Software
Houzz Logo Print
101newkitchen101

3 issues between me and $15,000

7 years ago

A complete redo vs painting.


There are 3-4 things that push me towards a total redo, but if I could solve these things I could potentially just paint and be happy enough.


I just started considering this, so any thoughts or input would be helpful!


1. Can you buy or build a fridge side panel and have it look like it belongs?


I’m thinking to move that upper and lower to the other side so I can scoot the fridge over to the door and then give it side panels. I’d also buy a new deeper box for above the fridge to make the fridge look more built in.



2. I really want drawers on either side of the range. Has anyone ever taken out a few lowers and added drawer bases? Would it look really odd if the drawers didn’t match exactly to the current cabinets?


Also, these bases don’t have fillers...how would I accommodate that if I switched to drawers. What looks like fillers are actually just part of the cabinets. It’s one solid piece.

So could I just remove these and buy drawers and a filler and then paint to match? Would I need a filler on either side of the drawers?


3. I do not like the way my island end looks. I don’t like the cut out toe kick. Has anyone ever added a panel and trim to the end and had it look original and not rigged up looking? I’d like the panel to go to the ground, which would hide the cut out.



4. This is a maybe. I would prefer full overly. Can you take partial overly doors off and buy full overlay and paint then to match? Or would something like this end up being really costly to where you’d almost be at a full redo?



Thanks for any help or input! I’m realizing this could save me a lot of money!

Comments (24)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    - Yes you can buy ref panels as long as you remove the cabinet at the end so you can add them.

    - If you can find matching cabinets, you can just order the drawer fronts, boxes and tracks and a couple of fillers and a good carpenter can convert those bases to drawer bases.

    - Yes you can buy material to create your own decorative end panel with a good carpenter.

    - I don't think you can change to full overlay doors - you said you had no fillers - I fear that you will have huge issues in the corners. Besides - partial overlay doors look just fine - why spend all that money.

    - As far as painting cabinets, I will defer to those who have done it. My experience has only been in a rental where I think the owner did it themselves - it barely made it 5 years and the paint was chipping and coming off. So I am not a fan..

    - You may want to consider adding handles... it is a nice look .. you could put some money into removing that small piece of stone backsplash and redoing the whole thing so it looks a bit cleaner - less choppy.

    Best of luck!!



  • PRO
    7 years ago

    You are already at more costs than buying new.

  • 7 years ago

    I've never done this but...

    You can buy full overlay faux doors. Basically they are doors are wider and longer than those you have... Full Overlay Tutorial . You install those on your pre-existing cabinets. So, understanding that:

    1) Yes, and as an example, say you went with the faux full overlay doors at Barker in the link above, you'd then purchase a large panel for the side of your fridge in the same style.

    2) Yes, it'd look odd if they didn't match. However, when you pull those base cabinets out, since they extend to each end and have a quasi-filler (my term!), you add a filler to the side of the replacement cabinet that holds the drawers.

    3) Same as the fridge, to the floor. Might look better to do an end panel, then add a couple half legs to each side, effectively covering the gap your toe kick leaves.

    4) Answered above.

    ... what it's going to cost is time and effort. If you wish to refinish your cabinetry and change out some of it, you have a lot of research ahead of you, followed by a lot of physical labor. Cheaper than a full kitchen of new cabinets, yes, but it'll also take time.


    There's one big 'if'. On the cabinets you wish to change out to a base of drawer stacks... will those come out without destroying the base cabinets around them? You need to look inside those cabinets before proceeding further with this : )


    Good luck whichever route you go : )

  • 7 years ago

    I don't think i'd make a large investment in that kitchen - too many things that could be MUCH better! Drawers, as you pointed out. It looks to me like there is not much aisle space around the island - and the island is a barrier between fridge and sink. The most efficient kitchen layout follows the path of ice-water-stone-fire (fridge-sink-counter-stove). It looks like your range is between the fridge and sink (if I am looking at the photos correctly).

    You could put in the time and money to the change the things you pointed out - and you would still have a sub-optimal layout - but after making an investment, you will be much less likely to tear it out and start over.

    Before making any changes to this kitchen, I would carefully evaluate my needs and wants. What really works in this layout? What drives me nuts every day? What would be my goals for a remodel? (in my case, the goals were additional and more efficient storage, better work flow, and a way to get most things off the counters). We get accustomed to the way things are - and how we have learned to adapt to our surroundings - so try to look at your kitchen with a fresh eye.

  • 7 years ago

    Great into, thanks!!!


    Even. With the full Reno, the layout was going to not be ideal. It’s a narrow Space, so the island still blocks the fridge and leaves minimal walk space around. I’m fairly used to the narrowness now, so I can’t continue to live with that.


    That‘s what got me thinking about just painting...the full reno basically had the same layout, except it had drawers and the fridge panel.


    It would be nice to change the door style and switch the to overlay, but that was the one thing I know would likely involve more cost. I think this might be something I could skip and still be happy. Painting them and adding a handle would make them look much better.



  • 7 years ago

    The drawer bases sound like they could be a little more complicated. but I’m going to take a look to see how tearing those out would affect the ones I’m leaving. They are dead corners, so hopefully that would be in my favor.


    Sounds like fridge and island panel might be the easiest of my four dilemmas, so that’s good news! I would definitely want to hire a carpenter so it’s done correctly!

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    You may not have room for an island, but you could have a narrow island cart such as this https://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/80035920/

    I have this in my 11 ft wide kitchen. I painted the base black so it would "disappear" and oiled the top. I love it and it is SO useful!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    We did everything you are asking for with stained cabinets (refinished). If you are painting, it will be easier. Check out the story at the link below. You need to find the right person to work with to get the drawer boxes built and get the doors/drawer faces ordered. We moved the fridge and boxed it in, added drawers on each side of the stove, and added panels to the island.

    Cabinet modifications

  • 7 years ago

    #1. Leave the fridge. When you replace it, get a counter-depth fridge. Don’t move the cabinets around. You would need a new granite slab because you won’t like the “seam” you would create moving the small base over.
    #2. You may be able to retrofit drawers into the cabinets, but may have to reuse the doors unless these cabinets are still made and you can order drawers with correct fronts for the retrofit.
    #3. The toe-kick on the island is normal. If you added a side panel to hide the toe-kick, the new panel would have to be an exact match, and you would be hitting it with your toes for the first month.
    #4. You can change the doors for full overlay, but it will cost you some money and the cabinets themselves will still be the same behind the new doors.
    Save up for a full redo...it won’t be $15,000....more like $25,000 just for the cabinets because you KNOW that you will come up with other changes.

  • 7 years ago

    I would look at keeping the lowers as they are but retro inside. Add interior drawers.

  • 7 years ago

    Everything you want is possible. My friend has used a good carpenter to modify her kitchen cabinets a few times because she doesn't want to deal with the hassle of a full renovation.


    The issue is really cost and whether you want to spend $x to make whatever changes you want rather than either living with the kitchen or making fewer changes.


    For example, installing rollouts for your lower cabinets is far cheaper and easier than swapping out for drawers. I have both drawers and rollouts in my new remodel and while the drawers are more ergonomic, the rollouts functionally achieve the same goal - making stuff at the back of bottom cabinets accessible without taking everything out :-). I certainly wouldn't spend money for drawers versus the relatively small amount needed to retrofit existing lower cabinets with rollouts.


    I can't imagine spending money to change to full overlay but then I can't imagine spending a significant amount of money for something that is solely being done because full overlay is considered "trendier".

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Your wish list isn’t just painting the cabinets for 10K. It’s renaking them too. For 5-7K. Plus all new counters, sink, and faucet, for 7-10K. You’re already at half the cost of a complete redo, with 1/19 of the functionality, because you aren’t changing anything that really matters, like the layout. Spend the other half and really fix the kitchen.

  • 7 years ago

    We plan to redo the floors, backsplash, and new granite...so moving the cabinets around wouldnt be an issue as far as the granite goes. @felizlady

  • 7 years ago

    @midsmwricanmom...I love the look of drawer bases on either side of the stove. I’d be limited to interior drawers because these cabinets have a center bar down the middle. It would mean super skinny drawers. Something to check into though if replacing the cabinets isn’t an option.

  • 7 years ago

    @snnac54...how awesome!!! What a transformation!!!


    Yes, we’d be painting, so a little easier than staining.


    i love seeing an actual example of someone who built a fridge box!!! Was it just built out of wood or did you purchase actual cabinet “panels”?

  • 7 years ago

    I got new doors and drawer fronts and went from partial to full overlay, paint-grade maple. They cost about 25% of what it cost to paint the cabinets.

  • 7 years ago

    Our number for the cabinets alone started at 21k, but found another line that brought it down to 15k. this is covering all my wish list things...pantry to hide the microwave, better looking island, uppers all the way to ceiling. It’s 15k just for the cabinets themselves...not including anything else...counters, faucets, or installation.


    Regardless of whether I paint or buy new cabinets, I still plan to get new counters, flooring, hardware, faucet and sink, and appliances.


    So, I’d save the 15k plus installation. Less whatever these changes I’m considering would cost.


    I’m leaning towards just keeping the doors. I think trying to change those would end up making it better just to buy all new cabinets.

  • 7 years ago

    What's wrong with your countertops? They look fine. I'd just remove the 4" piece at the back.

  • 7 years ago

    Post your kitchen dimensions so we can help you create a better layout. Then go to Ikea for excellent quality cabinets that will be the same price or less than what you'll get in the big box stores.

    Forget painting those not so quality cabinets. Not worth the time or the money to do them.

    101newkitchen101 thanked cpartist
  • 7 years ago

    It might be worth it to post a layout - there are some very clever designers here. Often, an island that is a barrier can be replaced by a well placed peninsula - but we would need a layout with measurements to see if that would work. If you have enough counter space - and it looks like you may - an island is not even necessary.


    Rarely does an island work in a U shaped kitchen unless it is quite large. Islands work well in L shaped kitchens or open plan kitchens. It was the move toward open concept that made the island popular. Now many try to retrofit one into a space where it really is more problem then help because they think it is "necessary" in a new kitchen - but it is not. Others think the peninsula is old fashion and the island is the new thing - but peninsulas are not old fashion - often they are the best layout in a small area.


    I would hesitate to make expensive changes using painted over previously finished cabinets. The best I've seen need light touch ups in 3 years and many more touch ups in 5 years. Painting is a good way to give worn cabinets a few more years of life while planning for a new kitchen. On the positive side, your cabinets are maple and that paints up better much better than oak.


    I did add some new cabinetry - bought unfinished and stained to match my present cabinets - as has been mentioned, that is easier if you paint. Also, my wood is oak which has a lot of natural variation and that helps camouflage slight stain variations.


    My cabinets are 22 years old and they are US made from a home center store. It might be worth looking into how much new cabinets would be. if you can use standard sizes, you can save a lot of money rather than needing custom cabinets.

    101newkitchen101 thanked jhmarie
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    As to adding drawers there's a cheap fix for that if you don't mind having drawers inside a door. You can buy pull out drawer boxes to fit inside the existing cabinets. This will require no change to the outside of the cabinets. People often alter old cabinets this way.

    Pull out drawer boxes in cabinet:



    Or companies like Rev a Shelf sell all sorts of pullouts that can be added inside old cabinets to make them more useful. A pullout for pots and pans might be nice next to a range:



    101newkitchen101 thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    Since you are planning to make major changes, find a good designer and ask him/her for their suggestions on how to address your issues. Best to do it all at once. Keep in mind, if you put in wood panels around your fridge, you may need to buy a fridge that is made to be enclosed. Enclosing it now will effect the efficiency of your fridge as it is designed to have the heat dispersed along the open sides. You may be fixing a minor issue and creating bigger ones. Seriously write down al your concerns and see what a professional designer can suggest. It's well worth it!

    101newkitchen101 thanked Barbara Almandarz
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I'd save my money for a full renovation at some point in the future. Doing what you want to do piecemeal could lead to problems you didn't know you had, and wind up costing mega-bucks.

    101newkitchen101 thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC