Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_9850470387

Big kitchen mistake - what can we do now?

7 years ago

Hi everyone. We recently bought our first home. We inherited a kitchen with brown cabinets, backsplash and granite counters. The brown cabinets were a nice shade, not oak. I had always wanted a white kitchen so before moving in, we got the cabinets painted in Sherwin Williams Pure White.


Horrible mistake: the shade of white is too stark and clinical for the space. Just does not look good. We have updated the cabinet hardware, and are updating the lighting to recessed lighting. Flooring throughout house also been changed to hardwood. But what can we do to make this kitchen look good? The paint on the walls is a beige color. We don't have money to change every single thing. I need tips and solutions to make this space livable. Breaks my heart to be in this kitchen.






Comments (24)

  • 7 years ago

    If layout and cabinet quality are both good I’d replace the counter and backsplash. The white you chose is fine but it does not go with the counter or backsplash.

  • 7 years ago

    What is the wall color?

  • 7 years ago

    Hi Sarah-

    Your kitchen and home are lovely, enjoy them in good health!

    You have so much lighting in there, it makes the kitchen cabinet color look very stark.

    I wonder if you are using light bulbs in the cool spectrum.

    Can you change the bulbs to a warmer type?

    That might help the paint to look less stark.

    Love your pot rack!


  • 7 years ago

    The problem is that if we replace the counter and backsplash, we would also have to get sink and paint changed. The kitchen sink picks up on the black tones in the granite counters right now. Wall color is Valspar desert something or other. It's a typical beige color, a bit on the peachy side. Because the kitchen flows into the rest of the house, I can't repaint just the kitchen walls. I'd have to repaint the entire space. It's just getting insanely expensive.

  • 7 years ago

    Gosh, those were beautiful maple cabinets before being painted. You can paint them in something like a linen white to help blend in with the countertops and flooring.

  • 7 years ago

    You need a warmer white for the cabinets. I am an advocate for using the resources from Maria Killam on color choices . She is on houzz and also runs a successful blog. Good luck!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I would start with the lighting as loobab suggested. Make sure all your lights are "warm" lights. Even LED's come in that now. It might make a world of difference at night anyway. And you might very well get accustomed to it after a bit of time. Get some green plants in there, something organic.

    Is repainting the cabs an option at all...even down the line a bit if you decide you can't live with this white? I've had 3 kitchens with warm white cabs in SW Dover White, including my current one. It's also my FR...just warm, creamy, easy to live with, looks good with everything.

    Can you take a picture standing back a bit as in the before shots? It would be helpful to see it all in good daylight. Pretty space with all those windows!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    can you switch out the backsplash? if you demoed it yourself, you could save some money. buying a simple, lighter tile wouldn't cost more than a few hundred. (and if you know how to tile a backsplash, it would save you another grand or so). You could try under cabinet LED lighting, but it's still going to be a stark white against brown/gold granite.

    I've also seen people who have painted their travertine w/a chalk paint to lighten it up. it didn't look half-bad. they did more of a white wash w/the chalk paint




    same granite/white cabs as you have


    But, I don't think it looks that bad. I would switch out the bright white outlet covers and find the travertine ones to blend w/your tile. Live with it for awhile and see if it grows on you.

    I don't know where you live, but pre-fab countertops are much cheaper than buying two full slabs. (3K for slabs, and about 1K or less for pre-fab. and that's just for materials, not fabrication) If you got prefabs, you could do all of your countertops for about 3K (total) , maybe a bit less depending on where you are. if you got 2 slabs, it would be a total of 6-8K. quite a diff.

    Add in the backsplash (DIY it and spend only 500 or so total). I don't know if this is doable right now, but at least it gives you an idea if you need to save up for a bit.

    examples of some prefabs (they come 6' for bathrooms, and 8and 9' for kitchens)


    marble, granite, quartz and quartzite. all are avail.


    Normally they don't carry too many of the more costly or exotics in the pre fabs, but my stone place had this TajMajal pre fab for sale. granted, it's quite a bit more than the others....1800 for a 2x9'. But I don't know what the going rate is for a Taj slab. I'd say at least 3K or more, plus more for cutting.


    btw, this would be a nice color w/your cabs, and you could prob retain your backsplash w/the Taj.

  • 7 years ago

    I had contemplated warmer white for the cabinet color, but our wall color is a beige. Wouldn't that all just blend in then??

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    there are a lot of people w/santa cecelia granite who paint their cabs a brighter white. a lot also have the travertine splash. most of those chose an ORB for the hardware. it seems to help blend in the darker tones a bit better

    these two aren't a super bright white, but, I lilke the ORB hardware with them


    and this one shows how it looks w/white subway tile. (but ORB hardware)

    and, people are always asking about backsplash choices w/this granite, so I had made up a sample photo w/diff colors. to help tie in the bright white, choosing a white grout w/these tiles would be a good option

    this one would look nice w/yours. the brownish gold tile w/white grout,,,but you'd need ORB hardware to pick up on the blacks in your stone.

  • 7 years ago

    the hardware is stark. the cabinets are fine. try a C or D shape handle in warmer metal as mentioned [see the color of small sq inserts in your backsplash] . maybe cup pulls for drawers. Can't tell which wall area is a sightline but you could swap a glass doored cabinet for the solid, since you know the paint. Scherrs does doors and might even do the paint for you. Glass doors provide quite a bit of change at that important eye level. Try some tweaks before you get into large scale adjustments. Changing backsplash could do quite a bit if you can/want. maybe pause for a bit first.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Oh, dear, this is exactly why I created an Ideabook for Kitchen Wood Cabinets to share with Dilemma Posters. I wanted people on the fence about painting wood cabinets to see examples of wood-cabinet kitchens that look great. (I do have professionally painted white cabinets in my home because the wood cabinets that came with my house were in poor shape. IMO, that's almost the only reason to paint or change out nice wood cabinets.)


    Although the OP is temporarily unhappy--this can be fixed--her Dilemma is an example of how changing one element in a space affects everything else and pretty soon you almost want to do a gut job. Harmonious rooms happen when all the finishes relate either through contrast (think white cabinets, black countertops) or in colors that "go with" surrounding walls, floors--especially floors which many people forget--and adjacent spaces. It's helpful and money saving to get a color consultant before making big color and finish decisions when you move in. Better yet, get a design consult--not just on Houzz--to weigh in. It saves money in the long run. A good designer can show you the way forward and do things step by step. Good luck with getting ithe kitchen together. It's a gorgeous kitchen in any case!

  • 7 years ago

    If you really, really don't like the white, changing out everything else, spending all that $$ might be an exercise in futility; you'd still have cabs you don't like. Live with it a bit if you can. I can't imagine that repainting the cabs would be more than the cost of changing everything else! It would be cheaper to repaint and you'd have the creamier white you want. Glass doors are great for adding charm and make a nice focal point....if I didn't have things to hide, I'd do all glass!


    Love to see more photos further back though.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    jama, I think she does like the cabs. it's just the white is so 'white' against all the golds and tans. repainting the cabs aren't going to be much cheaper than getting new granite, believe or not. They'd still have to remove all of the doors/drawers, dismantle all the hardware, sand down that new finish and respray. everything.(don't forget the base cabs. everything has to be taped off and covered, sanded, and sprayed) still going to cost at least 3K. she could get prefab counters for that much, or at least redo the backsplash for half of that.

    I'd say for now, switch out the hardware to ORB, and use something that's not so contemporary looking. (those bars are a little too modern for your traditional finishes). maybe something a little more black or dark ORB. lowes has these (those bar ends can catch your clothing. these would just work better w/your style)




    the next easiest change is the backsplash. demo yourselves to save money. Now, I wouldn't do all of this if you're not in love w/your granite. If you are, fine. if you aren't, wait 6 months/year and save the money for something you love.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    The cheapest thing to do is put an antique glaze on the cabinets. I'm not a big fan of these glazes, but it will make your white cabinets work better with that countertop and the wall paint. Find a board and paint it the cabinet color and then experiment before going at the cabinets themselves.


    Doing things piecemeal in a kitchen is always fraught with peril, unfortunately.

  • 7 years ago

    The best thing to do right now is nothing. Wait 6 months and put a full plan together of how you'll change things. Don't continue to do things piecemeal or you'll really muck it up more. (sorry I'm channeling my inner Sophie here)

    You may decide all you need to do is throw some rugs down, or maybe paint the walls. Or you may decide you hate it so much you need to redo the whole thing. Live with it for a while.

    Sorry I'm going to put my teacher cap on now. For anyone reading this who buys a new old house, this is the reason we always suggest to live in the house for 6 months to a year before changing anything. Unless of course the place is falling down.

  • 7 years ago

    Have you thought of changing the bulbs to a warmer white?

  • 7 years ago

    Or remove the paint.

    The Best Easy Way to Strip Kitchen Cabinets

    https://homeguides.sfgate.com/easy-way-strip-kitchen-cabinets-90487.html

  • 7 years ago
    <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><md>That Beth is awesome isn’t she
  • 7 years ago

    IMO Beth fixed it by offering several backsplash options with white grout and orb hardware to tie it all together.

  • 7 years ago

    Going out on a limb here to suggest replacing the cool hardware with satin brass to match the granite’s warmth. And yes, swap out all bulbs and lighting for something well into the warm spectrum. Overall, I think it is a fabulous kitchen. You just have some remodel shock, perhaps. Enjoy your lovely space.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Totally agree. ORB hardware will make a huge difference. Go get enough for a couple cabinets and a drawer set and throw them on and step back and see how it feels :) lowes sells tons of them in all spreads and sizes for not much $

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago


    Glazed KitchenCabinets · More Info


    Glazed KitchenCabinets · More Info


    White Kitchen Renovation with Detailed Moldings and Trims · More Info

    I think if you had the cabinets glazed it would soften and white and make them go with the counter tops and backsplash batter.

    Here are some kitchens from Houzz with glazed cabinets

    For me the biggest problem is the wall color - it looks almost gold. i actually like the countertop and backsplash. A few years ago I painted the oak vanity in my kids bathroom stark white. It was too much so I glazed over it and it looked much better.