Software
Houzz Logo Print
kathleenja

Any ideas as to how can we prevent people from falling down the step?

7 years ago

I am posting this to try to help my neighbors who recently spent a lot of $ modernizing their 1970s-era home. The home has a raised L-shaped entry. They removed the original wrought-iron railings, took out the carpet and installed tile. It's gorgeous! The "only" problem is that when you come in the front door, you cannot see the step DOWN! It is clearly visible when walking UP the step, so I don't think that is a problem. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated! We tried adding little strips of lights, or colored tile or a rug to help delineate the step down, but they didn't seem to do the trick. We don't want people falling down but really hate to start tearing up their beautiful new tile job!

This side shouldn't be a problem as the step is clearly visible.

This is what you see as you walk in the front door. Unless you're really paying attention, you would not see the step down.


Comments (19)

  • 7 years ago

    Ooh, that IS a real danger. Suggest adding a black, wall-mounted "railing" in place of the console table. That should be enough to indicate the change in level. Another option is a very low container with knee-high plants. If the planter isn't visible from the upper level it will also alert someone to the change. I truly hate these one-or-two-step "features".

    Kathleen Austin thanked chiflipper
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I think one of the two black line of tiles has to come out. That is a big problem you are right. So dangerous, especially for seniors. That is a broken hip for sure.

    Kathleen Austin thanked Lauren Jacobsen Design
  • 7 years ago

    I'd be contacting a custom metal worker and getting a handrail installed on each side. I couldn't negotiate a step without something to hold on to


    Kathleen Austin thanked Mary Ellen
  • 7 years ago

    I don't know how you can "fix " that without re-tiling. That was not good thinking on the part of whoever did that. Whenever there is a change is elevation in an open step like that, you need a change in flooring in some way to indicate that. If you don't have that, then you need a railing so that people see that and realize what is happening. The only other thing you can do there is get large urn type vases and create a visual "railing" by putting two urns on the top step on either side of the opening, and then two more on the lower step on either side of the opening. That will draw people's eyes down to look at the urns and they will see the difference in heights. Lighting will also be necessary, I could see putting wall lights in low on the walls to highlight the step.

    Kathleen Austin thanked cpaul1
  • 7 years ago

    We have a step like that in our house and when we first looked at the house, I feel down and unfortunately grabbed onto a couch, as I fell and twisted my arm. I broke my arm in a spiral fracture and tore my rotator cufff. We ended up being the house because we loved it dearly despite my broken bones. We had a blue border painted on the top step which defined it from the bottom step. No one has fallen since.


    Kathleen Austin thanked Virginia Vidoni
  • 7 years ago
    Yellow safety tape? Not a good look, but would significantly increase safety. One step down like this is a safety factor in any design.
    Kathleen Austin thanked mainenell
  • 7 years ago
    Hi, in my opinion a rail would ruin the look they are going for. Chairrail trim is a good option and will help outline that there is a step there. It can also add a touch of class to the home
    Kathleen Austin thanked Jacob Retana
  • 7 years ago
    Another pic
    Kathleen Austin thanked Jacob Retana
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    That is an accident waiting to happen and a lawsuit for the homeowners who have created a dangerous condition.

    The black with black creates an optical illusion of there being no step.

    The safest way to proceed is to get a really gorgeous handrail - this would alert people to the change in elevation AND provide a much needed safety feature because there are people who cannot safely go up even one step without having a rail of some kind to help with balance. Function and safety trumps whatever look they thought they were going for.

    Kathleen Austin thanked Helen
  • 7 years ago
    I would remove the black tile from the lower level.
    Kathleen Austin thanked indigoheaven
  • 7 years ago

    we had a step down like that; basically whenever we had guests i'd guide them to the step one at a time and point it out... 'there's a step down here, watch out'.


    that worked ok, no one fell, but i solved the problem by moving. never will i ever have a home with a step down again. also, no appliance garages.

    Kathleen Austin thanked Judy Mishkin
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Removal of the black strip on the lower part will help a lot

    Kathleen Austin thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 7 years ago

    Can they install stair lights on the riser? At least that will alert people that there is a step if kept on 24/7. I wouldn't imagine LEDs would eat up that much electricity.

    Kathleen Austin thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    Thank you to ALL who have offered help. I will be sharing every suggestion with my neighbors. I don't get to choose what gets done, but I do think removing the black tile on the bottom will help a lot. I also think at least 1 handrail would be a wise idea. I never would have thought of the chair rail, but I think that is a very creative and smart idea. Thank you so much for all your ideas. I hope to let you know what they do choose to do after the work is completed.

  • 7 years ago
    I would suggest handing them a printed copy of all of these suggestions.

    Their home is beautiful, but I agree that this step is a broken ankle waiting to happen. and, I think that a hand rail, while helpful, is insufficient.
    Kathleen Austin thanked indigoheaven
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I don't think a chair rail is sufficient - my opinion. Some people would not be looking at the walls when entering a home and even if they saw the chair rail, it might not register as meaning there was a step down.

    I really think an attractive hand rail is the only safe solution - because it is a universal signal to everyone that there is a step and because it provides a necessary aid to any visitors who need a rail to help them go up and down a step. There are some people who have difficulties going up and down a curb without some form of balancing aid - your step is pretty much the equivalent of a curb.

    Kathleen Austin thanked Helen
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Try etsy.com for a possible solution. I had this decal made for a client’s cellar stairway which was a huge accident waiting to happen. It is a rental, so doubly important for the unfamiliar tenant.


    Monument · More Info


    Artists are clever and I bet someone could come up with some kind of warning in a nice design.

    At the landing below there was another dangerous step which was not code. I had the carpenter hammer shiny upholstery tacks every three inches at the edge of the steps.




    Kathleen Austin thanked JudyG Designs
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    ???? bull nose stair treads with adhesive backing in two colors.


    Kathleen Austin thanked JudyG Designs