Software
Houzz Logo Print
grace_lim39

Best pot for a succulent?

8 years ago

I know this may be a silly question but I haven’t rly found a good answer for it. They say succulents should be grown in a pot slightly wider than itself? However my succulents are about 8-9cm wide and I was wondering if housing them in 8cm diameter pots would be ok, or should I house them in wider pots instead? It’s been pretty difficult for me to find nice pots with good drainage holes in Singapore.

Comments (14)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I dont know what do you expect from pots. I recycle old plastic nursery pots , and can often find the right sizes i need , with large drainage holes, which i also need. I prefer square ones, since they sort of look more orderly, but there are more sizes for round ones.

    I dont use clay or any other material as pots, since it is a bother to report a lot of my 300 plants.

    I dont know why people use that rule "bigger than the plant" , but my take, since plants vary in size, speed, and height, the best way is to orient with the size of the bigger pot is to factor mainly the ROOTBALL of the plant, and then see if you need to get a way bigger or less bigger pot than its already in depending on the plant itself.

    Eg, its not the same if you plant a slow growing ferocactus and a bryophyllum kalanchoe in a same size pot, with the same rootball. The pot cannot cope with the bryphyllums fast growing speed, and the size will eventually break the pot, or topple over, where as the barrel will grow slowly and just fine in the same time period. Same goes if you placed a creeping or falling succulent, a graptopetalum paraguyanese will overgrow the pot in no time.

    So, the how depends on what, where, and when.

    Grace Lim thanked Stefan
  • 8 years ago

    It's best to make the decision based on each plant. Trust your own judgment. If it has a tiny root ball but the plant is big, it still cannot take an oversized pot because excess soil around the rootball will just hold moisture and not dry out well. Stefan is right, you can re-use nursery pot or basically anything which has a hole in the bottom or in which you can make a hole(s). I don't care for clear containers though.

    Grace Lim thanked socks
  • 8 years ago

    I tested one on a myrtillocactus. No problem with the plant itself, but the pot lost a piece when i moved it. Think the heat and the sun made it brittle. Only useful for orchids i think....

    Grace Lim thanked Stefan
  • 8 years ago

    Can I check the root ball by digging up the plant a bit? Or do I have to remove the whole plant from the pot to check? The pots they’re in right now are very fitting, in the sense that I can barely even see the soil.

  • 8 years ago

    Before buying, i often check the roots of the plant by removing the whole thing from the pot. If i cant, usually the soil is too soggy(bad) or roots have exited the pot from bellow (good).

    Grace Lim thanked Stefan
  • 8 years ago

    We all have our own preferences - I use unglazed terracotta pots exclusively now. Lots of my Mexican desert cacti have deep taproots, and I use Long Tom pots for those.

    Standard 4" pot and a 4" Long Tom.

    With a coarse grit mix, naturally.





































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































    Grace Lim thanked SpanishFly - (Mediterranean)
  • 8 years ago

    I grow indoors only & use both clay & plastic for my succulents, depends on the plants.


    Haworthias & Gasterias mostly in clay, Aloes in both, Hoyas in plastic pots seated in clay for the added weight, Sans, in either depending on their size.


    How can one assess root ball size w/ just a peek? Sorry, you have to lift the whole thing out to know for sure.


    I'd suggest proper drainage holes are key, over & above a 'nice' pot, which if a MUST HAVE could be a 2nd, outer pot in which to place the potted plant, w/ at least one inch of space btwn the 2 pots for air circulation.

    Grace Lim thanked Karen S. (7b, NYC)
  • 8 years ago

    @Karen S.

    I actually managed to find a rather nice pot with a relatively large drainage hole at the bottom! Of course I would totally choose functionality over looks, won’t be choosing hole-less pots anytime soon.

    Noticed most pots that have drainage holes don’t come with a saucer? Cus obviously my succulents are indoors I wouldn’t want to have water dripping from the bottom and making a mess. I’ll check it frequently to make sure it’s not sitting in water to prevent reabsorption, also getting drainage mesh to cover that hole.

  • 8 years ago

    @gdinie your plants all look so good! Wish my house had more green like yours :)

  • 8 years ago

    No, sorry to say they don't usually come w/ saucers. I use old plastic lids from containers of ice cream. I've learned to improvise other plastic lids or jar covers as saucers under everything.

    Grace Lim thanked Karen S. (7b, NYC)
  • 8 years ago

    Grace, thank you. The plants are usually outside, and for the winter most of them are in a cold unused bedroom. I just brought them in for the day, as it was too wet and cold. I wish I could grow them inside without lights...

  • 8 years ago

    gdin - like the long tommie !!


  • 8 years ago

    Thank you, Fly. I got it in a boxful of terra cotta pots someone gave me. It is just perfect for the Ariocarpus.