Your home looks historic. If so, I would go with something closer to

https://www.lowes.com/pd/Pella-Carriage-House-96-in-x-84-in-Insulated-Sandtone-Single-Garage-Door-with-Windows/3817415

Local installers (not box stores) can offer you many options to complement your home style. I would suggest doors that have windows which would give you some light and break of the facade of the door. And, I would vote for a local installer.

Thank you both- like this?

his?

thank you- I tried dark brown on the virtual photos and thought dark brown looked a little funny with the tan above it?

The amarr color (wicker tan) would be a very close match to the stucco- actually a little better than what we have now, and it is a SW color so we would paint the top to match exactly. Still open to stained wood doors if they would look 10 times better, but for the $$ and maintenance ( wood not recommended in our climate) I think the "artificial" doors are a better choice?

is this better than the tan? It's kind of dark today- usually very sunny so the recessed parts of the house and windows don't usually read this dark.

The tan above is your siding it needs to stay the color it is and the pic above is a good color but not the country look with the wood battens and I agree S facing doors or garage doors need to factory finished and the “fake” wood ones if of good quality look pretty good.

The dark brown color above is good, but use a simpler style without all the lines. You already have textures and lines with your brick, siding, and roof - you don't need more on the garage doors. Real wood doors are very heavy and hard to maintain. The fake wood ones in my opinion always look fake. Go for the painted look, which will blend in better with your house.