Software
Houzz Logo Print
feathers11

Balance challenge

6 years ago

I came across a video by Dr. Christiane Northrup last year about balancing on one foot, and the benefits of doing this with your eyes closed because (something science-y I don't remember but it made sense). There are many other videos and links you can find, too. (Including this one: https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/287201.php#1). It's not just for injury prevention, but also relates to brain health.

Essentially, the challenge is balancing on one foot with eyes open for 20 seconds, and then close your eyes while balancing for another 20 seconds. Repeat with other foot. Work your way up to longer times.

I've been incorporating this at the end of my workouts, and I've noticed an improvement. I can often go for a full 60 seconds. With my eyes open is easy... closing them throws me off, but that, IIRC, is where the benefit comes in your body's ability to adjust.

Try it! In the meantime, I'll see if I can find Dr. Northrup's original video. The one that currently pops up for me doesn't give a full explanation like the earlier one does.

Comments (27)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Haven't seen Dr. Northrup's video but I worked with a personal trainer at my university wellness center before I retired and standing on one foot to balance with eyes open and closed was something he had me work do too. He was certified and was also a grad student in physical therapy . IIRC his explanation was that when we close our eyes we lose the additional 'leveling' that our vision gives us spatially...or something like that ;).

    And it sure was hard to do! I'd forgotten about it and will definitely start working on that again. It's such a simple life exercise to do anywhere. Thanks for the tip.

  • 6 years ago

    "(something science-y I don't remember but it made sense)

    LOL, you sound like me!

    I've heard it suggested to do this while brushing your teeth; kind of a twofer. I never think of it but can see where it would be a good practice to get into.

  • 6 years ago

    Our water fitness trainer has us do this at the end of every class during the cool down - it's a great exercise.

  • 6 years ago

    With my eyes open, I can balance on either foot for over three minutes at which point I am too bored to continue. With eyes closed, though, yikes! That is a different story. I never have tried that before and I didn't even make it to 15 seconds on either foot. Guess I had better practice that!


  • 6 years ago

    I've added balance exercises to my workout. You don't need a science-y explanation--trying it yourself will convince you that balancing with your eyes closed is much much harder than with your eyes open. Also challenging is keeping your eyes open but turning your head from left to right. Or extending your raised foot in front of you, then to the side, then to the back. All harder than they sound.

  • 6 years ago

    Okay, I stopped after 2 minutes with my eyes open. Barely made 5 seconds with them closed! 😂


    Here's an explanation:


    Visual cues from our eyes give us information about where we are in space. This is why it can be difficult to keep your balance with your eyes closed. Your eyes also send signals to your brain, telling your joints and muscles where and how to move.


    https://saveourbones.com/hows-your-balance-take-this-30-second-test-to-find-out/

  • 6 years ago

    OMG, I need to practice this! I have gotten to where I can't stand on one leg and put my jeans on. I have had some serious near falls from trying that. Currently I have o sit to pull jeans on.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Since taking barre and yoga, my balance has improved, but still not good for long periods of time and esp if the balance includes movement...and that's with eyes open and staring at a single spot.

    Eyes closed...a whole 'nother thing.

    I've been doing 2 min planking every night before bed and want to add side planking to the mix. Perhaps some closed-eye balancing would be good too.

  • 6 years ago

    I have decent balance with eyes open and will try with eyes closed. Another life skill to work on continuously as we age is getting up off the floor...without using hands if possible. An exercise we do at kettlebell class is great for this. It's a Turkish get-up. You can see it on youtube...takes some getting used to, but a really good one.

  • 6 years ago

    I can balance on one foot while on a variety of wobbly objects like a champ but eyes closed I haven't tried in a while. Think I'll start on solid floor first!

  • 6 years ago

    Nit-picky question here: shoes on, or shoes off? Socks?

  • 6 years ago

    I went down the rabbit hole of trying to find Dr. Northrup's video on this challenge. Who knew there is so much about this topic? balancing on one leg with eyes closed

    DH and I just took the challenge, and like Jinx we are drinking wine (and cooking while watching the Super Bowl. Probably not the best conditions.) We made it to the teens. Will try again tomorrow.

  • 6 years ago

    bpath, is this the video?

  • 6 years ago

    My PT has me do with shoes on; it's easier barefoot.

  • 6 years ago

    Dr Northrup used to be on the Oprah Show on occasion. Usually, the topics were around menopause. I believe she has written a few books also.

  • 6 years ago

    I actually find balancing easier with shoes on if they are supportive.

  • 6 years ago

    Some of my workout videos have you balance on one foot while doing overhead presses or bicep curls. It really works your core to do both at the same time!

    Donna

  • 6 years ago

    Back when I was in PT, I did balance exercises, wearing sneakers, standing on a thick foam pad, eyes both open and shut. It’s surprising how hard eyes shut can be. Now I do them standing on a Bosu ball (more elevated than a foam pad), sneakers on, eyes open. I should practice with my eyes shut on my foam pad at home.

    Speaking of a core workout, a guy at my gym walks with his arms fully extended above his head, carrying a bar with a small kettlebell hanging off each side of the bar. He might walk one foot in front of the other. His personal trainer gently pushes the client’s side as they walk along. I said to my personal trainer, I don’t want to do that one. She just laughed and said they've been working together for 3 years. Note to self: change trainers after 2 years.

  • 6 years ago

    I've tried the "balance challenge" before and was quite surprised at how miserably I did. My balance is definitely not what it once was, and this has affected my ability to get out and do things that I once thought nothing of -- i.e., scaling heights when hiking and rock scrambling was involved. I found myself seated on the edge of a mesa in a remote New Mexico region two years ago, unable to climb upwards as I'd done 20-ish years ago, for fear that my balance would be insufficient. I sat there and cried ... and then DH climbed back down and we went off and did another trail that turned out to be wonderful. Still -- that was a very eye-opening moment for me.


    I've been doing some work on my exercise ball since I've gotten back to weightlifting over the past month, and find it a real challenge. This tells me my core desperately needs strengthening.

  • 6 years ago

    In one of my exercise classes, we do what Donna mentioned. We wrap one foot around the ankle of the opposite leg while we do a set of bicep curls. Then we switch and do another set of curls. Generally, I'm able to maintain my balance.


    I tried balancing with my eyes closed and I don't last but a few seconds! Yikes, I thought I'd do better than that. But, really, isn't it more important to be able to balance for a long time with your eyes open?

  • 6 years ago

    FWIW, I do yoga poses that involve balancing on one foot - been doing so for years now. There are a number of poses that involve standing on one leg, and then switching sides.

  • 6 years ago

    My dd has this thing called a “stunt stand” she uses for cheer...basically it is a small moveable block attached to a base with about an 18” pole. She uses it to practice stunts and stretches she does in the air when she isn’t with her bases. For example, she’d stand on it on one leg and raise her other leg straight up. Well, after reading this, I thought the stunt stand would be a great thing to do this balance exercise on. 😳😂 OMG....I could barely do it with my eyes open!!! I feel certain I would have completely fallen off the stand and damaged myself if I’d shut my eyes! Gah, aging is the devil!

  • 6 years ago

    Interestingly after I posted yesterday about getting up off the floor without using your hands, the trainer at my kettlebell gym sent us this link today, about this very skill.

    aging test


  • 6 years ago

    jmck that's very interesting...I'll have to try it and see how I do, and see how DH does...

  • 6 years ago

    I KNOW I won't be able to do that!

    I can balance on one foot for a minute, but when I tried to do it eyes closed? Nope, had to put my hand on the table to steady me after 3 seconds.

  • 6 years ago

    I got the down with no trouble, it's the up that's a challenge! I needed a knee so lost a point. Something to work on for sure.

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz