Love the navy just because I am sick of gray!

Depends...what’s your flooring? They’re both equally beautiful but the lighter blue obviously lightens the whole kitchen up so if you have darker floors I’d go that route.

I love the darker island , but as kk asked, what ste yout floor? can you post a picture?

Although I love navy, I think I prefer the lighter one. However, as others have said, it really depends on what you have-- the navy island kitchen has dark counters and the lighter island has light counters. For what it's worth.

Floor is bare concrete right now so it can go either way.

Both so pretty! I've saved both those kitchens as well. Are you keeping bare concrete floors?

A natural, real wood island would be gorgeous next to the concrete, and it's timeless....

Well, I guess the good news is that either one looks pretty good. In other words, I think you can't really go wrong. ( but I voted for lighter which is not my usual preference so it might just be those combos).

I voted darker - I like the contrast.

If this were the floor, which one would you choose?

Suzanne, if that was the floor, I would probably do the darker island. I think either could look nice.

Salonva, I usually go for the darker too, but I really like the lighter color with the white. That's why I wondered what you thought.

So whose color and name is the lighter color and whose is the darker. Be reminded that colors in pictures look very different in person.