Software
Houzz Logo Print
daisydavid

Kitchen Cabinet Painting

6 years ago

Can anyone help with paint color and brand for my kitchen cabinet refinish project? I would like to know what white would work best and which brand- I use BM almost exclusively - Thanks

Comments (31)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I’d use BM Advance, but I can’t recommend a color without seeing photos.:)

  • 6 years ago

    BM Advance. Choose a color that looks good in the space and with the light in that space.

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks! The painter I want to use and Ace Hardware said BM Advance was the right product. What about sanding the surfaces or just use the BM primer (Advance?) Will that work without sanding or roughing up finish? Ive read some horror stories on here about bad cabinet paint jobs....prep seems to be the biggest culprit in botched cabinet painting projects. Any advice?

  • 6 years ago

    What BM white would you recommend? I dont want any off whites or colors.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    While Advance is a great consumer grade product for DIY, it’s not the product that a professional cabinet finisher would use. If you are paying good money to replace a factory tough finish, you should expect to have an equally tough professional finish applied. You wouldn’t want to pay for something less durable than what you have, would you? A cabinet coating pro would use a conversion varnish or 2K poly finish. Not a consumer grade trim paint.




  • 6 years ago

    Thank you!

  • 6 years ago

    We painted our cabinets 8 years ago and we used Ace Hardware Alkyd paint. They look just as good as the day we painted them. We also prepped them very well. I did a lot of research before we started. my husband is in the trades and this paint was recommended by several different professional painters.

  • 6 years ago

    Beth

    No I was paying a local painter to pain them but now Ive put on hold after reading responses to my questions about painting kitchen cabinets. I had a few painters quote me off Home Advisor's and they were all going to paint them and described the same process.... one coat of "special' primer and 2 coats of BM Advance type of paint. The local painter - one man band that has been painting for 30 years seemed very knowledgeable and got thumbs up from Ace HW employees who vouched for his work.


    The bottom line for me is where do i find the "pros" to do this job the "right" way and what is estimated price range for doing it properly- meaning prepping the cabinets properly and using the products which should be a given one would think but apparently not. Im trying to avoid posting the "horror" projects Ive read about so greatly appreciate the feedback from everyone.


    As layman I thought spraying would be the correct way to do cabinet painting but I was told its messy and not neccessary if you use the right products and process as you noted.


    Where are you located? Im in Metro North Boston area and would welcome referrals.


    Thank you

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks for the info Suedonim75! I'll look into Alkyd paint. I dont need to go to Ace just did because they were close and they carry BM paint which Ive used many times and been happy. Painting cabinets is another story though and I want to get it right.

  • 6 years ago

    Beth - I really like the pain color on your cabinets! That is color i would use on mine - just need the right painter now! Thanks again for the advice.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Try this FB group for a Pro. They are a DIY group, there to help you if you want to tackle it. But there are plenty of professional cabinet finishing Pros sprinkled in as well. To be fair, there’s lots of folks in there who are paid money to use homeowner grade products too. But I wouldn’t suggest using them.


    https://www.facebook.com/groups/PaintingKitchenCabinetsforProfit/?ref=share 

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    david,,that Alklyd. paint is the Advance. Advance is a hybrid between oil and water base.

    Most good, pro cabinet painters will use a spray lacquer (with a finish similar to the painted cabinets you would buy from a factory).

    for my kitchen, it wasn't cheap. (I have 62 handles if that gives you an idea of how many cabinets I have!) I had a hood made, cabinets modified for my micro and other drawers, shelves made, and I had all new door fronts and drawer fronts (which were only 2K more) . without seeing how large you kitchen is, expect to pay anywhere from 4K for a very small to up to 9K for a larger kitchen. That's the going rate. (mine was more than that because of all the modifications I had done) Without any of that or the refacing, prob would have been 8-9K for the amount of cabinets I had to do.

    I have painted 2 kitchens on my own doing the sanding, priming and paining method and it's a ton of work. very easy to cut corners. Meaning, they might not completely prep your wood by taking it all the way down, sanding well, cleaning and then priming. a lot of companies skip the sanding part and just prime. This is where you will run into adhesion problems that result in chipping and peeling paint. All of the drawer rails had to be unscrewed and removed from the bases. (and I had soft close hardware put on all my doors) And of course they should never paint on site. that's the sign of a second rate painter. (they will paint your bases on site, obviously, by properly taping and plastic sheeting off the the room, but doors/drawers all go back to the warehouse).




    Lacquer is easier because it's sprayed and dries almost immediately once it hits the surface. The paint particles are atomized through the spray and form a nice finish.

    So, you need to find a Pro Cabinet painter. I used Kitchen experts that I found on Yelp, believe it or not. They had at least 100 reviews and all were in the 4-5 star range. that's what you look for.

    then question them about exactly what they do and the products they use. it shouldn't be a secret.

    Usually a deposit is made up front, another payment after they remove your cabs to take them back to the shop, another when they come out to spray the bases, and final payment is made when it's all put back together. They should bring you a new toe kick too. I had my flooring replaced while everything was being painted. If you plan on new floors or countertops, get it done before the cabs go back in. Oh, and they should also spray you a sample cabinet of the color you pick so you can see what it looks like

  • 6 years ago

    I hate posting this every time some design pro comments on spraying conversion varnish in a home.

    Conversion varnish should not be sprayed in your home. It really shouldn't even enter your home ever, but at least having it delivered a few weeks later will see a lot less formaldehyde in your home. It is a health hazard and banned in Europe for a very good reason.

    There is nothing wrong with BM Advance it is a standard high solid waterborne solvent paint. Which is the exact same thing as many products being marketed as a waterborne conversion varnish (Which is not actually a conversion varnish). It is not the best product available, but it is a good product to apply in the field, which is different than spraying in a production shop.

    I would personally look for advice from people who have actually laid down a finish before.

    Good luck

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you for your advice

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I hate posting this every time some design pro comments on spraying conversion varnish in a home.

    And I really hate having to be redundant and pointing out what I actually said.

    bry,,,where did I say conversion varnish? I said lacquer, which dries much faster than a varnish. they are two diff products.

    I never said there was anything wrong w/Advance, just the people who use it and don't follow proper protocol. You can get a great finish w/Advance or the SW Cabinet line. You just have to know how to properly prep.


    I also said they should not spray on site. however, being that the bases are part of the kitchen and can't be removed, they must spray those. But with the right sprayer the overspray is minimal. there is no lasting odor like there was from oil based paint. it was a summer day so all of the doors/windows were open and they had fans. There was no lingering smell. I'm sure there were some fumes, but not enough to cause adverse effects.

    I don't know of anyone out here that used a conversion varnish to spray inside someones house.

    I'll also finish by mentioning that Calif has the strictest rules for VOC's in the entire union. If there was anything dangerous about using LACQUER in the home for cabinets, I'm sure some lawmaker in Sacramento would see to it that it not be used. You can't even buy Lacquer Thinner at the hardware store anymore.

    and as for off-gassing of formaldehyde, if you buy any textile products (or anything else for that matter) made in china, you're going to get a lot more. rugs, furniture, melamine tables, shelves, etc, all have it.

    Hey Bry,,,are you also this vocal when someone brings in quartz countertops or melamine cabinets into their kitchen?

    there is also a formaldehyde tester. if anyone is so inclined to see if products or lacquer is 'off-gassing', they can use it.

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    The majority of cabinets are not sprayed in the home. It’s the whole point of using a Pro that has the space to take the doors to do it correctly in their shop. B&R or even spraying, with some of the 1K or 2K stuff is perfectly fine in a home, with a pro utilizing proper safety measures. There’s been a lot of innovations in coatings technology.

    https://youtu.be/0eVuS37o3Uc


    https://www.facebook.com/groups/prorefinisherschatroom/?ref=share

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    We use Sherwin Williams ProIndustrial - Alkyd waterbased in a semi glass finish. This commercial grade and best for cabinets - should be applied with a sprayer. Good basic whites are Alabaster or Snowbound. A great dark gray is City Scape - but my new Love - Sherwin Williams Color of the Year - Naval - see pic. Isn't that classic!


  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    bry,,,where did I say conversion varnish? I said lacquer, which dries much faster than a varnish. they are two diff products.

    Did I say I was talking to you? So I will tell you where you said conversion varnish when you tell me where I said a single thing about you. Honestly, I don't even remember reading your post.

    However, for your own edification, conversion varnish actually is a type of lacquer. There are several types of lacquers and conversion varnish is a lacquer with solid contents high enough that it can't cross link with sulfonic acid alone so a Xylene is added to catalyze it.

    I never said there was anything wrong w/Advance

    I never said anyone said there was something wrong with advance. I just said there was nothing wrong with it, but I can't see how that would have anything to do with you.

    I'll also finish by mentioning that Calif has the strictest rules for VOC's in the entire union. If there was anything dangerous about using LACQUER in the home for cabinets, I'm sure some lawmaker in Sacramento would see to it that it not be used.

    I was talking specifically about the trick of chemically bonding xylene to limit the amount of free formaldehyde and then using advanced mixing techniques to reduce formaldehyde but significantly lengthen the time over which bound formaldehyde will be debonded by xylene. Remember that most conversion varnishes are using 3% Catalyst which pretty hard to get right. So the odds of some of those molecular bonds coming undone are really quite high, and unlike properly catalyzed conversion varnish, conversion varnish that has been over/under catalyzed might extend the formaldehyde release time by weeks or even months.

    As for what happens in Sacramento, I don't know. I do know what happened in the E.U. though.

    As for there being nothing dangerous about spraying a lacquer in a home...

    https://lmgtfy.com/?q=lacquer+explosion 

    Everyone who has been working with wood for any amount of time knows someone or of someone who blew up their shop.





  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    B&R or even spraying, with some of the 1K or 2K stuff is perfectly fine in a home, with a pro utilizing proper safety measures. There’s been a lot of innovations in coatings technology.

    https://youtu.be/0eVuS37o3Uc

    Watch the part at 2:04. There is nothing wrong with a water based 2 part poly in a home and I am great with 2 part poly's in general although I prefer the ICA over the Milesi. However, I don't think it is great to spray on cabinets in a customer's home that are already installed. Regardless of where the doors are sprayed, the boxes have to be sprayed in someone's home and I haven't developed the skill to do it in a home yet.

    Furthermore, I haven't heard of someone doing a 2k poly in homes. I am glad that is happening but it is not happening in my area and I doubt it is happening in many areas.

  • 6 years ago

    bry,,whatever.. don't be shy then when you feel the need to correct someone. Just say, "I disagree w/Cooks Kitchen remark about conversion varnish or 2K".

    Why beat around the bush and blather on about, " I hate posting this every time some design pro comments on spraying conversion varnish in a home." You obviously don't hate it that much. Come out and say what you want to say. no need to pontificate and give us a chem class.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    @Beth H. :

    I am sorry to disappoint you, but my annoyance wasn't actually directed at any specific person in this thread but at the constant regurgitation of that response overall. I wouldn't feel comfortable calling out Cook's Kitchen because I am unsure whether or not this was the first time I have addressed this issue with her. It just never fails that someone will note that real pros use CV...

    I was using the expression as a literary device to draw attention to what I was saying and not an invitation to drama. I assure you, that I honestly just want the kitchen industry to move away from CV, I love 2K's and have no problem with them. However, there are certain production reasons that CV is still used more heavily in the U.S. Which is fine, it is what it is... However, I would like people who are about to spray things in their house to realize the concern they are accepting for a slight increase in durability.

    I maybe should have expressed my acceptance of 2K's more clearly, however, that is not my crusade so it just didn't happen. I might also note that at some point half the industry started calling waterborne solvent based finishes conversion varnish and so half the stuff that says conversion varnish on the can is just BM Advance by a different name.

  • 6 years ago

    thank you bry. good info

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you all for very enlightening education in kitchen cabinet painting!! I have to say honestly Im more confused now then when I started as I dont know what best option is for me.


    My takeaway is "spraying" in the home does not offer substantial advantages over traditional painting methods with focus being on "prep" work on the cabinets. Im not sure I want to use the local painter that would use the BM Advance or similar product only because it seemed like he minimized the "prep" part of the process - He said "you dont need to do much to the cabinets because the primer with bonding agent will be good enough with 2 additional coats on top of the primer. He did say it would take a week with drying time between coats so he had that part right.


    I truly appreciate all the info from everyone and certainly did not want to see bry911 get into it with Beth H - you BOTH are clearly passionate about helping someone looking for guidance so I'll take note of both of your responses and try to get to bottom line. Beth H is fan of spraying and bry is not - even if i spray the cabinets faces I still need to spray the boxes so I dont see how you get around spraying one without the other since the boxes/frames are already installed. The cabinets are light walnut with not much grain and not high gloss finish. I know of friend that had local painter paint his cherry wood cabinets ( He just started in the business) and I was at his home over the holidays and they looked great. So again Im more confused than when i started because I dont know what is right way to go now.


    Can anyone point me to someone in Boston area that can handle this project?


    Much appreciated everyone's input- especially bry and Beth. :)


  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Just to be clear, I am a BIG fan of spraying. I am not always a fan of spraying commercial products in a home. When you start getting into commercial products that you plan on spraying in someone's home I would prefer a water based product but waterborne will sometimes give you a lot of the advantages with significantly fewer dangers.

    There are many good water based and waterborne products out there. BM Advance is good and durable but pretty thick and relatively hard to spray if you are not experienced. Kem Aqua Plus from Sherwin Williams is a good waterborne paint that sprays easier as it is much thinner. Both are going to be comparable in durability to a Lacquer but will have less yellowing problems and are safer. There are several waterborne alkyd systems that will give you a decent durable finish that can be applied in your home with relative safety.

    -----

    I am just going to assume that your painter wants to use Zinser BIN as a primer and paint over it (BIN sticks to everything and everything sticks to BIN). It is hard to give you definite solutions on cabinets I haven't seen and touched, but lots of people will clean cabinets thoroughly with TSP and a scotch-brite pad and skip the sanding step. How well that works depends on your cabinets and what they are painted with now. It is certainly not unheard of for quality refinishers to not put a thorough sand on a detailed cabinet. If your current product has good adhesion and you can get some tooth to it without sanding, then the marginal benefit vs. marginal cost of sanding can be a legitimate issue. Prep is absolutely the reason most cabinets repaints fail, but there is not a one-size-fits-all solution to prep.

    Zinser BIN can be a bit brittle. It is a great product and usually performs pretty well but it is a refinish and not a factory finish. It will not be as good as a factory finish, but at some point you have to face the fact that there is a reason you didn't replace your cabinets in the first place... So work on getting a great quality finish that will last, but don't spend a dollar chasing a dime.

  • 6 years ago

    THANK YOU

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I agree with Bri to not chase a dime and lose a dollar. But my main point remains unchallenged. Why pay a “professional” to do a DIY level job? If that is the level of job that you want, just go ahead and DIY. You can do a great job, if you take the time to do all of the steps needed.

    Finding someone who does the proper prep, which includes a lot of sanding, and who sprays a professional level product, can be challenging in some areas of the country. It’s worth seeking out, before you default to using someone that I would not use, no matter what product he used. Anyone who doesn’t do the proper prep is setting you up for a coating failure.

    Prep is prep. It’s not optional. It’s 85% of the job.The costs between a “good” homeowner product job, and one using a much more durable professional product? They are quite small. Because 85% of the work is the prep, not the choice of costing on top of that prep.

    If you indicate your location, perhaps there are resources in that location that you have not yet found.

  • 6 years ago

    When we painted our cabinets we did all the steps to make sure they were prepped. Our cabinets were the original cabinets put in, in 1968. The owner was elderly, and the cabinets were absolutely filthy. The edges had so much gunk on them that I had to scrape them with a putty knife. I sanded every last inch of them and then washed them down. We primed them very well and then used the Alkyd paint. We did this during the spring/early summer and we didn't have to worry too much about fumes because we opened windows and did work in the garage.

    The finish on my cabinets is rock hard and still shiny 8 years later. I have not had to do any touch up.

  • 6 years ago

    Points taken and much appreciated. I dont have time or desire for DIY project. I'll keep looking to find right professional and ensure they follow the practices noted in these responses taking all into consideration. On another note has anyone ever heard of Nhance which is proprietary process? They are contractor that Home Depot uses for refinish option on cabinets. Apparently they have UV light curing process that eliminates many of the issues mentioned in this thread - unfortunately I dont know anyone that has used them and have not heard much discussed about the Nhance name or process one way or the other. Interesting concept using special bonding liquid that cures with UV light to very hard finish. I have not idea what the cost is either so it may be crazy money. Thanks again for all the feedback.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    NHance is a UV cured cross linked 2K system. You still have to do the prep. There is NOTHING that eliminates having to do the work. NHsnce might as well be liquid gold put on the cabinets for what they want you to pay for the process. You can replace the cabinets with a good quality brand for what they want.

  • 6 years ago

    Wow OK - I get the biggest take away from all this is PREP!! Thanks for insight intointo NHance