Software
Houzz Logo Print
michele_chinichian

Help! Urgent wainscot + window dilemma

6 years ago





Hello! This is my first Houzz post.


We poured up the concrete flooring in our formal living room (6 inches). As a result, the wall area below the window is small with not much room to work with and this is what our contractor decided to do. See the first 2 photos for the “before” and the 3rd photo for the “after.”


Is the woodwork underneath this large window odd looking now? I kind of think so but I am not sure if I am overthinking it. I've always found this area below the window (even beforehand) kind of awkward.


The "dividers" underneath the window create very narrow “boxes” or openings below it. They are in the same length as the wainscoting that surrounds the room.


Options:

  1. We could remove the dividers, so it is one long, narrow rectangular opening of wall.
  2. Fill in the “openings/boxes” for a way too high wooden baseboard effect that is not consistent with the base of the surrounding wainscot, however this option may blend in better as a whole.
  3. Our contractor thinks what he did looks really cool with all the wood detail but is happy to change it, is he right?
  4. Something else? Not sure what the best option is for this tiny space? We will not have furniture covering this window. The entire room will be painted white.

I want this area to blend in with the rest of the room well. One possible concern with filling it in with woodwork up to the window casing is the joint may not be flush, our window casing juts out somewhat (unlike windows that have a sill where this may not matter as much).


I appreciate any feedback! We have to let him know asap! Thank you sooo much Houzz!

Comments (17)

  • 6 years ago

    I don't think it looks odd, and would leave it.

    Michele thanked Sammie J
  • 6 years ago

    Thank you. Our designer who is stuck out of the country b/c of the virus, really does not like the dividers. However, none of us can really see it in person b/c we are self-sheltering so who knows! I do appreciate the responses so far!

  • 6 years ago

    Here are a few more photos in case it persuades you one way or the other. I am leaning towards removing the dividers and just leaving it as a little wall area underneath. Thank you again for your help on this!


  • 6 years ago



  • 6 years ago

    With those pics, I think you are right ... remove them

    Michele thanked Sammie J
  • 6 years ago

    remove them vs fill it in?

  • 6 years ago

    Yes...now I think remove them (or fill them in). It really is a small detail in a lovely room.

    Michele thanked Mrs. S
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    thank you! another designer friend said she loved them and to keep them, aaargh! wish I could see this in person. thanks again for the feedback, it helped a lot!

  • 6 years ago

    Technically it’s correct. Visually it looks wrong. Adding those little pieces is like trying to keep the detail that used to be there prior to enlarging the window. With the now large window this section of the wall is all about the window, not the wainscoting. If you leave the detail (the short vertical pieces) visually it looks like you’re trying to squeeze in wainscoting and a huge window. Let it be one thing (window) or the other thing (wainscoting) but not both. Remove those little pieces.

    Michele thanked User
  • PRO
    6 years ago

    The woodwork in the room is fabulous! I'd remove those tiny pieces below the window--they are too busy with all the window grids. Then paint the entire room the same color for a sophisticated and cohesive look.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    I don’t think the window is larger they raised the floor 6” I find the grids in the windows much less attractive than the little bits below the window but now I would remove them . Such a pretty room and then you added carpet ugh.

    Michele thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 6 years ago

    @patr macd I believe you are looking at the "before" photos. we removed the carpet, filled in the sunken living room (hence the new problem under the window) and will be adding wood flooring. thank you!



  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    The windows look to be true divided lights--I suspect the home is quite old--so you cannot remove the muntins. They are perfectly appropriate with the millwork in the room. Unless they're not--what say you Michele?

    And yes, the carpet was removed! Wood floors will look smashing in that room!

    Michele thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    @Diana Bier Interiors, LLC Yes this post is not about the muntins, they can not be removed. This is about the 3 small partitions/dividers of wood below the window that is trying to keep consistent with the surrounding wainscot. Should we remove them and leave a small open wall area? Or fill it up with one long piece of wood underneath the window? I have better photos of this area in the thread. Thanks!

  • 6 years ago

    I like the little dividers and I think a piece of wood straight across would look good also. Now to make up my mind, I would ask...which would be easiest to keep dusted/clean? With your furnishings and curtains/drapes, you will not even notice the end result. Good job so far.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Yes as I said previously I’d remove the little dividers and just paint the area