Fun! I love the dark olive color and grey-blue. Those would really compliment the space. I agree, I have been looking for a rug to go in the room. So hard to find one that compliments the stone without overpowering it.

Heather if you post an image of your room with the current rug, we can try slipping other rugs under your seating as you see in these images

Let do it! I never knew you could do even half the stuff I am seeing. Amazing!

Everdebz, I think a sage or olive is more my thing. Thanks!

Natural woven fabrics? bit of sage. :)

Cotton Kilim Lumbar Pillow, 12x20 · More Info

Sopris Handwoven Contemporary Rug, Brown, Rectangular 7'9x10'6 · More Info

https://www.houzz.com/products/sopris-handwoven-contemporary-rug-brown-rectangular-79x106-prvw-vr~138928230

With my 2 windows open, this pillow brought out color of mortar[whatever dark is called] -- a bit sophisticated for accent color? indigo....

Rizzy Home T11397 14" x 26" Throw Pillow with Zipper Closer · More Info

https://www.houzz.com/products/rizzy-home-t11397-14-x-26-throw-pillow-with-zipper-closer-prvw-vr~65157429

I like this pillow and can see it in my room. Just the touch that I might need!

I'd try this gunmetal grey silver -

Thomas Collection Tissavel Faux Fur Throw Pillow 17440 12x20 · More Info

Thomas Collection Luxury Couch Throw Pillow 11416 12x20 · More Info

https://www.houzz.com/products/thomas-collection-luxury-couch-throw-pillow-11416-12x20-prvw-vr~116393761

https://www.houzz.com/products/thomas-collection-tissavel-faux-fur-throw-pillow-17440-12x20-prvw-vr~116404527

If you "go global" this type is nice -

Thomas Collection Faux Fur Designer Sofa Throw Pillow 17422 12x20 · More Info

https://www.houzz.com/products/thomas-collection-faux-fur-designer-sofa-throw-pillow-17422-12x20-prvw-vr~92371694

Thanks for all the tips! I am also thinking of adding some plants by the fireplace to soften it.

I like the middle one. The only thing I could think of was using solid colors in bluish/grays or greens. Thanks for the advice!

… table is so dark and seems darkest stain there … would a chalk paint be possible? Not sure your rug is so 'off' cause it's subtle and seems color in the fp?

Fp etc. stands so well on their own, that I imagine you could pick a rich color htat you like and spread it around a few times. .... idea:

Baby Alpaca Throw Blankets, Purple Plum · More Info

https://www.houzz.com/products/baby-alpaca-throw-blankets-solid-color-all-natural-purple-plum-prvw-vr~77775819

At a fair or boutique - handmade look that you want to see.

This would have no pattern I guess - several colors - but indoor-outdoor: