Software
Houzz Logo Print
editoria

When to replace my oil burner?

7 years ago

My oil burner is 16.5 years old. It works fine, but the guy who services it every fall says it's outliving its expected lifespan and I should replace it this summer. He recommends switching to propane. I haven't decided about the switch, but either way, since I'm in the process of having a new roof put on the house, I'm reluctant to take on another major expense this year. So I'm wondering if I can safely put it off.

The oil burner hasn't had a lot of heavy use. I heated mostly with wood for many years, using the oil burner to heat up the house in the morning and then turning it off. At night I turned the thermostat down, so in winter it might kick on during the night. I stopped using the woodstove two years ago, so the oil burner has been getting normal use since then.

The service man says dampness, not heavy use, is what kills an oil burner--and my basement is an old, dirt-floor dungeon. Definitely on the damp side, although when the oil burner is running it heats the basement and that helps.

Do you think I should be in a hurry to get a new oil burner (or propane furnace)? Thank you!

Comments (10)

  • 7 years ago

    this is oil fueled furnace? What age? What location? No, I see no immediate reason to consider replacing current system. While propane may be a bit less expensive and more efficient, this is a more a decision for you and your financial situation.


    IMO

    Alisande thanked tigerdunes
  • 7 years ago

    I recommend you replace your service company and not your oil burner. He is giving you bad advice. If the burner is operating properly then there no need to replace it. Switching to propane would be expensive and you likely will not save in heating costs.

    Alisande thanked mike_home
  • 7 years ago

    That's reassuring, Mike. When the oil burner does fail at some point, I imagine it would be more difficult to replace it during the winter (snow makes everything harder, it seems), but not impossible, yes?

  • 7 years ago

    If you have the burner serviced each fall then the probability of it failing during the middle of the winter is low. A competent oil burner technician will replace the nozzle and filter as needed. The motor should last many years especially if you supplement the heat with a wood stove.

    Does this tech work for a fuel oil company? I find it strange he is encouraging you to switch to propane. Maybe he doesn't know what he is doing and wants you to switch before you find out he has been doing a poor job of maintaining the oil burner. The whole thing seems suspicious.

  • 7 years ago

    He's part of a small, family-owned company that installs and services both oil and gas heaters. They put a propane heater (wall unit) in my barn in 2002, and I knew them even before that.

    It was his suggestion to replace the oil burner because it was nearing the end of its lifespan, but I may have been the one who brought up propane. Several people had told me it was more economical as it's cheaper per gallon, and he agreed. But when I researched it I found it's not that simple.

  • 7 years ago

    A gallon of oil may be more expensive but it delivers more BTUs of heat. A cost calculation can be done if you post the prices.


    I don’t have an oil burner but I would expect a life expectancy of 25 - 30 years.

    Alisande thanked mike_home
  • 7 years ago

    Don't forget, you'll need to remove the oil tank and properly dispose of the contents to switch. (The cost could be somewhere between zero and a whole lot... YMMV.)

    Also, renting or owning a propane tank has its own set of costs.

    I'd join the other folks above in the notion that you should replace a furnace at 16.5 years because it's getting old is nonsense... keep it serviced and hang on to it.

    Alisande thanked User
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I agree with getting a second opinion.

    One matter not mentioned by the others is that the heat exchanger should be inspected for cracks/holes. Was that done already? So long as it looks normal and the tech says it's otherwise operating and firing properly, you can rest assured it is safe and perfectly okay to continue using.

    Alisande thanked Elmer J Fudd
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks for all the input--I appreciate it! I assume the heat exchanger inspection is apart of his annual inspection; I don't recall him mentioning any cracks or holes. The estimate he gave me for a propane burner included removal of the oil tanks (two of them = 500 gal.), but he said we could just leave them in the basement if I wanted. I would be inclined to do that. They would be as empty as I could get them at that point. But it isn't a sure thing I would switch to propane anyway.


    A second opinion is a good idea, and I'll follow up on it.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Re the basement oil tanks... as I said above it conceivably might cost zero to dispose of them and their contents. You can check. That space may have a better use. (As part of the replacement, almost assuredly you will be required to remove any filling and vent pipes running to the outside.)

    Alisande thanked User