Well, personally, I'd stay away from the super dark color. I think it would be too much with the dark brick and black shutters. Exciting to be doing a project like this!

Thank you! The siding is on an enclosed sunroom and nowhere else.

I would choose the top one to go with the brick but what about your roof? Can you post a picture of the entire home?

this is with direct sun in the afternoon (plus I added 2 colors at the top)

I like the off white-creamy color with that dark red brick (we have houses in our neighborhood with that red brick). Not knowing what your roof color is, a neutral color like this should work as well!