Software
Houzz Logo Print
beth_kenney1643

Kitchen Cabinet Doors

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

Hello. We are looking to replace our cabinet doors. I want the shaker look but our boxes are in great shape. We plan on buying white shaker doors and trim pieces and having someone paint the boxes.

Has anyone purchased just doors? Where did you get them? Pictures to show current. Already got new appliances.



Comments (15)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Personally, I think buying new doors would be a waste of money. There's nothing wrong with raised panel doors. I'd repaint the cabinets as they are, and replace the backsplash and counter tops. Also add cabinet hardware.

  • 7 years ago

    I ordered doors for my existing upper cabinets from cabinetdoormart.com and I'm somewhat happy with them, but the holes they drilled next to the cups were way too big. If you're going with shaker, make sure to opt for the hardest wood they offer on the stiles and rails because they do seem to ding easily which is disappointing.

  • 7 years ago

    The doors are the most expensive part. If you’re going to replace them? Plus pay labor? You might as well replace all of the rest of the cabinets too. Then you could have cabinets to the ceiling, and have some drawer bases.


    I wouldn’t even paint those. Wood cabinets are back in style. Put some hardware on them. It’s the counter and backsplash that should be replaced.

  • 7 years ago

    I am not a fan of the painted cabinet look or the raised panel look and we need to replace all the hinges. The only thing left really is the door. I figure if I am going to spend the money I am going to get what I want. I have priced out having the whole kitchen painted vs just the boxes and getting new doors and it really isnt that much different to be getting the exact look I want. I just wanted to know if anyone had any good recommendations on where to get doors.


    This is our second kitchen remodel. We had to move out of my dream kitchen suddenly due to a work move and I want the same look here in my new house. The house is only 10 years old so I suspect that the boxes have plenty of life left in them.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    The ceiling is 10 feet, maybe 11. The cabinets are already 42s. We are not paying labor to put on cabinet doors. Our last kitchen we did entirely ourselves. The only thing we don't want to do is paint anything but the walls because that is not a skill we have.


    The counters and back splash are being replaced also. We just did the floor yesterday.

  • 7 years ago

    Also.. RTA cabinets that I have priced for my kitchen is $6500. We would have to assemble them all and rip everything out and replace it. Buying doors/hinges and having the boxes professionally painted prices out to about $3000. To have the whole kitchen painted priced out to about $2200 plus the cost of soft close hinges. So it is not worth it to rip out the cabinets. But, for me, it is worth it to replace the doors.

  • 7 years ago

    For $2200 you aren’t getting a professional grade cabinet coating. You’re getting a paint guy, and standard homeowner grade paint. You’d need to multiply that figure by 2-4 to get a properly and professionally done job with a coating that would be as durable as the one from the factory that you have on there now. It’s not worth it to do all of that for a fading style. You have the up and coming style. Wood is back! Run with it.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I got three quotes from 3 local businesses that have been recommended by multiple people with active websites with plenty of images of their work. They were all the same ball park. And if that is the case, then we will definitely go with the replacing the door route because it will be cheaper.


    Regardless of style. I do not like wood and especially not this color wood. But painting my cabinets including doors is not something we are going to do either way.

    No we are not removing a wall.

  • 7 years ago

    following ...

  • 7 years ago

    Look at Barker Door. You can specify to the exact measurements. https://www.barkerdoor.com/Shaker-Cabinet-Doors-s/39.htm

  • 7 years ago

    You can order new custom sized doors (finished or unfinished) from Conestoga Cabinet dealers. Very good quality and somewhat reasonably priced. CabinetJoint.com is a well respected dealer referenced many times here on Houzz. The folks at CabinetJoint are very helpful and know their stuff. They also carry other materials (light rail, crown moldings etc.) that could change up the look a bit if you like. I looked at several online dealers for new doors (rawdoor.net, barkerdoor.com, amishdoors.com, and a few others) but Conestoga had the best quality and most selection. Best of luck :)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Are your existing cabinet boxes constructed of plywood, or MDF, or particle board?


    If not sure, remove some screws to see. If not plywood or wood, then I would not invest in new doors, because hanging new doors on MDF construction is subpar. It may not be able to hold screws in as well.


    These are extreme photos, but trying to show what MDF looks like inside.

    Plus the MDF box sides show wear & tear faster



    If it's plywood cabinet construction, that's good news for adding new doors.


    Getting new doors is not as easy as it seems to be. There's a lot more involved like getting them sized correctly to hanging & closing right to laying level on older cabinet frames. Doors are the most expensive part of a cabinet & difficult to get exactly right, that is why most cabinet companies do not sell just doors. It's hard to find just cabinet doors, because it's not the best option when doing a remodel.


    Of course, get some quotes for the doors as others suggested above & try some local cabinet makers who might make an install the door for you. The door quotes will probably come in high. If it's too good of a deal, it's a less quality door material. So make sure you know what material the doors are made of. See if you can order just one to make sure you like it before ordering the rest.


    Common knowledge that a painted finish is never as hard & durable as a factory baked finish. Factory finish paint usually lasts longer.


    Imho, there's really not that much savings to justify the risk of going at it a-la-carte.


    If it were my project or client, I would go for the RTA cabinets. Get 2-3 estiimates from local cabinet dealers, that assemble locally. I save an average of 35% compared to big box stores buying from small local cabinet suppliers. Yeah, the countertop & backsplash will need to go, if replacing the cabinets, but that will be a nice improvement.


    White cabinets will not look that good with the current counter & backsplash. It might enhance the age of the counters & look dingy against white.


    Since you have done several kitchen remodels beforehand, you can tackle a whole job again & save some money by doing it yourselves. It will improve the kitchen & usually improves the value as a whole when done all at once.


    If planning to sell home 5 years or so, that's a good time to get the most bang for your buck with a remodel, because you will be able to enjoy your new kitchen for several years & it should still look updated & attract buyers.



  • 7 years ago

    I wouldn't spend any money or effort on those cabinets. And certainly wouldn't spend on new counters & backsplash.


    Because the double doors cabinets have those awful divider stiles which are a daily PITA. And I'm not seeing any drawer banks.


    On second thought, I would spend a few dollars for cabinet pulls and call it done. And use 'em until I had the cash for much more functional cabinetry.

  • 7 years ago

    If you’re so dissatisfied with the current doors and drawer fronts why not just save for a bit and replace it all lock, stock, and barrel? You can donate these if removed carefully and you’ll end up with exactly what you want. It’s a win for you and a win for a family in need. Factory finished painted cabinets and boxes will serve you better over the long run. Good luck!