Software
Houzz Logo Print
andrewjagor

Torn: Brick Mantel Shelf vs. Rustic Beam

7 years ago
Hi all,

Really on the fence here and wanted to see if you guys could weigh in on the aesthetic pros and cons. I have a very generous friend who has just renovated a 200 y/o barn and is offering me a roughly 7”x8” beam to use as a fireplace mantel. I currently have a brick mantel in my house and am wondering, purely from an aesthetic/design standpoint, which would look better. I have someone who can come pull my brick mantel out and relay the bricks to make the hearth one flush brick wall onto which I could then mount the beam and corbels. When the brick mason came by, I couldn’t help but appreciate the clean look of the current mantel - I don’t want to remove some architectural detail just to have something that may be deemed trendy in 5 years. On the flip side, I think a wooden beam may tie in nicely to my decor and be a really nice addition to the otherwise all white brick fireplace. Thoughts? I’ve included pictures of my current mantel as well as close approximations to what it could look like.

I placed another wood beam I have (smaller than what would be used as the mantel) to give a visual in the space.
Rustic Beam
Protruding Brick

Comments (17)

  • 7 years ago

    I think the beam is lovely, but a bit small for your fireplace. The one in your inspiration picture is about twice the size.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Houssaon- The op said this was a smaller beam (for visual purposes) than what would be used.


    You have a lovely space! How much would these changes cost?

  • 7 years ago

    I can't vote because it all depends on scale. I would want to see the actual beam. The one you show is too small. The one in your inspiration photo looks good.

  • 7 years ago

    I'd want it to be this big:


  • 7 years ago

    Well the TV kind of spoils the effect, so might as well keep what you've got.


  • 7 years ago
    I agree with gracie01. The brick mantle is fine as it is. You do not need to spend any money on it.
    Installing a beam to go with your decor is the wrong reason to my way of thinking. Installing a beam as an architectural detail that is in keeping with the style of the house would be a better reason.
    Is there some other way you can use the beam in your home or on your patio?
  • 7 years ago

    I think the brick mantle is fine . . . and it's timeless. Big beams will come and go. And when it's gone, you'll wish you had the brick back! Is there somewhere else you can use it?

  • 7 years ago
    gracie01 - not really the most helpful comment. I prioritized having an open space in exchange for putting a tv over my mantel. I realize it’s not optimal, but it is what it is.

    The beam I’ve shown is an extra one that I have - not the one I would use.

    The cost to remove the brick shelf and relay bricks flush with the rest of the hearth is around $275. I’m purely asking from an aesthetic/design perspective which would look better.
  • 7 years ago

    The wood mantle would update the space and tie in nicely with your floors.

  • 7 years ago

    I like the look of the rustic beam and how it works with your flooring...at least on my monitor. The size in grover's example looks good.

  • 7 years ago

    Yes for the beam.....if you think it is the right size.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Gracie-That was quite rude and unnecessary .


    I like your current set up. Is there another place you can use the beam? Picture ledge somewhere?

  • 7 years ago

    Your TV is perfectly fine where it is, and I love the beam! The mockup by Grover looks great.

  • 7 years ago

    I think you've made the right decision. I like the beam idea but you're right that it could be a trend that will quickly fade out (or not, who knows).

  • 7 years ago

    Love what you have....and love the inspiration pic lol. Think you made the right decision though, yours is unique. (from one Atlanta homeowner to another).


  • 7 years ago
    ..