Anton you did not answer the question . IMo yes the hinges should match the other hardware I assume this is just a upgrade of an existing kitchen

If the hinges are visible I definitely would. We have brushed brass hardware, but our hinges are concealed and those are more of a satin nickel. It doesn't bother me that they don't match but if you could see them when the cabinet was closed it would.

Anton - Thank you for the pix and link!

Patricia - It initially started as let's replace the countertop tiles and backsplash, to quickly changing everything out but the lay out of the kitchen (we love the layout as it works for us).

We are currently having our cabinets painted with White Dove in Satin. Cristallo quartzite for countertops, MOP for backsplash, and stainless steel appliances (and faucet).

I am gearing towards either brass or gold hardware for cabinets, and would prefer to have the hinges match!

Any recommendations on soft close hinges in those colors? I've read some scary reviews on hinges from big box stores and would prefer to stay away from them.

Looking to get the replacements ASAP!

Kaylie - Thank you for the response. Our hinges are hidden, but I will know they are there! :)

I just finished a remodel with custom cabinetry and have some inset doors which have hinges showing. Those hinges somewhat match the knobs and pulls as they are oiled rubbed bronze and my cabinet pulls are enamel and antique copper. However, my cabinets are a medium stained wood so the hinges themselves are not a design element.

My internal hinges do NOT match the exterior finishes and doesn't faze me :-). They are some type of silver finish. I have "fancy" interiors as they are painted and clad in teal blue to complement other design choices I have made in the kitchen and elsewhere in my open design plan.