This would be the other option. We like the decorative glass. But not many other houses in our neighborhood have decorative glass

I would definitely select the first door because it comes closer to the Tudor cottage style than the second door. I would not consider what other homes have in your neighborhood when making a selection. The second door has no "charm." Can you post a photo of the house? I have a Tudor cottage as well.

Here she is. Still working on landscaping. Thanks for the input.

for those with clear glass who would like Tudor style, check out the window films on Amazon--this pattern is available

The glass diamond points and wood rectangle panels seem to conflict. I would probably go with rectangular glass to repeat the house’s windows.