Software
Houzz Logo Print
evang83

Landscaping help! Replacing Crape Myrtle.

7 years ago


Hi! We got our landscape plan, and my husband wants to replace the crape myrtle. He’s been looking online but is coming up empty. I like a more structured tree, but we already have several Oakland Holly’s. I have zero clue about landscape. I hope to one day know more, but for now I’m in the trenches of motherhood. Any help or suggestions for our landscape plan would be great!


Thanks!



Comments (5)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    " I like a more structured tree [than a crape myrtle];" What does that mean? Most trees have more or less the same structural traits ... one or more trunks, some limbs, branches and twigs laden with foliage. If they have a refined shape, it is usually what you have created by maintenance/trimming.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I guess I mean something that isn’t drooping limbs. A taller, thinner tree as opposed to one that will grow so big, that it takes over it and encroaches on the front of the home.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    A taller, thinner tree ... are you thinking in the X-mas tree shape? That's the starting point ... what overall shape and how high do you want it to be when it's finished? BTW, your bed size is going to be cramped for anything you put there. You should expand the bed somewhat forward for a better fit.

    evang83 thanked Yardvaark
  • 7 years ago

    Full grown, less then 15’ high. I would say more of a Christmas tree shape. I apologize for the lack of description, landscape is all greek to me. I’ve wondered if maybe we should just swap out the Crape myrtle for another Oakland Holly, or put the Crape Myrtle on the other side of the house so when it’s full grown it isn’t encroaching on the driveway and dropping petals there.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Here's one quote of 'Oakland' Holly size that I culled off of the Web: "... will grow 15 feet tall, and eventually 20 feet tall, with a width of between 8 and 15 feet." Posted sizes are snapshots sizes at X-years (5 or 10 ... I forget) out. They are usually conservative because growers know everyone wants smaller plants. In reality you can expect a plant to grow about double the posted sizes. This is likely a 30 to 40' tall plant that gets 15 - 20-something feet wide. Knowing that you're planting between a house and driveway tells us that there's not enough room. This is not a plant that should be planted 3' away from the foundation walls. It should be more like 10' or 12'.

    The Christmas tree shape, while it is the defacto anchoring shrub/tree for home corners, is a difficult plant to actually use, and usually has a limited life span in which it must be removed at the end, as it overwhelms the house and space. Most people do not like removing lower limbs off of this shape plant, but as they grow wider, there is little choice but to turn them into tree forms. Or else the lower limbs are impeding the driveway or jamming into the house. It is much easier to have a tree form in the first place, where the expectation is to have a clear trunk to the eaves, and the foliage canopy will be above the house, where there is open space. (This presumes the house is one story. If it is two-story, the tree needs to be larger and correspondingly farther away.)

    The designer is probably figuring that you will pollard the crape myrtle, which is the sure way of controlling its size, as well as regulating some other features. But if you don't do that, it's probably not a good fit, and you could use an even SMALLER tree (made out of a large shrub.) Use the Christmas tree shape if you want, but be aware that in 10 years, you'll be removing it and starting over.

    If "... something that isn’t drooping limbs ..." is your characterization of crape myrtle, I don't understand or agree with it, or think it's accurate. A crape is more or less like any tree. It can be grown a number of ways, each having a distinct appearance. Usually it is a multi-trunk tree. But it can be grown as a single trunk. Commonly, it is pollarded, but also, often, it is not and just allow to grow naturally, with a natural canopy. "Drooping" limbs, if they are lower limbs and in the way, are simply cut off as part of routine maintenance.

    I don't think we know where you are located, but there are probably other larger shrubs that can be made into trees there.