Software
Houzz Logo Print
idealtrucks

HVAC Quote Opinions needed

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

I've got a few quotes to replace my existing heat pump and add duct work for a new addition I've built. I need some opinions on which is best. New addition is 576sq ft. Existing house is about 1800

#1 - 14 SEER 4 ton HEIL 10yr parts/1yr labor warranty - $6800

#2 - 14 SEER 4 ton York 10yr parts/10yr labor warranty - $8150

#3 - 14 SEER 4 ton Carrier 10yr parts/1yr labor warranty - $7800

#4 - 15 SEER 4 ton Colemtn 10yr parts/10yr labor warranty - $8000

Comments (12)

  • 7 years ago

    would like to see some model numbers on both outside HP condenser and inside air handler...thermostat, filter cabinet?...you are sure about the labor warranties?...i personally would like to see an American STD quote...what is your location?...size of heat strip?...New refrigerant lineset?...


    IMO

  • 7 years ago

    I'm guessing, as they are all 14 SEER, that these are bottom-of-the-line, builder grade systems. In which case they are WAY overpriced. Having said that, if these estimates were from different dealers, then this might be the "going rate" (whatever the market will bear) in your neck of the woods. Still, I would get a few more estimates with better quality equipment.

  • 7 years ago

    There is some cost for duct work in the new addition. Therefore it makes it difficult to comment on the price. We need to see model numbers and a location in order to offer any meaningful comments. My first reaction is 4 tons for the AC seems over sized.

  • 7 years ago

    These are from 2 different dealers, but neither gave me exact model numbers. I'm located in VA

  • 7 years ago

    You don't have a valid quote unless you have the model numbers of the heat pump, air handler, and coil. The size of the heat strip should be specified, and the type and dimensions of the return filter.

    A rating of 14 SEER is the lowest allowed in Virginia, so for all you know it is the lowest model offered by each manufacturer. I suggest staying away from the low end stuff no matter whose equipment you purchase.

    What is the size of the current heat pump and how well did it perform cooling the house in the summer before you added the addition?

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Both specified 15kw heat strip. The current heat pump is a 25 year old Trane 3 ton, 12 SEER. It has no problem heating and cooling the house, except the power bill is high.

    They both gave some prices on higher end too.

    Coleman CH16 - $8800

    Coleman Echelon 19 - $10000

    Carrier Performance 16 - $8900

    Carrier Infinity 18 - $11900

    York 15 SEER - $8750

    I guess I need to call back and get model numbers

  • 7 years ago

    minimum AHRI spec...


    15+ SEER, 13 EER, 9+ HSPF....


    heat strip should be staged, probably a 10-15 KW


    with an old system like you have, you should see some significant savings.


    IMO

  • 7 years ago

    If you are going to purchase a single stage heat pump, then I don't think you should go larger than 3.5 tons. Ideally you find a HVAC contractor who will do a proper load calculation to determine this. If you are going to spend the extra money on a 2-stage unit then 4 tons is most likely the correct size. The 2-stage is something to consider if your old system did a poor job of controlling the humidity.

  • 7 years ago

    Mike is spot on about a 3 1/2 ton sgl stage system...with your new addition I would ask for a load calc...also make certain ductwork addition is sized correctly and has a return as well...4 ton 2 stage HP system would be good but comes with added cost...


    IMO

  • 7 years ago

    I received one more quote on the system from a third installer. A comfort maker system, 14 seer, 4 ton for $5400. 10 year parts, 1 year labor warranty. Any thoughts on this brand vs the others?

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Comfortmaker is made by the same company as Carrier. It's not bad, but it is lower end equipment. Did they give you model numbers?. The N4A5 appears to be their only 14 SEER condenser. At least its costing a little less. Prices still seem high although if this includes ductwork to the add-on, that might explain it. You are increasing your square footage by 30% so the 4 ton doesn't seem totally out of line but you really should get a load calculation done. If you want to pay less, you need a significant increase in efficiency. You won't notice a difference going from 12 to 14 SEER. The N4A7 unit is 17 SEER - you might see a measurable reduction in energy bills if you upgraded to this.

    With any of these systems, the quality of the install is far more important than the manufacturer or model. Don't lowball yourself for a few hundred dollars by getting a "Craigslist special"!

  • 7 years ago

    The quotes mean nothing without model numbers for both outside condenser and inside air handler with matching AHRI numbers. It looks like you are bottom fishing for price.


    TD