Your house is adorable! I think the Enzian Blue for the shutters and the door looks very nice. You can then add some touches of it on your porch with flowers, pots, chairs, etc.

I like the blue on the shutters and the door, second choice is the goldenrod door with nightfall shutters. You could also take the shutters off, just an option

Red brick, white trim and blue or black shutters is classic. I’d do a red red front door.

I like blue, but I think I'd choose a bit of a brighter blue, and a fresh coat of white trim.

Thanks everyone! Here are a couple of the ideas that were suggested:

Red door, blue shutters (could also do navy shutters but it's not an option on this simulator)

Goldenrod door, black shutters (also wondering about navy shutters with this option...)

Lighter "Geneva blue." There isn't a brighter option than this -- but again, we could just get white and paint it ourselves!

Here is one color I keep wondering about for the door if we were to paint ourselves, but now I wonder if it's not bold enough:

Great little house! The storm door should disappear so that the door itself is the focal point.

I‘ve attached a pic of board and batten shutters, but don’t think they are appropriate for the style of your house.

You have many color choices, and I’m sure you’ll get more suggestions on this site. Be sure to post “after” pics!

I like the yellow door with the black shutters, but whatever color door you do, get the storm door to match. I have seen this done and it looks much better.

Also power wash the foundation if possible.

We definitely need to power wash!! And I wondered about the idea of getting the storm door to match, but though it might look nicer with white like the trim so the door is "framed" and pops more. No? We definitely want to keep the storm door though. I know it would look much better without one, but we often leave the door open and pull the screen down on the storm door and want to be able to continue doing that.

The color of the front door will make much more of a statement if the storm door matches. I figured you wanted the storm door for ventilation.

Yes, definitely get a storm door to match. The Enzian Blue is nice, or the yellow door with black shutters. Stacey's suggestion of black planters/yellow flowers would be nice.