Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_21884067

...do you like thorny roses?...

6 years ago

'The Country Parson' scares me to death... I couldn't imagine anything eating this... rabbits, deer?.. surely not..



...you are welcome to show your worst offenders...

Comments (41)

  • 6 years ago

    Unfortunately, though, those thorns won't stop anything which wants to eat that plant. Most of what will get eaten is new, soft, fresh, succulent growth whose prickles aren't any kind of defense. And, anything that is going to munch those harder canes isn't going to pay attention to the prickles. Though I can appreciate mosses and really decorative prickles, I admit that I have moved away from deliberately growing that kind of "flesh ripper" in more recent years. If my roses want blood, they're going to have to really WORK for it from me.

  • 6 years ago

    I agree that thorns won't stop deer at all. They ignore the thorny stuff and concentrate on the soft new growth, buds, and blooms like Kim says. Thorns will stop burglars (maybe), and UPS men tearing through the snow (which conceals the deadly roses). Unfortunately, I've witnessed this awful collision between man and thorn. Diane

  • 6 years ago

    Hands down my thorniest is Mdm Hardy which I will grab a pic of once the kids go down for their nap

  • 6 years ago

    ..certainly gives a new twist to ''lock up your daughters''.. that is one thorny rose..

  • 6 years ago

    Doesn't it? LOL! Now, THAT'S a "chastity device"! LOL!

  • 6 years ago

    I love thorny roses. They add to the charm of the plant, especially if the blooms are pink, large and fragrant (looking at you, Gertrude Jekyll). That bit of danger when you try to take a cutting without gloves makes it all the more fun to grow.

    That picture of Waldtraut Nielsen gives me anxiety though for some reason...I think if I grew it i'd have to kill it before it can kill me

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    My thorniest is Stanwell Perpetual. I have said before that it belongs in the cactus family. The prickles aren't big, but like a million needles (spinosissima). That's the reason it's leaving this year. I loved the idea of a Scotch Briar Rose because my husband is of Scottish descent, but I couldn't handle it another year, literally. Pine needles get packed into the center and are impossible to remove, so it always looks a mess and can't be healthy for the rose.

    HMF has this interesting note: Continuous (perpetual) bloom throughout the season, occasional repeat later in the season.

  • 6 years ago

    God NOOOOOO! I use to not mind them.... I would get scratched because I am not a glove kind of person...... but one of my attackers scratched my cornea. I would just as soon have another C-section and this time without pain meds.... because NOTHING in my entire life has hurt more than that. Not only did it scratch my cornea I then got an infection in it and it was AWFUL..... I don't have any enemies (at least none that I know of) but I would NEVER ever wish that on them...... That being said, I love them from a far and in other people's gardens..... but give me a good old black spot disease prone rose and I would be MUCH happier with it in MY garden than anything that thinks Audrey is just a sweetie.



  • 6 years ago

    Pink Surprise is a thorny beast.


  • 6 years ago

    Ewww, Sheila, my UPS guy wouldn't like that one.


    Sharon, I hope your cornea healed properly. I'm glad I wear glasses--they may not protect as well as safety goggles, but they help, as evidenced my my scratched up lenses, which I know came from gardening misadventures.I wear gloves when pruning and I still get scratched, gouged and poked. You should see my gardening coat all ripped and torn. Big roses don't even need bad thorns to do lots of damage. They like to pull hair, too. Diane

  • 6 years ago




  • 6 years ago

    Nanadoll....did you fall into Waldtraut Nielsen by any chance?

    I hope what's left of you is ok lol!

  • 6 years ago

    No, but I grow a lot of huge roses. They can make mincemeat of you as you crawl around them trying to prune. That jacket is long gone. Now I have a coat to take a pic of. Diane

  • 6 years ago

    I am glad to hear there are roses that don"t have throns, the one at the very beginning looks like a real horror!

  • 6 years ago

    I grew the Austin rose Othello through the '90s. It had canes 3/4 inch thick and 10-12 feet tall, and at least as thorny as your picture of the Country Parson. Tieing those canes to a horizontal position against the fence, or worse, weeding around the base, was an exercise in planning and pain management. Nanadoll, those pics of your jacket are painful just to look at!

  • 6 years ago

    Sorry, rough nap time yesterday. Here’s a picture of the Madame and I swear it’s worse in person!



  • 6 years ago

    LOL I have sought out some of the thorniest roses I can find, to plant all around the perimeter of my property. My "fence" will eventually be 7-10 feet tall all around, and the roses are planted close together so their thorny canes cross. I am confident this will deter people from entering...and hopeful it will also deter deer.

  • 6 years ago

    Some of those Gallica and Mosses are similarly well endowed I've noticed... and I remind myself why I decided to ditch 'Blue For You' after liking it so much... but when I saw this.. that was enough for me...



  • 6 years ago

    Munstead Wood, of course, but my Peace tree rose is formidable. Pruning it was.. interesting. George Burns, when I had it, was ridiculously thorny.

  • 6 years ago

    I recently took a photo of Gentle Giant, due to the thorns.
    Carla in Sac

  • 6 years ago

    Of all my newly planted roses, the only one I left in the ground when I moved was Munstead Wood. It was beautiful but just too thorny to bother with...

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I don't mind thorny roses, especially now that I have a good pair of pruning gloves. The thorniest roses in my garden are definitely the rugosas. Some of them are Cactus like for sure, especially in the thorn's ability to break off little tips in your skin that are impossible to get out. This is Frau Dagmar Hastrup.


  • 6 years ago

    The wichurana roses don't have nearly as many thorns, but the ones they have are big and sharp. This is Sombreuil that I have over a gate, which certainly causes some trouble!


  • 6 years ago

    Some of the rugosas are truly frightening, and make me hesitate in planting them despite their other qualities.

  • 6 years ago

    I've always been impressed by soft-looking 'Jaune Desprez' looks and the contrast with its wicked thorns. But I have, and have had, plenty of roses I wouldn't want to fall into, and coming from a variety of classes. It might actually be easier to list the ones that are relatively pain-free to handle: for me the Lady Banks roses, 'Crepuscule', and 'Fantin-Latour' come to mind, as do many Gallicas. P.S. I don't remember the canes of my 'Mme. Hardy' looking like that.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Chris what gloves you use for your roses? I use bionic, but the fingers where out too fast. Love them for my hands, but last pair wore out quicker than usual. So looking to try something new.

    Diane my roses pull my hair too!

  • 6 years ago

    I accept thorns but think a rose looks friendlier the fewer thorns it has. Here is a picture from a site that's actually called " The Danger Garden" . Here's the Wingthorn Rose. I've thought of getting it just for its thorns.

    My clothes get so torn up gardening I buy gardening shirts from Goodwill that I can treat as disposable.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Well, darn, the picture didn't post. Here's a link:

    http://www.thedangergarden.com/2011/11/why-arent-you-growing-this-plant.html

    Or maybe this will work:

    Photo by Rosenschule Ruf on hmf

  • 6 years ago

    Erasmus... that picture reminds me of Dracula's mouth....[ sorry.].. really scary that one...

  • 6 years ago

    Yeah, I can see it. Looks like it's dripping blood. A vertical picture might not be so scary.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I was looking at Nanadoll's sweatshirt and nodding my head in sympathy at the memories of having clothes ripped up by thorny climbing roses. I have stopped wearing knit clothing for the job. They are too vulnerable.

    These days I wear a barn coat. They are tough and sturdy and work much better at resisting tearing. I got mine from LL Bean. The one I have is available in a lined or unlined version to choose depending on how cold it is likely to be when you do your pruning work. Carthartt offers them, too. They call them chore coats. I heartily recommend a jacket of this type. I expect mine to last for the next 30 years. After that I think I'll cut way back on active gardening as I will then be in my 90's!

    Rosefolly

  • 6 years ago

    rosefolly I wear an OLD denim lined jacket and it's great, but a barn coat would be better in warmer weather! I love those thorns above. I think that's R. Om... Pteracantha. I've wanted that rose for a while just for the thorns. They glow like rubies in the light, but I don't think it's hardy around here. Everyone always seems to go on about New Dawn, but all the roses shown here look much worse. It must be the length of her canes that cause the problem. I much prefer these widely space thorns to the daggers of my only rugosa. I fell into it once dragging it down a hill and that was a lesson learned!

  • 6 years ago

    Alana, I can't say I bought any kind of special pair. I can't even recall where I purchased them, they're just a nice leather glove portion and then a long sleeve made with the harder material. They may not last that long but since I had only ever used normal gloves, having ones with longer sleeves has made a huge difference. I was getting so many scratches before hands that people were always asking me what happened haha.

  • 6 years ago

    Kim that wins thorniest from me. The ones that seem to grab are those ones with the hook shaped thorns. Those grab and hold on then you're snared u til you can wiggle free.


    I had a fall into a climber a few months ago. It scratched up an arm and a leg pretty badly. It made me think about wearing eye protection. I should have had my heavy gloves too. Thank goodness for denim.

  • 6 years ago

    I'm glad you're OK, Kitty!

  • 6 years ago

    Definitely wear eye protection or at least a cap with a visor. I hope you are okay.

  • 6 years ago

    in china, most people don't have garden or yards to plant roses, the thorns are not functional for us at all in balcony, so we hate thorny roses╮(╯_╰)╭

  • 6 years ago

    for me New Dawn commands respect and Pioneer Spirit, Sombruile. But-- several others even Mrs BR Cant, Lavender Crush, Jasmine, can do significant damage to the flesh.

  • 6 years ago

    When we first moved here there was not a back fence, so we naively planted the very thorny, reputedly highly fragrant, Nova Zembla, a blush white sport of the pink Conrad F. Meyer hybrid rugosa. It is a monster, with very thick10' to 12' canes loaded with big and little thorns sharper than the sharpest razor wire, with blooms at the tippy top.

    We quickly realized that, like a loaded gun, this plant was much more of a danger to ourselves than to any possible intruder, especially since our garden is only 20' wide, and we got rid of it.

    Nova Zembla (New Land), comprising two islands, incidentally, is the north-easternmost place in Russia, and the name, I read somewhere, has come to signify in popular parlance, "the ends of the earth". I think it might be best grown there, or in Alaska.

    Years ago the Brooklyn Botanic Garden used to have several specimens planted near the entrance of its Rose Garden and pruned to an inch of their lives (that is to say, to about five feet).

    This blog writer, by the way, says that Conrad F. Meyer (and NZ presumably) are among the few thorny roses whose vicious thorns actually repel deer -- but so does dynamite, probably. He also says, mirabile dictu, that it is not very vigorous when competing with grass.
    https://kansasgardenmusings.blogspot.com/2014/08/conrad-ferdinand-meyer.html