Which one do you like? That's the only thing that counts. You're the only one who's ever going to see it, not some random people on the internet. Buy what you like. Done.

Your are right! I should have known better than to ask for advice from random people on this website.

Hi Lasvca - I had Mckenna and it looked beautiful in the photos on-line but when I got it home it was this heavy canvas almost faded looking duvet. Did not like it. I got another one, can’t remember the name and it was the same way. I got a very beautiful one and for much cheaper & nicer material from...yea, I’m a little embarrassed but Pottery Barn Teen!!

Also the vision for your room sounds lovely! Just my taste too. :)