Software
Houzz Logo Print
steven_mitchell76

LVP for small space

7 years ago

First off I'll say that my remodel is middle of the road cost-wise; I am very budget oriented, but also want quality materials. In Canada, I don't have access to some of the more popular brands common in the U.S., and the flooring I've posted below seems to be some of the best i've been able to find, in my price range.


So, I am debating 3 different colours of LVP from 2 different companies, both are stone-plastic composite (SPC) w. backing. I could use some help. https://imgur.com/a/zZxGcg7 


Relevant details about the space:


- 540 sq. ft apartment

- East facing windows (direct sun until noon only)

- New Ikea Kitchen w. Grimslov grey cabinets and stainless appliances


I am a cyclist and bring my bikes inside - generally I value durability above any other flooring characteristics such as "foot feel".


The flooring:


- The white flooring on the left is from the local builders flooring centre; it is apparently made for them by http://simbaflooringcorp.com/. It is 5mm thick, has foam backing and a 12mil wear layer. The sales rep says it meets high environmental regulations, but I can't find any additional information other than the spec sheet provided by the rep. This product has a good warranty, but I question the reputation/longevity of the manufacturer. Price is $2.79 sq. ft.

- The other two floors are made in Canada by Bieulieu (https://www.beaulieucanada.com/en/flooring-products/engineeredluxuryvinyl/2130). As far as I can tell, this is the highest quality available from this company; lifetime warranty, pthalate free, responsible manufacturing practices, high 3rd party ratings, lifetime warranty, cork backing and a 22mil wear layer, etc. Again, I can't find much info about the specific product beyond the manufacturer website, but at least I know that Beaulieu is a reputable company. Price is $3.79 sq. ft. (cdn.)


I prefer the white floor, although the Beaulieu samples do look very nice as far as wood knock-offs go. In my small and dark space, white floors seem appealing, but all other indicators suggest that the Beaulieu is likely the better choice. Can I make a welcoming space with a darker floor?


Not sure what to do - would love to hear some thoughts.

Comments (13)

  • 7 years ago
    Post pictures of product - we are just guessing how light is light and how dark is dark. The question is also all other elements - are you reusing furniture and how that works into the scheme of things. In concept a dark floor can work better IF the other elements harmonize and you have good lighting. Dark floors show dust light floors show scuffs and dirt (thinking of your bike). Pick your poison on that in relation to your housekeeping standards. But best to post photos of both products in your space in multiple areas for us to comment on them from a design perspective.
  • 7 years ago
    And if you haven’t taken samples home to study in your space that is a must.
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    As commented above, you need to post photos of the actual floor you are considering as opposed to the manufacturer’ss site as you did in the first instance. Download their image of what you are considering and post here. It does take a bit for the photos to post. Wait for them to go from grayed out to full color before hitting submit.

    That said, the wood grain you posted second is midrange not dark in color to my eye and I doubt will show a lot of dirt. I would never want a white floor, personally, since it would never look clean. I live in a rural area with a gravel drive, so YMMV depending on your shoes and the surfaces outside your home.

  • 7 years ago

    @thinkdesignlive and @NHBabs


    Sorry you two - I'd posted an Imgur link of the samples in my space, but it didn't seem to work. I've taken a bunch more pictures with the natural light that I have atm.


    > The question is also all other elements - are you reusing furniture and how that works into the scheme of things. In concept a dark floor can work better IF the other elements harmonize and you have good lighting.


    At this point I just have a hodgepodge of furniture. I certainly wouldn't base decisions off what I have. At some point in the future, this will probably become a rental.









  • 7 years ago
    Middle for sure as well just based on color. Definitely no to the white and the other looks too cool grey. Will not be a tone that will stand the rest of time.
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    The middle one definitely! This will give the inviting welcoming warmth you are looking for without being dark. Personally, I agree with the other poster, the white would drive me crazy with every single small spec of dirt. The gray one on the right isn’t bad but the middle one seems to balance the clean IKEA grimslov and stainless aesthetic and will give you a little contrast you need so everything is not gray. And these are not dark by any means.

    One more thing to consider, if you choose one of the 2 Beaulieu, is there a way for you to see more planks to assess the color variation light to dark, plank to plank? Color aside, then I would choose whichever of the 2 have the most acceptable variation to you. Hope that helps!

  • 7 years ago

    I agree with everyones assessment that the middle one is, in a sense, the most versatile (least likely to offend or be a PITA). I very much want to love the white, but recognize it's short comings.


    @thinkdesignlive

    >the other looks too cool grey. Will not be a tone that will stand the rest of time.


    Agreed.


    @ishop19

    > if you choose one of the 2 Beaulieu, is there a way for you to see more planks to assess the color variation light to dark, plank to plank?


    Yup, already saw the 5 pieces together. No huge variation, 5 different prints, so its certainly no worse than anything else available in that price range.


    Thanks everyone.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    @thinkdesignlove,

    @ishop19, and

    @lindsey (still misses Sophie)

    One last comparison - I grabbed 2 more samples from another vendor. Maybe you can chime in before I pull the plug.

    Specs are very similar, price is comparable; another "off brand". Customer service was exceptional.









  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Well. That tile changes things a bit.

    The top left sample in your last picture looks best with your tile on my screen. The natural wood one that I liked originally looks better with your cabs imo.

    So based on what I see here, either of those two choices will be fine. Just depends on whether you want your floors to flow perfectly or whether you would rather have your cabinets really "sing." But again, neither of those two would look bad.

    Any of the other samples are absolutely not in the running.

    Eta: if the tile is being replaced, absolutely go with the medium brown from the original batch of photos.

  • 7 years ago
    I agree w Lindsey’s take on it
  • 7 years ago

    To clarify - the tile (actually vinyl sheet) is being covered. The LVP will run continuously through the space.


    This is such a strange process, in the showroom I loved the new grey sample - but the second I got it in my suite realized it is much too cold. I appreciate your opinions - I would be lost without guidance. Thank you so much.

  • 7 years ago

    Yep, I agree with lindsey (still misses Sophie) also!