Trying to post some possible types of patterns...

I agree with you. They all match too closely. All beautiful in their own right, but.....yes to finding something different.

Yes, all beautiful, but a bit too similar. I love the one where the two sofas are. Would pick one the colors from that rug as the predominant color in a replacement rug.

I agree with dedtired. The one with the two couches is my favorite, but all three are the colors and style that most appeal to me.

Ded, I was thinking the den rug should be the one to replace because it’s in the middle of the living room and the foyer. Everyone loves the foyer rug so that would be the hardest one to get DH onboard. And I don’t really have another place for that (round) rug. I find the red color in the den rug to be overly bright, and if I had to pick my least favorite of the three, that would be my choice. Unfortunately it’s also the hardest size to find, since the room is small and has a radiator plus a floor vent. The good news is, we have a good rug store near us that has some odd sizes, and DH loves the store (we got our dining room rug there) so that may help me with my negotiations!

I too would change the rug in the foyer. I love the one with the two sofas.

Okay, now I understand how your rooms flow. So, I agree about replacing the den rug. I like the idea of a stripe.

I think they coordinate beautifully.

I'm an outlier, I like them. In your photos, you are showing an angle that emphasizes the rug (to show the pattern). But underfoot I don't think they would register as prominent. So I think they work as is.

I think they look fine too-- but having them so similar doesn't seem like YOUR style. I love your funky leanings and so I would mix it up-- and yes, with the Den rug.

I like them all. You are right, the one in the den is a bit bright. If you are going to change it I would go with something like the number 1 or 2 rug you show as examples rather than #3 as it seems too bright too.

Pretty rugs. I would also change the one in the den, and buy one large enough to go under the chairs.

All are great rugs but yes, they seem to be too much of a type, one after the other. The obvious change would be the one in the middle, the den. However.... is there any possibility that one would fit in the foyer? I know you said there is no place for the round anywhere else and don't want to change that - I'm just curious how that one would look in that space but I would still change the style of the den.

OTOH..... in working with 2 different importers here to find rugs that work with my antique Persian, both have 'collected' rugs for me of varying sizes that are much like what you have, variations on a theme based on what I have. They both insist that there should be continuity of style throughout but I haven't pulled the trigger because like you, I want to mix it up more.

Thanks for all the feedback. DLM, the den rug is too large for the foyer space. Hard to tell in the pics, I know.

allison, yes, ideally the rug would be under the chairs but it's really hard to find a size that works in that room, that isn't too big or too small (I think the size of the current rug is also what's bothering me about the whole situation). 8' x 8' would be about perfect, but I'm not finding a lot of rugs I like in that size. 8 x 10 is too big.

Funky, at first I thought your post said "I like your funky earrings." LOL.

Beautiful rugs and rooms! From what I am seeing on my monitor is that the rug in the den is brighter and the red is more of a true red than a warmer red like the other two rugs. I would look for something more muted if you are going to have red in the new rug. Maybe a bit more of an orange red than bright red. Or as in one of your options... the green rug... you won't need to worry about the red. It could just be my monitor. Colors are so difficult as they translate through so many mediums.

What about a sisal? Easy to get a custom size.

Ha ha, I was looking at this earlier!

https://www.naturalarearugs.com/p/carmela-custom-sisal/

I just don't know if it would be toooo neutral. Also, one of our dogs had a field day with a seagrass rug in our beach house, so I don't know if she would do the same w/ a sisal rug.

I think they look lovely just like they are. Maybe you just want a change, you could buy a different rug and switch them out as the mood hits. I think that everyone gets tired of having the same thing after a while.

I'm late to the party, but I like the idea of changing the den rug to something very subtle....sort of a palate cleanser.

Palate cleanser! Exactly!

Got a new rug! I really let DH make the decision because he loved this rug. I think it works!

Here u can see the other rugs nearby.