Software
Houzz Logo Print
janmarkle

Replacing countertops...Opinions Needed!

7 years ago

We are seeking advice on replacing our countertops. We are drawn to darker granite in either a leather or antiqued finish but our kitchen is small. Will it make our space look too dark? I’ve attached pics. Thanks!

Comments (11)

  • 7 years ago

    I think a white quartz has a simple elegance to it and would look great. Otherwise, I’ve found on here and personally that pearly vanata and taj ma Hal granite look great with maple color cabinets. I personally wouldn’t go dark. I have black with similar color cabinets; and it’s just too dark for me.

    janmarkle thanked Cynthia Keifer
  • 7 years ago

    I would also change out the black appliances, if possible.

  • 7 years ago

    I could see a beautiful soapstone or quartzite. If you go with granite or quartzite its called a honed finish vs polishes. Dark counters will lessen the light but it appears that you have sufficient overhead lighting. You can also add LED tape lighting under the cabinets to keep it bright.

    janmarkle thanked gtcircus
  • 7 years ago

    Black poster board would work too, and look more matte.

    I think a dark granite will make your kitchen too dark.

    janmarkle thanked chispa
  • 7 years ago

    With the great u shape I think something w flecks/elements or even some movement will be a great feature.just keep the tone in mid range-find something you really like. Floor and cabinets are basic enough...you can go for more detail than black granite or plain whitish . it isn't all that small.

    janmarkle thanked herbflavor
  • 7 years ago


    I did not think I would like it but it looks ok.

  • 7 years ago

    Can do better than ok w everything out there to choose from. Great backsplash which does not exist here is part of a change , so visualizing what it can be takes more focus.

  • 7 years ago

    Lovely cabinets. Black is a lot of maintenance to keep it looking clean.

  • 7 years ago

    I love soapstone and would just turn the lights on!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Too dark. The kitchen is a workspace, not a showroom. You need bright, well-dispersed light for work, and dark counters work against that. You'll end up with shadows and point-source lighting instead of diffuse (even if you add under-cabinet lighting, which you need even now).

  • 7 years ago

    it looks, at least from the viewing from this monitor, that the counters and the cabinets are in excellent shape, but that they are at odds in terms of tone - the cabinets being warm and the counters being cool? if so, the two elements are fighting one another. is there a color you could take from the decorative plates over the sink that would marry the two surfaces if you painted the backsplash? Do you dislike the counters for other reasons?


    I’m going to side with those who suggest not going too dark, but think that you should take one of your drawers and go visit some stone yards. See how the wood looks against a variety of colors and patterns. Are the cabinets cherry, by any chance? That’s a tricky wood :). It looks great with some colors you’d never guess and just “meh” with shades that should be a perfect neutral.

Sponsored
The Steele Group
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars1 Review
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio