Charcoal grey or navy would look great with your brick and creamy trim.

I like the two offered suggestions. Go with your gut....you can always change it.

Something like BM Tarrytown Green can work nicely with brick.

Hi there!

You should whitewash the brick for a rustic look with character. From there, you can play around with color on the shutters - a dark green or blue would really pop! PPG's "Admirality" or "Nightwatch" would be my top suggestions.

Meghan

Here are some colors from Benjamin Moore.

I'm pretty sure I used Stuart Gold on my front door. I get lot of compliments.

Here is a green.

I like the Tarrytown, houssaon. I also like the Old Navy and Cheating Heart.

I would keep the red door but go for a softer look with the shutters. I used a gray green.

This is Tarrytown Green on my brother's brick colonial (shutters and door). The brick's a bit different, but I think Tarrytown would work nicely with the OP's house, too.

Tarrytown is a classic. I like it too.

Thank you everyone for your thoughts and recommendations! I really appreciate it!

Consider painting the porch framing a whiter white because the frames of your windows show and are a bright white, which you cannot change. But to have the 2 whites makes the porch trim look grim. The shutter color choices offered above are great. Choose what YOU like best, or look for your own ideas.