Software
Houzz Logo Print
bwv_988

smoke-proof a room

6 years ago

I have to remodel a room in my house for a family member who's a chain smoker. I am thinking of porcelain/marble floor or hardwood floor with some rubber underneath to prevent the cigarette odor from spreading through the house. What kind of paint would you also recommend to seal the walls and ceiling? Any good recommendation for smoker eater system?

Comments (10)

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I am sorry your family member is addicted to nicotine. But, that is his/her problem, not yours. It sounds as if you are providing housing, which is generous on your part. The smoker’s part should be not to smoke in your home. There is no way you can contain the odor. The permanent damage to the room will impact either your resale value or your wallet when you have to renovate the room.

    I suppose you could replace a window with a door accessing a small deck and chair, but you will still smell the smoke.


    I had a friend who smoked only in one room, with windows open, air-fresher at full strength. When she quit smoking and washed down the room (and everything in it), the room still had the odor, but you should have seem the ceiling! It was yellow with nicotine. Washed and repainted, she finally had to have it skim coated to mask odor remaining.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Unless you create a bank vault, with its own self contained HVAC, this is doomed to failure. The smoke will go throughout the house, because it will seep through the pores of the paint, through the gaps in the trim, through the electrical plates, and through the duct work that connects the room to the rest of the house.

  • 6 years ago

    If money is no object, feel free to treat this room like a hospital room. Ensure you have a top-notch ceiling extraction unit that pumps out to the roof (just like the ventilation in a bathroom). And then you use exterior doors that have all-weather seals that prevent air from escaping.


    And you want to ensure the fresh air return in the house is blocked and you have a fresh air supply in the room that is separate from the rest of the house.


    You can create negative pressure in the room compared to the rest of the house (like in a hospital isolation room). This would be equal to building an entire addition. Depending on where you live this type of system should run several tens of thousands...possible $100K or more.


    How much do you want to keep this room sealed?

  • 6 years ago

    It gets into the material within the walls. The wood. Also, if this family member is so infirm, he/she can’t go somewhere else (or quit their habit), then there isn’t much care or respect for you, is there.

    Id be worried about that person causing a fire. I’d be worried about me and the rest of the family developing lung conditions, allergies, sensitivities, and general misery from seeing it and smelling it.

    When my kids were little, and everyone was afraid of my MIL, it was down to me to tell her she can’t even smoke in my backyard, because I don’t want the kids seeing it, and I don’t want my neighbors to smell it. I grew a backbone that day.

    I recommend standing up yourself and having enough respect for this person’s ability to alter the behavior. It’s possible, because lots of people have done it. Your relative can do it too.

  • 6 years ago

    Can this family member stick his or head out the window while smoking? That’s what I did when I was a teenager. :)

    If not, a small covered/semi-enclosed balcony or patio that can be heated and cooled, connected to that person’s room, would be your best bet.

  • 6 years ago

    Thank you all for your thoughtful answers. I think it would better for me to renovate an accessory structure and turn into an MIL unit.

  • 6 years ago

    The family member has mental illness. There's no way to get him/her to quit smoking. We did try many times in the past.

  • 6 years ago

    I agree, if you have another structure, that would be the best place for this person to be, unfortunately.

  • 4 years ago

    If you haven't already (since I see that this was a year ago), I would invest in a high quality air purifier such as IQ Air HealthproPlus or similar. Keep that in the room with the person who smokes and have it running all the time. I've recently seen that they have improved their model so that it is quieter than the one I have (many years old now and still working well). That way, the smoke will go through the air purifier first and not the rest of the house. - it's best when right next to the air purifier, of course, but it will be your best option. I would still also have the same air purifiers in the rest of the house, but it's best to catch the smoke at the source.