Software
Houzz Logo Print
benjamin_b66

Help with Douglas Fir

7 years ago

Hello,

I have three Douglas Fir tress in the backyard of a home we recently moved to. One is especially sparse but the other two seem to be leaning that direction too. Also I notice today that many of the needs toward the inner portion of the trees are starting to yellow. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Location is SE MI


(Going to try to upload photos, it's not allowing me to post with images)



Comments (10)

  • 7 years ago

    Swiss Needle Cast has been establishing itself in Ontario over the past 10 years...suspect you’re seeing the same.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Finally figured out how to upload photos! Do you think this looks like Swiss Needle Cast?

    Tree · More Info


    Tree · More Info


  • 7 years ago

    I'd suggest taking samples (and your photos) to your local extension service office for an accurate ID.

    Yours does not present the way SNC typically presents, with typically yellowed and sparsely foliated crowns and with infection occurring on the newest growth, rather than on interior, older growth.

    I can't state that it isn't SNC with any certainty......while the pathogen is widespread here in the Doug's native range, because of tree height and density, it is difficult to confirm except by air. Although surrounded by Doug's, most of which are also very tall, I have not seen much sign of it. And I haven't been to many Christmas tree plantations recently to see how it might be affecting younger, smaller trees more in line with the OP's.

  • 7 years ago

    what she said ... as to potential disease ... check it out ...


    first pic.. upper part is reverting to normal growth pattern ... key word.. normal ... it was probably sheared in the nursery ... to make a pretty plant for sale purposes ... if you are referring to that part being sparse ... it is NOT ... its normal growth ...


    second pic.. no conifer .. nor any evergreen ... holds its leaves forever ... in the conifer world ... they are held 1 to 3 seasons... and then it is normal to shed them ... this can be increased by severe winter.. or severe summer ... like drought ... this is why most conifers ... are nudey... leafless ... inside.. where the sun gets blocked out.. as the tree grows in all dimensions ...


    in this pic.. most of the minor yellowing .. is 2 or third years leaves.. and they are being shed ... you look to a growth tip.. and then at the bark.. as you track back into the branch.. and you can literally see.. the various years growth ...


    rule out disease ... but once you do that.. dont go trying to solve things which are not problems ... there is nothing to do about NORMAL shedding ...


    with large forest trees... i call it the ugly teen years.. going from that cute little tree you bought ... into the forest tree it is ... [prior owner bought]


    keep us up to date ... and welcome to the forums ....


    ken


    the future of your plain old doug fir

    https://duckduckgo.com/?q=Douglas+Fir&t=ffcm&ia=images&iax=images

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Douglas firs are often like other western NA & European conifers (Norway spruce is one exception) -- short-lived in the east. Some form of needlecast is the usual problem, & also pine wilt for pines.

  • 7 years ago

    Douglas Fir in southern Ontario was rock solid until Swiss Needle Cast became established. Gardengal48's description is more consistent with the most severe manifestation of the disease and seen as the worst affected trees.


    Typically, the new growth IS NOT affected as the infection level is cumulative year-on-year until enough stomates are blocked and the needle is shed. Around here, that means 1-2 year needle retention and sickly looking trees. Current year growth is involved on some trees but I can't say if that's the fungus directly or indirectly (weakened tree) as I've only seen that on trees growing in poorer locations (low summer moisture or poor/compacted soils). There are still some trees that are going strong...either because they are fairly isolated, local spring conditions aren't as conducive to infection, or they are more naturally resistant.

  • 7 years ago

    I really do urge you to get the issue properly diagnosed/accurately ID'd before you start ad libbing with any control options. It is very tricky to accurately assess or identify woody plant pathogens just from a couple of photos.:-) There can be multiple causes that will produce superficially similar symptoms and you really need the benefit of a path lab or at the very least, a strong magnifier to differentiate.

    If it is SNC, it can be treated with a fungicide containing chlorothalonil but timing of application is critical. If your extension service confirms the SNC, they will also suggest the proper timing for your area.

  • 7 years ago

    If it ends up being something the requires spraying, personally I would tear that thing out and restart with something else. Why bother dealing with spraying it for a few years till it gets too big to effectively treat without drifting pesticides all over your property.