Software
Houzz Logo Print
cailgirl123

How are your Ikea kitchen cabinet fronts holding up?

7 years ago

I am designing an Ikea kitchen and would like advice from people who have had Ikea cabinet fronts for at least several years. I had planned on using the Lerhyttan light gray, which are lacquered solid birch and birch veneer. The color is temporarily discontinued, but probably will be back soon enough for me to use it. I am having some doubts about the color though so have begun considering other materials.


I was told today at Ikea that a new pure matte white shaker style front will be available in the next couple months. I believe it'll be melamine foil (like Voxtorp), but might also be painted finish (like Bodbyn).


A friend of mine has an Ikea kitchen with white melamine fronts that's about 10 years old and some of her melamine is peeling from heat or water exposure. I would love to hear how people's cabinet fronts are holding up. If you respond, please tell me how old your kitchen is, name of your fronts, and the material your fronts are made of.


Thanks in advance.

Comments (38)

  • 7 years ago

    I put some in about 8 or 9 years ago and they’ve got some ugly chipping and peeling. I don’t remember the name, but it was one of the simplest (and cheapest) white flat door styles. I noticed some minor flaws in a couple of doors and wish I’d dealt with it then, because they have been chipping and peeling for years. I also see damage near the dishwasher, which is not surprising. You’re smart to ask. If I had it to do over again, I would have opened the boxes to inspect them right away. We live pretty far from the closest ikea, so it wouldn’t have been easy to make the exchange. It was a stopgap kitchen solution for this house, and the boxes and hardware have all held up fine. The order wasn’t even big enough to warrant pro delivery. But it’s always bugged me, especially because i could see a little bit of bubbling on the finish at that spot. Oh well. They’ll move to the garage whenever we get real cabinets in the kitchen. Maybe it’s easier to handle exchanges now that they do shipping? Good luck!

  • 7 years ago

    p.s. I wonder if your friend has the same cabinets. Sounds familiar, and similar age too. I’ll look to see if I have the door style in my files.

  • 7 years ago

    following

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Ikea has different lines.

    Avoid thermafoil doors. Known to peel overtime. This is an example of thermafoil, unsure of brand.





    Suggest getting solid wood doors or high quality MDF. They hold up better & can be easily touched up or repainted years later.

  • 7 years ago

    We have Adel Birch doors that are 11 years old, but from the old Akurum line. The poly around the sides near dishwasher and a couple drawer tops is starting to wear away and should be sanded/re-applied but otherwise I think they've held up well to our relatively heavy use. If you can afford better quality doors+ikea carcasses I recommend that route because it makes replacements easier if Ikea decides to discontinue your doors...

  • 7 years ago
    I have a $10 a door IKEA black brown style with horizontal graining that still looks new after 5 years in a rental. I believe it's some type of foil.
  • 7 years ago
    artistsharonva Are the doors you pictured from Ikea?
  • 7 years ago

    Ours are doing really well. They are in a rental we own, flat front lacquer style. They still look great after 8 years.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    That's a picture of thermafoil. I'm not sure which brand. I edit the post to say unknown brand, to avoid any confusion.


    However, I thought it was relevant to show what thermafoil is since IKEA offers foil cabinets in Class 2. If doing IKEA, I suggest only Class 1.

    There are different for IKEA.

    Class 1: real wood + MDF. At this time, only four lines of IKEA doors contain any amount of real wood, and no doors are made entirely of solid natural wood.

    LAXARBY and BJORKET lines: door frames are solid birch; door panels arebirch veneer on particleboard.

    FILIPSTAD line: door frames are solid oak; door panels are oak veneer on particleboard.

    EKESTAT line: door edges are solid oak or ash; door panels are oak veneer on particleboard.

    Class 2: MDF + foil. This class is the main category of IKEA doors, with melamine foil and/or thermofoil applied to a fiberboard base.

    RINGHULT line: fiberboard and melamine foil.

    GRIMSLOV and MARSTA lines: fiberboard, foil, and melamine foil.

    BROKHLT, JARSTA, and EDSERUM lines: particleboard and foil.

    TINGSYRD and HAGGEBY lines: particleboard, polypropylene, and melamine

    https://www.thespruce.com/ikea-kitchen-cabinets-are-made-of-1822041

  • 7 years ago
    Thanks. I saw that post too but it isn't updated and I'm not sure class necessarily corresponds with durability as much as it does with production costs. I'm hoping more people with Ikea fronts chime in. Thanks!
  • 7 years ago

    I put Lidingo (Akurum’s version of Bodbyn) in my last house in 2014. We lived there for two years with my very active family of 6 + St Bernard, and then sold that house to a friend two years ago. They’re still in perfect shape.

    Two years ago we put Torhamn in our basement kitchenette. Also still in perfect shape.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Ditto what Patricia Colwell Consulting and cailgirl123 said above.

    artistsharonva - the classification of the Ringhult and other high gloss finishes as "class 2" is really misleading.

    Ikea's high gloss finishes such as the Ringhult, while technically thermafoil, are worlds apart from typical thermafoil fronts. The finish is thicker, and very hard and is really really difficult to damage.

    The Ringhult is Ikea's best selling door line, despite this, good luck trying to find one bad review on the web. And it's not as if this finish hadn't been around for a long time. With the older Akurum line, the Ringhult was called Abstrakt and had been sold for about 20 years. We have the white Abstrakt in an upscale condo in the city that has been rented out for more than 15 years, yet that kitchen looks like it did when new, only the stone countertops have some discoloration and a chip or two.

    We also have had the Ikea Godmorgon vanity in the same high gloss finish in our kid's bathroom for about 10 years, it also looks like new. Not a scratch, and most certainly no delamination.

    Easiest finish to clean. Also, good to know, white glossy finishes do not look busy, fingerprints don't show other than from very specific angles.

    Also, according to the kitchen staff at Ikea Schaumburg, should the finish have scratches or been dulled by agressive cleaners, turtle wax or plastic polishing compound will restore the shine just as it does on cars.

    And, we just put in an Ikea white Ringhult kitchen in our house last spring. I still love this finish as much as when we put it into the rental apartment years ago. The look just can't be beat for modern spaces.

    About 12 years ago we added 3 Akurum Nexus birch pullout pantries to our kitchen as a stop gap measure until we finally remodeled and expanded our kitchen this spring.

    We took them out and re-used them in the mud room and a walk in closet. One door has some tiny dings, and the doors have darkened a bit over the years. Otherwise they're in beautiful condition. As birch is a somewhat soft wood, the sides had a 1/8" hard beech wood edge that has really helped to protect the edges from inevitable dings.

    I wish Ikea would bring back the Akurum Nexus fronts for the Sektion. they were beautiful.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Thermafoil is subpar to painted solid wood or solid mdf. I have seen to many thermafoils fail by peeling in the field that needed to be replaced, therefore I never recommend it to my clients in a kitchen. If you're going to get IKEA get the higher class.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I have the new ikea cabinets with the bodbyn fronts. Its been a year and a half so not the time your looking for but they show no wear as of yet. Mynext door neighbor has some other brand of cabinets same time frame and they are beat to hack looking. We both have a family of 4...

  • 7 years ago

    I installed Akurum Adel Birch in two rentals 6 1/2 years ago. They are in perfect condition. This past summer a tenant moved out that was a messy cook and horribly filthy. I had to scrub grease layers off the cabinets. They cleaned beautifully and allowed me a thorough inspection. I’m amazed at the quality and the fact the kitchen still looks brand new!

    i installed Akurum Lindigo on the perimeter and Ramsjo Black/Brown in my kitchen 4 1/2 years ago and I love them. They also clean beautifully, especially the Lindigo. They also look brand new. I have mostly glass uppers (even flanking the range), and despite what everyone says about keeping glass clean, I have no issues.

    I then installed Bodbyn in my daughters kitchen 2 years ago. They are the same as the Lindigo except minor differences in dimensions. They are performing just like mine, a breeze to keep clean and in perfect condition.

  • 7 years ago

    Not all thermafoils are created equal. There has been much improvement in material quality and bonding techniques recent years. Cheap is cheap whether paint finish or other.

  • 7 years ago

    bbtrix / I Miss Sophie Do you know what material the Adel Birch, Lindigo, or Ramsjo is? I think Ramsjo is real wood. I'm particularly interested if Adel or Lindigo are thermafoil. Thanks.

  • 7 years ago

    My Adel is Birch wood. Grimslov replaced Adel in Sektion. I don’t know if they changed the material, but don’t think so. Here is what the cabs looked like after I finish cleaning them this past summer.

    The Lindigo is painted, likely mdf or fiberboard, definitely not thermafoil. Very sturdy. I like it so much which is why I chose Bodbyn for my latest remodel. The Ramsjo is wood. Laxarby replaced Ramsjo. I like it too but the Lindigo is more carefree with spills.

    All of my kitchen cabinets are holding up better than my sis’s 3 year old custom kitchen in her $mil home.

  • 7 years ago
    Thank you!
  • 7 years ago

    My old beech wood doors, installed in 2003, still looked great when we sold three years ago. Wish they still had that lovely medium wood color now, I'd use it again.

  • 7 years ago
    Was Adel solid wood and veneer? Grimslov is Fiberboard, Foil, Melamine foil, so if Adel is that also and holding up well, that's really useful!
  • 7 years ago

    The Grimslov White and Birch are completely different. The Grimslov Birch is solid and veneer Birch wood just like the Adel. No melamine in the Grimslov Birch. https://m.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/art/10405321/

  • 7 years ago

    bbtrix / I Miss Sophie Thank you. That makes a lot more sense. To summarize for others reading this thread from here and other similar threads ... For Ikea fronts, it seems like the solid/veneer wood is a safe bet and people seem to also find the painted fiberboard reliable. I'm not a huge fan of the latter b/c it seems very shiny to me. I don't think I saw anyone with Ikea melamine foil posting that they've experienced problems, but general consensus seems to be that they are most likely (though not likely) of all the Ikea fronts to have problems mostly water/heat related. People also seem to think Ikea melamine foil is higher quality than most out there.


    Thanks everyone.

  • 7 years ago

    I have had Ikea upper cabinets in my laundry room for 9-10 years, and they have held up fine (they do not get the same kind of use as kitchen cabinets, though). They have yellowed slightly over time.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I have one of my oldest clients that I called to see if they still had their Ikea kitchen. THe answer was a resounding yes and they 5 kids who are now all out of the house but that kitchen was installed 22 yrs ago and she still loves it but would now go many more drawers for case cabinets.

  • 7 years ago

    12 year old wood veneer ikea (flat slab door) going strong. Only damage is what we’ve done to it (accidental scrape and one wrong drilled hole). Not a large kitchen and every day use, two kids.

  • 7 years ago

    I have had 2 sets of IKEA cabinets in my GARAGE for 12+ years. One gets used EVERY day for dog walking stuff. The other large pantry type cabinets hold overflow costco toilet paper, etc. Honestly - they still look brand new. (Garage is NOT climate controls and we are in NC - can you say HUMIDITY?) I have a small run in the basement 7+ years and that also looks brand new - but that's in conditioned space and very lightly used.

    My brother redid his kitchen 5+ years ago. (2 adults, 2-3 LARGE dogs) It still looks stellar.

    These are 3 reasons I decided to go with IKEA for my new build. Additionally, by sticking with stock sizes / IKEA cabs, I can truly replace all the doors in a weekend in my new build and completely change the style of my kitchen if I so desire.

  • 7 years ago
    Patricia Colwell and just_janni Can you share if the cabs are veneer, painted fiberboard, or melamine foil?
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Just chiming in (as a contractor who's designed/installed scores of IKEA kitchens) to endorse what others have said in this thread: Stick to the solid/veneered-wood doors or painted MDF doors, but avoid the thermofoil doors. Or use custom doors and IKEA frames.


    My oldest IKEA installation (Akurum Adel Medium Brown) is now 17 years old and has held up beautifully to this day.

  • 7 years ago

    Just checking in on this to see if there are any new Houzzers who have had different experiences...since we're about to press the GO button on a new IKEA kitchen...and Godmorgon in two bathrooms.. thanks!

  • 7 years ago

    Mittens - which doors are planning to get?



  • 6 years ago

    We bought the full kitchen plus the otr microwave. If I install it with the spacer piece then about 1/2 to 3/4 of an inch of the black portion of the microwave will stick out. Is this right? Seems only the stainless door portion should be out past the cupboard.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    @Jason De Marco - Not sure what you mean by "spacer piece" but many OTR microwaves do stick out well beyond cabinet door depth.

  • 4 years ago

    In 2015 I replaced peeling, delaminating, Lidingo base cabinet doors originally installed in 2008 (at my expense -- the Ikea store in Schaumburg, IL told me that the warranty does not cover normal wear and tear damage from kitchen moisture). Now the base cabinet doors are peeling again. At this point I am looking for a company that makes solid wood replacement door fronts for Akurum cabinets.

  • 4 years ago

    Marsha - check Scherr's, they make doors to specs for IKEA cabinets.

    https://www.scherrs.com/contents/en-us/d88_Working-With-IKEA-Products.html

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks. I will take a look.