I don't think either is quite right. If I HAD to choose between the two, I think the first one looks better than the one with the iron scrollwork, which doesn't seem to go with the transom at all. The leaded glass is a bit better with the transom but still looks a bit like an afterthought. Are there any other options you can consider?

One of groveraxle's would be better because the window is so prominent

2nd option if we must choose between those two.

Groveraxel those are great, but what type of glass can I place for privacy? I don't want clear windows. Something obscured needs to be placed. Thanks for the photos! I would have to remove the top leaded window I guess to insert these types of doors.

There are a million types of privacy glass and privacy films you can use.

Decorative Film Products | Decorative Films · More Info

https://www.decorativefilm.com/product-list

Why frosted glass etc? How close are you to the street? Get a Ring doorbell and you can see who is at your door and within 35 feet of it from your phone and they are on candid camera. I have beveled glass panes and there has never been a privacy issue. Does your front door look into your master bedroom? Again, during daytime its really very hard to see into a house and at night I leave the porch light on and you cannot see into the house. By the way - rethink your choices as they don’t go with the house.

Your home requires a Tudor style door and I don' think I would want to see any additional arches. That one for your front window is more than enough.

I need the privacy glass because you can see into the family room as couch. It really bothers me not having that privacy.

Here is another option any thoughts?

Look at your other poll; the answer is clearly there.

I voted for your second one but don't really like either. I think your arched transom needs to go as it doesn't match the house well. Love BeverlyFLADeziners middle suggestion and groveraxle's second suggestion. Either are much better choices. Let us know what you've decided!

We like the suggestion of a Tudor door for your home and to go with something simpler.

We have baroque glass on our front. Even tho it’s not a full privacy glass, believe me, I would see someone standing there before they would see me.