Software
Houzz Logo Print
sbs1717

Does anyone have experience or own a mechanical home elevator ?

8 years ago

I just found out the hydraulic elevator equipment will not fit in the garage. I am rebuilding along the Jersey shore and my BFE ( base flood elevation) is 10' and I only have 36"above the BFE, the equipment needs 45" . My builder says to go with a mechanical elevator. I research everything and It is hard to find info on the mechanical ones. Everyone I know who has an elevator has the hydraulic. I really have no choice here but i would like to know......

If you have a mechanical elevator what are your thoughts....do you like it?

Do you know the manufacturer?

I would like to know if they are noisy? What is the maintenance on them each year and how expensive is it to maintain?

Thank you

Comments (6)

  • 7 years ago

    Did you ever find a solution? I am just starting the research for a home elevator in a new build, in order to make the home accessible in the Florida Keys.

    BFE is also 10’, but the ground level is only garage space. I need the elevator to get to the first floor which is raised over 14 feet from ground level.

    Any ideas or info would be helpful. Thanks.

  • 7 years ago

    Gulf Coast (Bolivar Peninsula/Galveston) new homes are using 'exterior lift' which is, of course, on the exterior! and they will go up as far as 14' I think. There is a manufacturer/seller in Florida.


  • 7 years ago

    I'm not sure what you mean by a "mechanical" elevator. Would a cable drum elevator be what you're thinking? Perfectly fine, and probably preferable in your case to a hydraulic one.

    Inclinator makes a good one. And the drum can go above, below, or to the side of the elevator, which would eliminate your flood issue.

  • 7 years ago

    Note that Thyssen is OUT of the residential elevator market in the US (used to have the LEV product). Apparently, they gave up after some lawsuit.

    I've got a Garaventa lift. I called just about all that were available in NC when I was building my home and I'm happy with my choice. Mine is the straight "winding drum" The motor sits on top of the rails at the top fo the shaft and there's a small control box that sits above the elevator door at the top level as well. The only thing coming from the outside of the shaft are the two power (one 240 for the mechanical, one 120v for the lighting) and the phone line (the elevator has a phone in the panel).


  • 7 years ago

    A cabin close to my cabin has an electric cable drum lift. Someone on this site asked about non hydraulic lifts, so I looked at the lift. It cost about $10k, 5-7 years ago, not including installation. The lift company is in Florida, the lift is designed to be used as a cargo lift at a boat dock. The lift is not certified for human cargo. The name of the company was something similar to: loadmaster, cargomaster, liftmaster. 500 lb rating. The owner of the cabin uses a wheelchair, I have seen the woman and a helper use the lift.

    12’ lift, motors and drums on on the top. The cage is Aluminum, not sure what the posts are made out of.