Software
Houzz Logo Print
pjsbconroy

Cabinet recommendations.

7 years ago

Bathroom remodel

Replacing vanity 8 foot space between 3 walls. White painted shaker style.


Looking For feedback on quality of cabinets

-Waypoint

-Wellborn Forest

-Panda

-Merrilat


Decora, Omega and the like fun over $5,000. For a secondary bathroom, exploring other options. $$


The cabinet bases and top have me way over budget.


Floating two stock smaller vanities leaves awkward unusable space.


Thank you

Comments (17)

  • 7 years ago

    A local cabinet maker can be surprisingly affordable. They can provide exactly what you want; drawer size and placement, stained wood or paint over maple.

  • 7 years ago

    Thank you !!

    very helpful.

  • 7 years ago

    live_wire_oak


    Merril $2,500

    Wayp -$3,300

    Wellb - $2,400


    thoughts on Schrock and Shiloh?

    Thank you.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    There is a poster who did Shiloh cabinets in her kitchen and is very pleased with the quality.

    I just remodeled and had a local place do all of the cabinets in kitchen and bathrooms but I have no idea how the price compared to a semi-custom brand. I designed with various aesthetic and functional design choices in terms of wood, door style and configuration and so the price of my fully custom made locally was less than if I attempted to get the same with a "brand". I had a built in hamper made and all of my cabinets including the sink cabinet have pullouts. I installed a special roll out for hair stuff which includes an electric plug.

    I don't think bathroom vanities get as much use as kitchen cabinets so I personally wouldn't be as concerned with getting the highest quality if budget is an issue. You obviously don't want crap - but you are not going to be opening and closing doors and drawers as frequently nor will you have drawers and shelves carrying the kind of heavy loads of dishes and cookware that kitchen cabinets do.

    I would focus on aesthetics and functionality so that it works best for you needs - whatever those happen to be.

    P C thanked Helen
  • 7 years ago

    At that price, they put you in Merillat Classic, not Masterpiece. Which is fine, but it is below Waypoint in quality, as is reflected by the price. Price and quality are linked. Shiloh snd Schrock (great choices) should be a but more than Merillat Masterpiece, which should be more than Waypoint. There is no escaping that price and quality link. Higher quality will be higher priced.

    P C thanked User
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Factory should start at $1-2K

  • 7 years ago

    She doesn’t want kindling. This is 8’ of cabinets. There is no way to do that with anything of even low box store quality at 1K.

  • 7 years ago

    With tax and delivery we paid $1800 for 42" of vanity (Starmark), plain shaker full overlay doors, maple painted white. We did an offset sink so 3 nice sized drawers on one side. We are happy with the quality.

    P C thanked adawn5
  • 7 years ago

    interesting, wellb forest prices similar

    to Panda, which made me leery.


    With a major kitchen redo in the future. This helps paint a more realistic picture. Thanks !!


  • PRO
    7 years ago

    $5k for 8 lineal feet of vanity is $625 per foot for a factory cabinet?



  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    96” of cabinetry can cost 2K on the lower builder quality end, with the toe kick, and at least a couple of drawers. In other words, with a desirable result.

    I’ve also done 12K in the Omega custom end. Yes, $1500 a foot. Except that’s not how cabinet pricing is calculated any more than a homes pricing is calculated by the square foot. An inset cabinet design with 2 towers, 2 large drawer stacks, decorative furniture feet and detailing, plus a specialty finish will cost $$$ no matter who makes it. High quality cabinets have a lot high quality materials and a lengthy production time that is reflected in their costs.

    No drawers at all, just doors, in a poor quality stained oak finish, isn’t what most people want, even for a secondary bathroom. That’s the only 1K product that you could even find for 8’ of cabinets. Or import flatpack.

    Kraftmaid Vantage or Merillat Masterpiece (same company, virtually identical specs) is a very nice mid range product. Schrock and Shiloh full lines, (not the lesser spec’d junior like like Merillat Classic) would be similar in quality. And pricing. More than Waypoint. Given the numbers discussed in your other quotes, those should be 3800-4500, if similar specs are maintained, and you are actually compared true like items.

    The junior lines like Merillat Classic also offer a nice product if that higher number isn’t doable. Examine the specs to understand the differences between the full lines and junior lines. See if those are “good enough” for you. They are for many people, and I’ve used them plenty of times.

    P C thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    Live wire oak


    your thoughts on


    Wood Pro $3,300


    omega $4,000

    not sure I need this grade for a secondary bath.


    merrillat classic $2,500

    waypoint $3,300


    is wood pro comparable to waypoint?


    im only familiar w omega

    at this point the numbers are close enough


    thank you. Appreciate your feedback

  • 7 years ago

    Of the list, and as other posters suggested, waypoint is a good option. I couldn't choose them because they didn't have a stain/color we really wanted, so we had to go up in price a bit for a Kraftmaid. Which actually has worked out fine so far. There is another brand out there -Fabuwood? Good hinges, it's like ikea, maybe a touch better.

    P C thanked Rebecca Mauri
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    What's the layout? One sink or 2 ? Drawers? Upper cabinets?

    You can do something like this ( 2 48 "vanities ) White shaker from Kraftmaid delivered to your home for about $3200



    P C thanked Debbi Washburn
  • 7 years ago

    Have you checked with local cabinet builders? We paid about 7K to a local cabinet maker to build us an 8' vanity with a tower in the middle, a 4.5' wide 8' tall hutch-style linen cabinet with drawers and laundry pullout below and cabinets above, and some floating shelves in a weird nook with a closed cabinet below. I don't know the cost of just the vanity bc the quote was for everything. but the linen cabinet is very large, and required some innovative work to get it the way we wanted, so I think it was a substantial part of the 7K. Of course you have to add the countertop cost, fabrication, installation, and on-site painting painting in order to compare apples to apples. So I don't know if it's more or less expensive to go the custom route. We decided to do it because we were able to get exactly what we wanted and utilize every inch of a quirky layout.

  • 5 years ago

    I can only speak for the quality and customer service of Wellborn Forest, and both are poor. You can view some of the quality issues in my Ideabook or at https://lkldkitchenredo.tumblr.com/. Avoid Wellborn Forest. They did send a rep who ordered replacement pieces, but when those arrived in as bad shape as the first, the next order never came, and my kitchen was never fixed. They were happy to take the money and run though.