Software
Houzz Logo Print
cpacker

New water supply will be $$$

7 years ago

Has anybody else faced this problem? I tore down my old

house and am rebuilding on the same site. Code requires that I

upgrade the water supply line. This means going into the street.

It's hard to find a contractor in D.C. to do this. The result is

that estimates range from $40K to $60K. Does this sound about

right?


Comments (30)

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Too many variables to tell. Are you required to have a new tap to water supply ... or there is a well with a meter somewhere and you need to run pipe into that well. Call the water company, tell them what are you trying to do ... normally they are very helpful. They could also provide you with the names of contractors who do this kind of work ( just tell them you are not looking for recommendation) just names. Here new tap fee is 4k, upgrade is 1k. Water company can also do the work (or hire out) for $$$$ tap +move meter well at $/ft.

  • 7 years ago

    Can you provide some more details? Where I build water tap on ranges from $1500 to $2000, For new construction.

  • 7 years ago

    My job will require cutting into the street and replacing the existing supply line and then fixing the street. It's a residential area in Washington, D.C. The contractor will have to obtain all necessary permits for public-space work. The total new pipe length both public-space and private-space length is about 50 feet to the foundation of the new house. A house down the street had that done and it looks like they had to repave the entire width of the two-lane street.

  • 7 years ago

    Sounds crazy. I had a sewer line replaced for $5k.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Sounds like a crazy price. If it is that high I want a break down from the bids on how much of that cost is permitting and such. Permits should be a set price across whoever you pick. That way you can compare prices better.

    Interesting looking at this page for fees. Only sewer taps are marked for contractors being responsible for "Contractors are responsible for excavation, backfilling, and repaving."

    I wander if water tap costs other than the fee are covered by city where they have pit on your property. Then you cover cost from pit to house.

    https://www.dcwater.com/fee-schedule

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Seems like you could get a separate bid from a paving contactor to cut and repave the street. Then get a bid for the 50' of water line with the paving removed.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    The water runs right down the middle of the street in my neighborhood in my KY city. There is no "asphalt to the side" - it's an asphalt street with no sidewalks or curbs.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    The water meter that connects to your house is in the middle of the street?

  • 7 years ago

    So BT is correct - there are too many unknowns for us to answer well.

    This all varies based on your location. In my neck of the woods, new service requires that the customer hire a contractor to install everything from the main, to the meter pit, to the house. Tap fees are variable but range from a few hundred to several thousand.

    Backfilling and road repaving is the responsibility of the contractor and the main could be on the other side of the street.

    On subsequent repairs, the homeowner is typically responsible only to the meter pit or shutoff (if the meter is inside).

    BT is also correct about asking for names but specifically not asking for recommendations. Our utility says clearly that they don't make recommendations.


  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    sambah, of course the meter is not! I'm talking about the water line. The line that connects it to my property, runs off of that. The meter is buried in the front yard, just beyond the 15' easement. The the main line runs from the meter to the house (in the basement).

  • 7 years ago

    So, just to be clear, are you sure you have to replace all the way to the main line? Is it possible you just need to go from the house to the meter pit?


    My guess is that you have to replace it because:

    1. it's lead

    2. it's galvanized

    3. it's undersized


    If any of those are the case you will probably have to replace it to the main. If not, ( for example, you need to replace it because it will enter the wrong location) you may be good just replacing it to the meter pit.

  • 7 years ago

    Sounds crazy high to me, but plumbing always does. Several thoughts:

    - Do it right. Never, never skimp on plumbing (or electrical) ... you'll just end up paying to fix it later, and that's more expensive than doing it right this time.

    - Could you possibly save something by tearing out the old pipes yourself? Tearing things out doesn't require the same skill as installation. My husband isn't particularly good at fixing things in the house, but he says, "I can destroy things."

    - Get several estimates.

  • 7 years ago

    We need ALOT more info!! Breakdown? Ditto what Mrs Pete said.

  • 7 years ago

    Talk to your contractors that did the estimates and ask them what they are assuming in that estimate. The main may be on the other side of the street, or it may be very deep. In DC there are probably additional costs for signage and redirecting traffic while the work is being performed. Also the streets in some parts of DC are of course over 200 years old. It may not just be a matter or removing a little asphalt and gravel and digging a hole. I've seen some old street cross sections during excavations where there is asphalt on top of concrete on top of brick and there may even be some heavy timber in the mix. Also the main may be so old that it is made out of archaic materials and therefore more difficult to connect to. In all these cases you will need to ask the contractor for clarification.


    Also, if I remember DC permit costs are based on the cost of the job. So the assumed cost of the permit may be growing with the estimate. This will increase the range of the estimates.

  • 7 years ago

    Given the amount of surprise this has generated, I've put the

    relevant plans on my website:

    http://cpacker.org/water.pdf

    (It's 25mb, but see pages 7 and 8 if you can get it)

    and the two estimates that my builder passed along to me:

    http://cpacker.org/water-est1.pdf

    http://cpacker.org/water-est2.pdf

    One is about $40K and the other is...$68K!


    The background is this: My builder didn't include the water and

    sewer hookups in his scope of work. (At the time, I didn't ask why -- my

    architect had leaned on me to go with his favored builder rather than

    put his plans out for bid. I decided, what the hell, it'll all go

    smoother this way.) So when he hit me with the news of the costs,

    I assumed that they weren't out of line, considering that it means

    cutting into the street and repairing it. He warned me that it was

    hard to find contractors to do this kind of job. This is indeed what

    I have found.


    The job is basically to upgrade the water service from 3/4" to

    1.5" from main to house and attach a required cleanout to the existing sewer

    line. The mains are under the middle of the street. The street construction

    lacks complications warned about by poster AFox.


    As to the suggestions to separate the job into

    plumbing and street work myself -- I wouldn't know how to

    coordinate that -- I'm not a GC!. Should I go to the contractors whose

    estimates I have at hand and request detailed breakdowns?


  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    The first estimate: What is the 20 ton of CR6 (crushed rock) for? Then too what is $6,800 for a clean out? Did you ask them how many man hours? How many days do they see this project taking?


    It could be nobody wants to do this work in DC.

  • 7 years ago

    Your price is not surprising. Welcome to the world the average home owner doesn't usually play in. If county/city is requiring you to go into the street to up-size the line, you are essentially taking on the "developer" responsibilities as a single home owner. This is a different caliber of costs, different caliber of contractor, and there is typically no leeway with requirements.


    Paving a road to traffic standards is a different ball game than paving an asphalt driveway, and costs will reflect that. Frequently, lines are run in the road per county/city requirement so no surprise this is where the main is.


    Whenever you tie into or impact existing infrastructure, cities/counties use it as an opportunity to upgrade current infrastructure, meet new zoning/code requirements, etc. This is how cities/counties get a large amount of road/utilities and their improvements paid for by the private sector, usually developers. But in this case, you are "developer".


    It's not that no one wants to do the work, rather there are only a handful of contractors who are qualified and do this level of work, and they don't get paid peanuts. These are not the same contractors who actually contribute to building your SFH. Therefore, it shouldn't be expected that an architect or regular builder could have provided estimates for this (they don't know what they don't know or encounter frequently).


    Ask for a more itemized bid so you can attempt to compare apples to apples among bids, but don't expect this will be in the ball park of line installs on private property.


    It wouldn't hurt to contact your municipality and see if there is any way around this requirement. It's generally cheaper to buy an easement and take a different route, sell a kidney, just about anything other than impacting public infrastructure.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    What HU-129265525 is kinda right... this is what a developer would normally deal with.

    But to his point: Why are you dealing with this at all? Isn't this your GC's problem? Your GC should know what contractors to use and what's reasonable, etc. I don't think you should get bids - etc... I think you need to remove yourself from it and let your GC earn his keep.

    I don't agree with some of the other that HU-129265525 said or suggested. Your Tap fees are very reasonable (cheap even). I also don't agree that the Architect/GC couldn't have known - of course they've dealt with tear downs in your area before!

    Even so, the price seems really high -- but as a homeowner you aren't in a position to know what's reasonable or to evaluate bids or contractors. That's the GC's job.

    Also, what's with the homeowner providing the bond?

    Here's what I would say to your GC/Architect: "Guys, you should have seen this coming and I'm pissed... I hired you so we could avoid $70k surprises and so we are not off to a good start at all. Now, Mr GC - you need to get quotes on this and $70k isn't in the realm of 'reasonable'."

    Yeah, $6,800 for a cleanout is crazy - esp when the equipment is there. Was $1250 in my neck of the woods and the equipment wasn't already there.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    You know, the more that I understand the bigger story, the more angry I'm getting about this.

    I would absolutely get both the GC and the architect in the same room and ask them WTF!

    Seriously!

    They are supposed to be overseeing this job - the ENTIRE THING. That they left the water and sewer off of the contract isn't acceptable. Of Course they should know what's involved in a tear-down! They should know the codes, the contractors, what's usual and customary, all of it. THATS WHY YOU HIRED THEM and not your cousin, Buba. That they left this $70k "surprise!" out of the contract is just total BS! If they don't know this stuff then they are the wrong team for the job - and I'd make sure that they heard that loud and clear!

    You are going to have to put out some extra money - they aren't going to eat that amount. But they need to know they f'ed up bad... and they better be finding a cheaper contractor.

    Here's something else they should have known: If that existing sewer is tile (the house was built in 20's... so it is), you want a mostly new sewer run - not just a cleanout. You don't want to build a new house and connect it to a 100 year old tile sewer lateral that those trees have been sending roots into. Old tile sewers are like old wiring... they seriously suck, but they really suck when you start tapping into them and making modifications (like a cleanout). You will be ripping up your yard again in no time. You may not need to go out into the street, but you want from the sidewalk to the house to be new.

    I looked at Google Street view - that's a simple residential street - not a historic area, not brick, not a six lane road... Traffic control will be minimal. That contractor is out of his mind -- and your GC better get on the ball and figure this crap out.

    BTW: You need to set expectations clearly up front and not let this crap slide or it's going to be a very painful project. DO NOT ASSUME RESPONSIBILITY THAT'S NOT YOURS! Don't get bids, don't micromanage, don't own problems that aren't yours to own -- including this one. You are going to be writing a check... but definitely NOT a $70k check... and you want new PVC sewer to the sidewalk. It's up to them to own this problem and figure it out.

  • 7 years ago

    Just suppose: 3 men X 40 hrs = 120 man hours * $50 hr = $6,000 labor. Then add machine time and materials - say another $6,000. Then add $3,000 for profit = $15,000 for the job.


    There should be no connection fees since the water and sewer were already connected.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I pretty much hate it when someone avoids a possible path to success because they don't know how to do something. . . .you learn if the money you can save makes it worthwhile. I think you can take the requirements and 'talk' to a paving contractor. If he can do the cut, dig and repave at a much lower price you ask him about scheduling. And if he has a preferred plumber he likes. Or some other possibility he can enlighten you about. He is capable of assisting you to get the job. In fact he'll have to help to get the job. So the right guy will. You have to move forward to get to that point.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    geoffrey_b you are not wrong... but yeah, there will be tap fees since it's going to a 1.5" pipe from 3/4". But the tap fees for the water were $325 and for the sewer $660 (you probably wouldn't go all the way to the main sewer, but to the sidewalk - so no tap fee for sewer).

    There would be permits, bonding, backfill, paving and sidewalk repair. I also think you are low on your labor costs. So let's make it a $25-30k job just for grins and giggles. Note: The first proposed bid required the homeowner to bond to the city for the street cut AND provide insurance (OH! HELL! NO!).

    Also note that the first proposal should just be tossed - it doesn't meet the specs called for in the documents (2" poly when the specs call for 1.5" type k copper). It doesn't actually address any of the specs in the drawing (meter pit, curb stop, split for fire service, etc) like the second proposal did. The second proposal did actually address the sewer correctly as spec'd in the drawings,

    -Note I believe both quotes are only responsible for temporary patch of the asphalt and sidewalk - not permanent restoration.

    -There appears to be a street cut bond - that I'm assuming is to insure the street and sidewalk are permanently restored - which will be done by someone else. This is paid by the owner because the owner is ultimately responsible for restoring the pavement. My guess is that this is a cash deposit that is returned after a period (say, $20k held for 12 months, for example) or it's a non-refundable percentage.

    -Note there will be an additional cost of permanently restoring the street and sidewalk.

    Also note that the City is clearly strict about protecting existing trees and silt containment - and that's not in the these contracts. This all has to be coordinated by the GC.

    Again - this is all WAY outside the scope of a homeowner and completely under the scope of the GC.

    So here's another issue I'm seeing: The architect spec'd all this out, provided drawings, etc. How did the GC leave this off the contract?!?

    Again to the OP: Other than writing a check (something considerably less than $70k) and smacking this team upside the head - really hard - this is not your problem or responsibility and it's completely out of your area of expertise. You hired people to deal with this - don't take this on. Also know that the $70k bid isn't the complete job, there's still the pavement restoration and the mater of the street cut bond - as well as misc DDot permits.

    Even if your GC said "water and sewer connection are not in the scope of the bid but will be handled separately" both the GC and the architect should have given you a non-binding allowance for that work so you aren't surprised by it. If they have done this before and know it's $30-60k, for example, that's potentially 10% of a $600k construction budget and not something that should be a surprise. You just ate up a big chunk of your contingency allowance before the first stick of lumber has been cut -- and that's completely BS since it was entirely foreseeable by them.

  • 7 years ago

    I dont know if this helps, but I had two septic tanks that I abandoned to hook up to city sewer. It was a big job. I also wanted to bury an overhead electric line. For these jobs, I got recommendations from the city for contractors, but they were not residential contractors. I believe these were contractors the developers use. First thing I would do is call the city back and ask if there is no way to get around this. Dont be afraid to point out the cost. If you dont feel the person is knowledgeable ask to speak to someone else. Then ask for a list of contractors who can do that sort of work.

  • 7 years ago

    geo.....you MUST BE UNION!!!!!!! FIFTY dollars an HOUR???????????????? That's INSANE for a labor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And then you add a TINY amount of profit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! VERRRRRRRRRRRRY TINY amount of profit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! That's a scam!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 7 years ago

    Ah, there's Robin. We've missed all those exclamation points. Or something.

    I strongly suspect that this will be (like many things in real estate) - location, location, location.

    So, for comparison, about 7 years ago, I had to replace the sewer line from the house to the road. This meant it went through the sidewalk, and all the way to the center of the street. I had to pay for all of that to be replaced afterwards. Total cost $7.5K It would be now it would be closer to $10K. So that gives you a very rough ballpark for materials and labor.

    NOW - we're building a new house. Permitting will run us... Oh, probably around $2K. Compare that to someone building out in Portland or Seattle or Cali - where anywhere for $20-$80K would not be unusual PLUS the cost of structural engineers and landscape architects, etc.

    So, the difference between by $10K and the OP's $40K lies in fees imposed by the city, PITA imposed by the contractors because they have to spend so much time DEALING with the city to get it done, and the inflation that arises when competition is stifled by the requirement to use "approved" contractors. And also graft.

    Basically, that's a "major urban area" premium you've got going on there.

  • 7 years ago

    My builder might have thought he was doing me a favor by not

    including the water and sewer hookup in his contract. He

    mentioned that thereby I wouldn't have to pay his markup.

    Anyway, I've found online a list of pre-approved contractors

    that DC Water uses. I'll look into whether I could get a waiver,

    but I'm not optimistic. Actually, I'd rather be able to get a

    waiver on the sprinkler system mandated for all new residential

    construction! Thanks for all the help.


  • 7 years ago

    Wow, so if you are moving ahead with doing this yourself, you are really asking for a lot of trouble. You are not in the position to evaluate these bids or know what's reasonable and customary, how to handle insurance and bonding, etc. There are contracts on either side of this that need to be coordinated also (silt containment and permanent pavement repair, for example).


    Dude, your contractor did NOT do you a favor. That was a complete BS line. Fine that he would have marked it up - he's actually adding value by managing that (as you are beginning to see).

    Leaving a big chunk of construction costs off the budget is not a favor it's an "oversight".


    It's becoming more and more clear that your contractor is a problem - you need to call him out.

  • 7 years ago

    Actually, I'd rather be able to get a waiver on the sprinkler system mandated for all new residential construction!


    All these cities want affordable housing - then they have mandates like sprinklers, and possibly ridiculous fees/requirements to hook up and existing residential property.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Yeah, I'm with you on the residential sprinklers - that's a tough one to get behind.

    I do know that time to flashover on on new construction / furnishings is crazy short compared to older materials (wool, wood, etc) - about 1-2 minutes before there is no way to get out. Even in the best of circumstances you wouldn't have fire truck there yet.

    That said, most residential fires are in older homes due to wiring and such - not the newer homes with sprinklers.

    Also, I see that trade organizations (companies with a buck to make) are often the ones pushing some of the new regs.

    I get it that when you do a tear down, you need to bring the water line and the sewer up to standards. Get rid of any lead pipe, etc.

    So far, I've been amazed that the city fees have been reasonable in this case... I know we haven't seen breakdowns on the permits and such, but the crazy prices so far are coming from the contractors.