. These were $5, 1.5-2’ when planted about 4 years ago. Look good to me. Whether or not they will grow pretty well and look good on your property will depend on how wooded is “wooded’, which is why a pic would be nice. I realize this pic is not a “wooded setting”, but they still dont see much sun until oct, nov, dec, jan, feb, mar., april (which is actually quite a bit of sun lol). March 24 pic.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Your fence planting containing narrow pointed habit conifers is going to look markedly less fine when these collide with the spreading branches of the maple to the left. Already the arborvitae(?) at the back of the view is being swallowed by the much larger conifer to the left of it.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    1st “paragraph” refers to above pic.

    Ive been cutting off the ends of maple branches as needed. I cut them back about 1’ from from dawn redwood branches. Then the next year(or whenever I happen to be there with my loppers), the same. Havent touched dawn redwood branches but will as needed. I realize these are young and as time goes on they may not look as good since these are far from ideal conditions (this area is also very wet during winter/spring), but so far they are doing much better than I thought they would when I planted them. Also in pic is a volunteer Virginia juniper that I transplanted. The cut down tree had a large canopy until last year when it was cut down. Everything in pic planted about 4 years ago. Nothing fancy lol, but gotta love it, at least I do(future solar-powered, stream-fed koi pond will go to left and a little down from the two smaragd).

    I pruned the mystery conifer a couple weeks ago. It was not touching the smaragd arborvitae in 1st pic, but on the other side it was swallowing up another smaragd, p. pungens montgomery, thuja occidentalis forever goldy, and a yew. I rarely prune so this was an accomplishment. This is on the other side(does anyone have any idea what this conifer is, Ill take close up pics). P. Orientalis Aureospicata on left. Check out my prune job.