Software
Houzz Logo Print
eld6161

Another WWYD re: texting?

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

DH has a childhood friend who he and his sister grew up with. Although I have met "M" and have seen her on rare occasions, as a couple DH and I have never socialized with her. There is a reason but it is too complicated to go into.

She calls DH from time to time for advice etc. More often than not, I'm ignored. For example, when signing off never saying to say hi to me, or ask how I am.

She called this past week with very sad news. Her daughter was diagnosed with a rare cancer. Prognosis does not look good in this type of cancer.

I texted her and basically said DH told me about "T" and how sorry I was and my prayers were with her. She did not answer the text. I told DH that I texted "M" and did not get a response. Sometimes odd things happen and maybe she didn't receive it. DH said, yes she told me she got your text.

Since this is someone I don't consider a personal friend so I felt a reach out by text was a way to show support. Of course, now I think I should have called.

Have any of you been in this situation?

Comments (40)

  • 8 years ago

    There is no excuse to fail to respond to your text, regardless of whether she or Miss Manners felt it inappropriate (TBH it did not strike me as inappropriate as I read your post, but I can see your point)

    eld6161 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 8 years ago

    Does the reason you don't socialize with her have anything to do with her old feelings towards your husband? Did they date or could she have had a serious "crush" on him which he didn't reciprocate?

    Because of the seriousness nature of her situation, I'd give her a pass even though she's never inquired about you in the past.


    eld6161 thanked Oakley
  • 8 years ago

    When my dad was in the hospital-- and then recovery, I received a lot of texts. An overwhelming number of texts. My siblings and I were constantly texting. Because he's had some recovery issues there were updates (sometimes hourly) on tests, mood, generally how he was doing, how mom is doing, does anyone need anything from the store, etc. At the same time, we were all trying to balance work and home life. Sometimes I wouldn't get to texts from those who were not family or close friends for days-- maybe not great etiquette but it's what I could muster between taking care of his needs, mom's needs, my work demands-- and my own emotional needs.

    I did return most texts-- but honestly, it was a burden. Even when the scariest part was over, there were still many emotions and stresses. My first priority was to my family. I appreciated the well wishes and inquiries.. and I am sure your husband's friend does also. I recommend extending her a break and I encourage you to not make much of it. All her energy is on her daughter/family right now.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I'd also give her a pass under the present circumstances. In fact I would probably continue to send well-wishes occasionally as you hear news about her daughter. No response required.

  • 8 years ago

    Oakley, I didn't want to get into the reason, but......here goes.

    DH and his sister X grew up next store to this family. DH was friends with the brother and X was friends with "M".


    DH's sister is very jealous and years ago made the announcement that we should keep friends and family separate. Although X had a husband she never had children, so never any invites on her part through the years that always involves kids. Mind you, our family consist of a handful of people!


    I alway included X in everything. It became clear early on that X did not want me socializing with her friends.

    A few examples: X said: "M wanted to include you in her daughter's baby shower, but I said why would SHE (meaning me) want to go?" So, I wasn't invited.

    There were a few other incidents and it didn't take me long to see what was going on.


    I decided to clear the air with M. I found out that when I extended an impromptu invite through X to come to a BBQ since everyone was upstate at the time X never told her. But instead told me that she wasn't interested! At this point we decided that we couldn't socialize. After all X is her childhood friend. M meant well and wanted us to be like extended family.


    So all of this is very juvenile and strange. I would have loved for my DD's to have gotten to know M's daughters through the years. We haver such a small family and we are all scattered so this was a sad missed opportunity due to petty jealousy.





  • 8 years ago

    I cannot believe some of the people that people have to put up with. Yikes, ridiculous!

    Oh and of course my focus was on you, Eld, not the woman. I still think she could have texted "thank you".

    Also a shout out for "Caring Bridge". It is a site that allows you to update F&F on a loved one. I did it for a friend who had cancer, at her request. Made things easier.

    eld6161 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    eld, I find that situation very odd.

    I think that "M" is about to discover just how important friends can be, albeit, too late. Too bad it had to be in such a dire situation that her daughter is in.

    Then again, maybe she's just to oblivious.

    eld6161 thanked pudgeder
  • 8 years ago

    There's no telling what X may have told M about you. Maybe not all truthful?

    M could have quickly texted back a Thank You, but we can not control what others do. you did the right thing by reaching out to her.

    eld6161 thanked maddielee
  • 8 years ago

    Definitely a good deal of juvenile behavior going on. I'm sorry about the bad medical news, but what I don't quite understand is that you sent a text, received no response, but in the interim this woman communicated with your husband and told him about your text? It would bother me if my husband was communicating with a woman who had what seems like little regard for me. That she seemed to make no effort even long before the medical issue to befriend you, but calls your husband for advice and such, is odd IMO.

    eld6161 thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Ida, yes odd, but strangely enough it doesn't bother me. This is a woman he has known all his life. M not being friendly with me is as a result of DH's sister.

    But, the reason for my post was to get feedback. Since she did not answer me, I felt that maybe it was not the thing to do and that I should have phoned her.

    Quite honestly, I don't think M means any ill will toward me. When we do happen to see each other we are friendly and cordial.

    And , adding to all this when she does communicate with DH she doesn't mention it to X! And, DH didn't mention that yes M already called to tell him about her daughter when X called to pass on the information.

    So again all strange. But, I have been living with it for 34 years, it's not going to change now!

    Maddie, yes you are right. Things have a way of circling back to me.


    Mtn, thank you for the Caring Bridge referencde. We have friends who used TinyBeans for her premie, so I guess this site is similar.

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks for the explanation. Sounds like X needs Ida to send her a big ole Texas A$$ Whoopin'! Right Ida? lol

    eld6161 thanked Oakley
  • 8 years ago

    I just hope that M's DD will be okay. I would, as someone suggested, send an occasional text or email and just let her knowing that you are thinking of her and her daughter. No response necessary.

    eld6161 thanked blfenton
  • 8 years ago

    It just makes me sad for you. It can be so hard to find friends that we really enjoy being around and it definitly was as you say, a missed opportunity. X should be ashamed of herself and grow up. That said, I’m of the belief that when stuff like that happens, it’s better to confront the issue at that time to make sure it doesn’t happen again. Upon the first wind I caught of X’s behavior, I would have had a conversation with her and set her straight, family or not.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Lukkiirish, I have tried to have heart to heart talks with X. One issue I have is that she lies. And, she really believes her own lies. The lies come into play so that she gets what will suit her.

    Example: We had a niece and her family visiting during the summer. They stayed with us and X came up while they were here. X had an appointment so had to leave to go home (45 minutes away) and planned to come back. I am standing right there and she tells the niece I'll be back at 5:00! Niece and family had plans to sightsee in the area and I didn't want to restrict them to a time frame. But.....

    At exactly five there's X. Of course niece and family came back at five. I was talking to X and said, "You know it would have been nice if they had more time. " She then said "Oh no, K said 5:00!"

    She manipulated the time as it would suit her and then denied she was the one who said it.

    I believe in HER mind, she believes that K was the one who suggested we meet back at 5.

    Another example: When my DD's were small I used to invite her to all the extra curricular activities. She would bring an overnight bag. She claimed that she could not drive at night.

    Until a few years later I caught her in the lie. I said, 'Oh, you drove that far and at night?

    She looked at me stunned. Instead of being honest and saying I really like to spend time with you and my nieces and this is a great getaway for me, she lied her way into it.

    My last example but of course there are many more: I used to have a summer home and one weekend my oldest had a severe ear infection. I was up all night with her. I was exhausted. DH calls and say he is bring X up or the weekend! When she saw the situation, she didn't jump in and help out. I didn't need company that weekend.

    When we had our heart to heart with the above being included, her answer to me was, "Well, we are tired and you had to cook anyway!"

    That was the last time I thought I could try to make things better. Now, I feel she is DH's only sister and he can handle her. They lost the oldest to Multiple Melanoma. DH does everything for her and she lives the lifestyle she does because of him. But, as for me, I l keep my distance, help when I should and try to keep a low profile.

  • 8 years ago

    I've had an X in my life so I emphasize with you. X's are into themselves and do what's good for them no matter who it hurts. I finally was able to get X out of my life.


    Re the text, I just lost my husband and while I tried to respond to every text, call, card, letter, email, I was in such turmoil at the time, I don't know how I could have not missed replying to someone. In fact, I know I did forget to reply to one email. I meant to. I finally did, but it was weeks later. So I would cut her some slack on this. And you did nothing wrong by texting. That seems to be the way people communicate today. (Not my favorite way, but I do it too.) I feel so sorry for her...nothing worse than having a sick child, especially when the future is so bleak.

    eld6161 thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    I would not respond to someone I did not know well if their message contained the word ''prayers''.

  • 8 years ago

    Albert, she knows me for 34 years.

  • 8 years ago

    My intention for this post was to understand if I should have called instead of texting. That texting was possible the wrong thing to do in this case. Which is why she didn't respond.


    But, I think Marlene, you are right. Right now she is overwhelmed and as she should be.

  • 8 years ago

    Eld, sorry for going off track, but I can't let this pass:


    albert_135: I would not respond to someone I did not know well if their message contained the word ''prayers''.


    What the hey??? And this comes from an atheist.

  • 8 years ago

    eld - I thinking texting was fine. As several have mentioned, just keeping track of the texts coming in during a situation like that can be too much. Can you imagine if everyone were calling? Close family and close friends - yes, a call is welcome. Just tell DH to give her your best wishes (or whatever your preferred thoughts are) whenever he contacts her.

    eld6161 thanked rosesstink
  • 8 years ago

    That’s a pretty miserable situation Eld. You must have the patience of a Saint; I seriously doubt I’d be able to handle myself as gracefully. My DH has a sister that was a bit of a handful the couple of times that shes visited but it was mainly due to a cultural difference. For example, the first time I met her, she said hello and immediatly started talking to my husband in their native tongue; he quickly chimed in and said, speak English so my wife is included and I appreciated that.

    As for your text, I can only imagine how overwhelmed and upset M must be, I wouldn’t take it personal. It doesn’t matter that it was a text, you did a nice thing, the right thing by sending your sincere note.

    eld6161 thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Wow Albert that really isn’t very nice.

  • 8 years ago

    X's are like brain worms.

    You did the right thing. As hard as it is ...let it go. Her daughter has cancer so that shouldn't stop you from being kind or offering a kindness. We can't let brain worms stop us from being good.

    eld6161 thanked just_terrilynn
  • 8 years ago

    My dad died in August. It was very sudden to me and the situation was complicated. I got a number of texts, emails and voicemails that I didn't have the energy to respond. I also got a bunch of BS involving other people's agendas.

    Frankly, I didn't (and still don't) have time/energy to deal with it. My expectation is that folks know I appreciate they are thinking about me and don't need any additional effort from me right now.

    Based on my personal experience, I would say this is your issue to get over with. If you didn't want to offer some genuine support, then that's on you. If you did, then you accomplished that so move on. She has bigger fish to fry.

    eld6161 thanked 1929Spanish-GW
  • 8 years ago

    So sorry for your loss Spanish!

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Terri. I really just wanted to make the point from the other side of the situation.

    eld6161 thanked 1929Spanish-GW
  • 8 years ago

    I'm sorry about your dad, Spanish.

    And I do agree with you. I think eld was kind to send a text, regardless of their past or current relationship. Having a child diagnosed with a bad cancer isn't something I'd wish on anyone. That's a very heavy cross to bear. At this point, I wouldn't expect the usual niceties we come to expect in less trying times. You did a nice thing and that should be it, there should be no expectation of a reply in kind. And then I'd let it go, and give thanks for your blessings.

    eld6161 thanked Bunny
  • 8 years ago

    I think sending a text was a kind gesture, that’s how most people communicate these days. She may not feel like “talking” just now. Your X sounds just like my MIL. Brain worm is a good description. She was so disruptive and manipulative that their church women’s group had to disband rather than have to eject her, especially since her DD’s FIL was the minister. She’s still up to her old tricks to this day.

    eld6161 thanked Saypoint zone 6 CT
  • 8 years ago

    I have insomnia tonight and it's 2:30 am, so if I seem too nosy chalk it up to that. While eating dinner tonight I thought about your situation. M not replying to your text doesn't bother me, that's normal behavior.


    But why has she calling your husband over the years? I know they're childhood friends, but it's bad manners if she isn't welcoming to you. I'm sure it's innocent on your husband's part, but frankly, she needs to lay off and find her own husband, or does she have one?

  • 8 years ago

    To me, you don't have a SIL problem, you have a DH problem. Why does he allow his sister and old neighbor to disrespecct his wife? He needs to stand up for YOU. Why do go along with this? And you invite her into your home?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Personally I would have responded to your text. But that's me and I'm old fashioned. However many individuals feel that a text is an informal, quick communication tool and don't necessarily feel that they need to respond.

    As for whether you should have called instead of texted - do you often telephone her? Since you said that you don't consider her a personal friend then a phone call wasn't necessary.

    Perhaps you'd like to send her a 'thinking of you' card at some time.

    eld6161 thanked maire_cate
  • 8 years ago

    This has turned int a whole other conversation. I am perfectly fine the way things are. I gave you the history so that you would understand my level of friendship with M and why it is the way it is.

    I also understanding M calling DH as he is a fund of information and really is a go to person for many for advise on a multiple of things.


    M and I are cordial and friendly when we see each other at events etc.


    Marie, my thought was that M was "insulted" that I texted instead of calling. As a simple TY response doesn't take long. However, of course she has bigger fish to fry and I was only seeking opinions here as I try to do the right thing.


    Rather, I don't feel disrespected. With SIL, well there are issues, but none I can't handle.



  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    In these circumstances, I would not call or text--I would send a card. At times when I've felt particularly overwhelmed, every text ding or ringing phone can feel like an additional burden, because it usually requires some kind of response regardless of whether the recipient is up to it. When someone gets a card they can open it when they're ready. So the sender knows they've reached out and acknowledged the pain/loss, with no expectations on the recipient.

  • 8 years ago

    I agree that sending a card is much better than sending a text. I find text messages tend to be impersonal and often annoying. I've told my friends and relatives not to text me - they should call and talk with me if they need to tell me something. I use texts just to send links or addresses - I do not find it a nice way to communicate with friends, unless there is absolutely no other way. Email is okay, but still more impersonal, although it is easier for me to respond to email than texts.

  • 8 years ago

    Please correct me if I am wrong, but it was SIL who wanted friends and family to be "separate". Perhaps SIL has made this sentiment clear to her friend which translates to how the friend reacts to you. SIL has a lot of power. To be honest, I think you are being a much better person than I to reach out to the friend regarding her daughter's illness. The method of contact is immaterial to me. The friend may be reeling from the diagnosis and unable to respond. You wouldn't look for a response from a thinking of you card. Sorry if I sound critical, but the situation has an interesting dynamic.

  • 8 years ago

    I don’t like talking on the phone anymore. I much prefer to text or email which doesn’t require both parties to be available at the same time.

    eld6161 thanked Bunny
  • 8 years ago

    But, the reason for my post was to get feedback. Since she did not answer me, I felt that maybe it was not the thing to do and that I should have phoned her.

    This was how I understood your post. It was a narrow question of, "are texts in appropriate in this situation?" I also thought that the only reason you mentioned that she did not reply, was because you thought the lack of reply may have been because she was offended , because a text is too impersonal.

    No, you were not wrong to text.

    I also still feel that she was "wrong" to not at least text back "thanks". It takes seconds to do that. I understand that some people may be unable to get around to that in a crisis, and I am not saying it is a cardinal sin. But IMHO if you read a text you have a second to simply reply "thank you". Not necessarily right away, but eventually.

    eld6161 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 8 years ago

    Rather, I thought I made it clear. Yes, the reason why I couldn't develop my own relationship with M was because X did not want me to.

    So when M and I realized exactly what was going on, the invitations stopped.


    Mtn, thanks. This why I like coming here :)

  • 8 years ago

    eld I think you did the right thing -you did what your heart told you to do

    you probably don't phone her often-so maybe felt less natural to phone

    yes maybe a card is the right way to go-but depends on one's culture and what one's used to do..it'd be the last thing to come to me, to send a card, upon hearing someone's devastating diagnosis. I'd feel an impulse to react-and it might be that would take me time to think about a card even.

    you did what felt right to you in the moment. she also did what felt right to her in the moment-which was probably doing nothing as she's so distraught

    yes I'd probably text very fast "thanks" as I'm almost always answering.. but who knows what we'd really do, under circumstances such and such

    you texted as you felt strongly and your thoughts were with her, and that's what you did. and she is in the state it's hard for her to answer..maybe to talk in any manner, whatever it might be.


    I must add-I don't really like talking on the phone(with few exceptions), or texting, or Skyping, or many other things

    I do appreciate people's kindness in whatever form it comes. I don't expect it to be tailored to me. They do what they feel right at the moment.

    I'm kinda sure she does too


    these are all details, hard to get them perfectly right. Nothing is right about this situation. It's devastating, and rarely one can say something that's more than a sign of "I'm with you". And whoever's going through this, he understands it, and he doesn't expect more, or less, or differently, or..He knows. Or so I think.


    I lost somebody dear to me recently. I was so ...in short I wrote about it to some friends. I had to put it in words somehow, to stop sobbing, Nobody but one answered anything at all. It's okay. What could have they said? They were there to read. Maybe. And writing helped.


    whatever you did was fine, whatever she did not was fine too-even though it left you with this sense of maybe you offended her or something

    you didn't.

    she knows.

    I hope her daughter beats the disease I hate with all my guts, and its gloomy statistics and..whatever you wish for them I wish and hope, and yes, pray-because that's what people do sometimes, it's about the intention, and we all have our ways to express it.


    Spanish. hugs..


    (see, even writing here-I feel it's all silly and inadequate. What can you do. You word something-you loose something. with a slight hope others will get the sign. of your intention)



    eld6161 thanked aprilneverends